Malak,
Just some highlights I'm gonna hit.
1. Switzerland - Lots of guns. Very, very little crime.
The swiss are much less of a 'whup your ass, yee haa' sort of people. They are very subdued. Essentially it's completely different culture who are more responsible. difficult to compare really. It's like comparing thai people to iraqis.
1a. The mere presence of guns does not create crimes nor criminals.
It helps though.
2. Gun violence in the US has gone down in the past decade.
Interesting point. Why has this happened? Much, much, stricter policing because of 9/11 or because more people have guns?
3. Gun violence in the UK has gone up in the past decade.
It was very low before hand so a couple of deaths per year is statistically going to be a much higher jump that it really is. Secondly, yeah, there are more gun crimes, but do you think it would go down if everyone was armed? I'd rather see tighter border control and policing. It's like handing everyone a knife as they get onto a plane in the airport just in case some criminal has smuggled on a weapon. It's an absolutley stupid idea.
3a. Gun laws in the UK have never been stricter.
Yet they need to be stricter still. Interestingly you can go shooting in england, but you keep your weapons in a safe at the club. That way little jonny doesn't blow his brains out, and dodgy dave doesn't manage to commit suicide. Three months later, after some councelling and dave is reformed and no longer suicidal. Great news
3b. Guns are being smuggled in by gangs and much of the violence is drug related
Tighter border controls required
4. In the US 90% of guns used to commit crimes were obtained illegally
ALL of them smuggled in? Nope. Many stolen from people. Having guns in circulation, despite being owned by nice (always stable) good clean americans, adds to gun crime.
4a. Of that 90% only about 10% were stolen (either from a store or from a private residence)
Source please. So, you could effectively reduce gun crimes by 10% if people had to keep their weapons in safes at a local armory/gun club.
5. Gun crime (as well as most crime) is largely a symptom of socioeconomic problems. Wanna lower the crime rates? Address the source of the problem, not the symptom.
Yeah... 'guns don't kill people, people do.'. Thing is.... the gun does kinda help though, doesn't it?
As for the home defense needing a gun thing. What's that about other than modern US paranoia? Are these people trying to rob you? In which case they'll not bother risking their lives and will simply wait until you're out. You'll arrive home, realise you've been robbed, and your guns are missing. You'll have a little cry about it, then buy a bigger gun 'for next time'.
Are these people breaking into your house for some kind of revenge? Why wouldn't they just kill you on the street, or ring your doorbell and cap you when you open it?
Are they just mental and are trying to kill you for the sake of it? Well best of luck to you. Personally, if that's the reason I'm buying a gun, I'd rather put some armour on my door and better locks. You think having a gun fight is a better defense than sitting in an armoured, locked room? Also, do you sleep with the gun under your pillow or something? If not, this mysterious intruder who's decided to randomly attack you will certainly have the element of suprise. good luck to you and your family as you unlock your gun from the cabinate as some nutcase is spraying bullets through your stud walls.
Essentially, the argument for 'home defense' is a weak one. Who really is going to break into your home at night and come upstairs to try and kill you? Paranoid much?
Bottom line. It's a penis thing. "Hua! lets go shoot some sh!t! hell yeah! woo!"
Just some highlights I'm gonna hit.
1. Switzerland - Lots of guns. Very, very little crime.
The swiss are much less of a 'whup your ass, yee haa' sort of people. They are very subdued. Essentially it's completely different culture who are more responsible. difficult to compare really. It's like comparing thai people to iraqis.
1a. The mere presence of guns does not create crimes nor criminals.
It helps though.
2. Gun violence in the US has gone down in the past decade.
Interesting point. Why has this happened? Much, much, stricter policing because of 9/11 or because more people have guns?
3. Gun violence in the UK has gone up in the past decade.
It was very low before hand so a couple of deaths per year is statistically going to be a much higher jump that it really is. Secondly, yeah, there are more gun crimes, but do you think it would go down if everyone was armed? I'd rather see tighter border control and policing. It's like handing everyone a knife as they get onto a plane in the airport just in case some criminal has smuggled on a weapon. It's an absolutley stupid idea.
3a. Gun laws in the UK have never been stricter.
Yet they need to be stricter still. Interestingly you can go shooting in england, but you keep your weapons in a safe at the club. That way little jonny doesn't blow his brains out, and dodgy dave doesn't manage to commit suicide. Three months later, after some councelling and dave is reformed and no longer suicidal. Great news
3b. Guns are being smuggled in by gangs and much of the violence is drug related
Tighter border controls required
4. In the US 90% of guns used to commit crimes were obtained illegally
ALL of them smuggled in? Nope. Many stolen from people. Having guns in circulation, despite being owned by nice (always stable) good clean americans, adds to gun crime.
4a. Of that 90% only about 10% were stolen (either from a store or from a private residence)
Source please. So, you could effectively reduce gun crimes by 10% if people had to keep their weapons in safes at a local armory/gun club.
5. Gun crime (as well as most crime) is largely a symptom of socioeconomic problems. Wanna lower the crime rates? Address the source of the problem, not the symptom.
Yeah... 'guns don't kill people, people do.'. Thing is.... the gun does kinda help though, doesn't it?
As for the home defense needing a gun thing. What's that about other than modern US paranoia? Are these people trying to rob you? In which case they'll not bother risking their lives and will simply wait until you're out. You'll arrive home, realise you've been robbed, and your guns are missing. You'll have a little cry about it, then buy a bigger gun 'for next time'.
Are these people breaking into your house for some kind of revenge? Why wouldn't they just kill you on the street, or ring your doorbell and cap you when you open it?
Are they just mental and are trying to kill you for the sake of it? Well best of luck to you. Personally, if that's the reason I'm buying a gun, I'd rather put some armour on my door and better locks. You think having a gun fight is a better defense than sitting in an armoured, locked room? Also, do you sleep with the gun under your pillow or something? If not, this mysterious intruder who's decided to randomly attack you will certainly have the element of suprise. good luck to you and your family as you unlock your gun from the cabinate as some nutcase is spraying bullets through your stud walls.
Essentially, the argument for 'home defense' is a weak one. Who really is going to break into your home at night and come upstairs to try and kill you? Paranoid much?
Bottom line. It's a penis thing. "Hua! lets go shoot some sh!t! hell yeah! woo!"