• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

detroit pistons are so overrated.

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: hans007
well i said if you were starting a new team.

the all star game is not a showcase of best team. it is called the all "STAR" team. stars tend to be individuals. i didnt even say that the pistons were not the best team. they are just being hyped up as this great team and it is even probable that they lose to the spurs again. no one is hyping up the spurs right now, and definitely not the mavs. that is why the pistons are OVERRATED.

horrible logic.
the pistons have the best record in the NBA and it's no stretch to call them the best team right now. it's not hype. the statistics show that the pistons have won the most in the NBA. how is that over hype?

i also didn't say i'd definitely take gil , redd or howard over ben wallace as he is probably actually an allstar. but rip and rasheed are probably the 2 you dont build a team around and are never really game changers.

funny because Detroit built around them and look where they are now. remind me never to hire you as an NBA GM.

you guys are actually saying if you had an expansion team, and the only persons available were dwight howard or rasheed wallace you'd take rasheed? or if the only 2 players available were rip hamilton or gilbert arenas you'd take rip?
are you in crack?

a MAJORITY of the coaches in the east are saying it. i guess they're on crack. hans007 is the only logical one here, guys. he's got so much more credibility than NBA coaches who DID choose Rasheed over Dwight and Rip over Arenas.

DON'T get me wrong. Arenas and Howard are studs and are young. no one's saying they're without tons of talent. but all-star snubs happen every year.
 
a MAJORITY of the coaches in the east are saying it. i guess they're on crack. hans007 is the only logical one here, guys. he's got so much more credibility than NBA coaches who DID choose Rasheed over Dwight and Rip over Arenas.

that doesnt mean anything...the nba is so messed up in certain things. the allstars should be based just on stats...what the fvck does it have to do with how the team is doing. It is an individual accomplisment. Its the only time that individual achievement comes above team achievement. I don't want to see rip taking 18 footers in the allstar game nor do i want to see rasheed take 6 3's. I wanna see vince throw down, I want see ridiculous stuff that doesnt happen in a game. THere is something in the NBA for good teams and team players...its called the playoffs. leave this sh1t for the playoffs and let the best players run the allstar weekend

anyway i like the pistons and it'll be real interesting how the end of the season turns out.
 
Originally posted by: Inspector Jihad
that doesnt mean anything...the nba is so messed up in certain things. the allstars should be based just on stats...what the fvck does it have to do with how the team is doing. It is an individual accomplisment.

that's not ideal either. if it were just down to stats, it'd basically be a fantasy basketball team.

for anyone who knows about fantasy basketball, the All-Star starters would be: Andre Kirilenko, Shawn Marion, and Brad Miller.
 
Originally posted by: nateholtrop
Originally posted by: hans007
and they lost to atlanta for god sakes. not to mention utah TWICE.

....and blew out the spurs twice.

funny how the OP conveniently forgot that the Spurs and Mavs have lost to the Hawks and Knicks. :laugh:
 
Originally posted by: dafatha00
I think the Pistons are definitely the elite team in the league this year and I'm a Lakers fan.

That being said, Pistons fans are punks.

You are just angry over how the Pistons pretty much swept you guys in 04 save a lucky shot from Kobe at the end of I believe game 3.
 
Originally posted by: nateholtrop
Originally posted by: dafatha00
I think the Pistons are definitely the elite team in the league this year and I'm a Lakers fan.

That being said, Pistons fans are punks.

You are just angry over how the Pistons pretty much swept you guys in 04 save a lucky shot from Kobe at the end of I believe game 3.

no, no. he'll undoubtedly bring into argument the palace brawl and make sweeping generalizations about pistons fans, detroit citizens, and michigan people.
 
A few items...

Stop defending Piston losses with "it was their 3rd game in 4 nights", or "last game of a roadtrip". The Pistons are the best team in the NBA - they are not going to win every game, however, and you don't need to find excuses for their losses, nothing to be defensive about when they lose a game.

Rasheed Wallace is not having an all-star season by any standard. I'm not saying he's not a good player, I'm simply saying that he's not having a great season at all. Someone said earlier that Rip Hamilton shouldn't be an all-star, that he's an overrated player - that person should not be allowed to watch another NBA game, or post about the NBA on this forum. He's the best jump shooter in the league, probably the best conditioned athlete in the NBA, and a tough defender as well. B.Wallace and Billups are also shoo-ins for the All-star team this year.

Dallas is pretty good - this isn't the same no-D Dallas team that we've seen in past years, and their depth and versatility are going to cause problems for anyone they face in the playoffs this year, West or East.

The Suns only hope is that Amare comes back 100%, which I don't think is likely. They have no post defense at all without him and have no chance of beating SA without Amare.

I'm not sold on the West dominance against the East though. After SA, Dallas, and the Suns, no one in the West is overly impressive. In the East you have the Pistons, Heat, Cavs, and Nets - and despite the Cavs & Nets records being less than the Suns' record, head to head I don't see a lot of difference in the quality of those teams.

I think the difference is more at the bottom of the standings - the bad teams in the East - DO YOU HEAR ME KNICK FANBOIS? are much worse than the bad teams in the West, but I'm not sure you can tell me how great the West is when the Hornets are a playoff team in the West, and I don't think they are any better than the Boston/Chicago/Milwaukee/Wizards in the East, and I'd say pretty much the same for the Grizzlies (congrats to Gasol on the All-star team, he's tough) and the Jazz/Lakers teams that are fighting for playoff spots.
 
Originally posted by: NeoV
Someone said earlier that Rip Hamilton shouldn't be an all-star, that he's an overrated player - that person should not be allowed to watch another NBA game, or post about the NBA on this forum. He's the best jump shooter in the league, probably the best conditioned athlete in the NBA, and a tough defender as well.

just to add to Rip's accolades this season:

http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/players/3330

look at this percentages. granted, Rip's been getting his share of layups with Flip's more open offense, his %'s are gaudy: 49.9% FG, 44.6% 3pt, 86.5% FT. shooting 50% at the 2-guard position is phenomenal. only Tony Parker trumps that with an unbelievable 55%FG shooting. but TP can't touch Rip's 3pt and FT percentages.

one could make arugment that he might be the best all around shooter in the NBA.

 
Originally posted by: eelw
Originally posted by: hans007
it will be hillarious watching all the sports casters who love them die when say dallas beats them.

Yeah right, whatever. The Mavs are not even getting past the Spurs or Suns to even get a chance at the Pistons. Dream on there bud.

Yeah, because the Spurs own the Mavs... Oh wait.
103-84 Mavs
92-90 Spurs

So it's gotta be the Suns... Oh wait.
111-108 Mavs
102-96 Mavs

Detroit the "only other elite team" for comparison.
94-88 (preseason) Mavs
103-97 (preseason) Mavs
119-82 Mavs
 
as a pistons fan, the mavs honestly scare me more than the Spurs do right now. the last few times the spurs and pistons played, the spurs looked "old". the mavs are so athletic, young, deep, and now they play some good defense. if they get hot in the playoffs, i wouldn't bet against them making their first Finals appearance.
 
Originally posted by: Phoenix86
Originally posted by: eelw
Originally posted by: hans007
it will be hillarious watching all the sports casters who love them die when say dallas beats them.

Yeah right, whatever. The Mavs are not even getting past the Spurs or Suns to even get a chance at the Pistons. Dream on there bud.

Yeah, because the Spurs own the Mavs... Oh wait.
103-84 Mavs
92-90 Spurs

So it's gotta be the Suns... Oh wait.
111-108 Mavs
102-96 Mavs

Detroit the "only other elite team" for comparison.
94-88 (preseason) Mavs
103-97 (preseason) Mavs
119-82 Mavs

You really think either the Mavs or Suns have a chance against the Spurs in a best of 7? Dream on. Neither Dallas or Phoenix has the defense to win championships like the Spurs or Pistons.
 
Originally posted by: iamme
hans007 do some research before you make claims, mmkay?

here are the records through 45 games:

pistons played: 22 east, 23 west teams (39-6)
san antonio: 22 east, 23 west (35-10)
dallas: 17 east, 28 west (35-10)

the pistons have played MORE WEST COAST teams than eastern teams. nice try though. overrated, lol:

3 straight eastern conference finals
2 straight nba finals
1 nba championship (almost back to back....i know almost doesn't cut it, but they were damn close to doing something not many have done in nba history)
and this season, they've flirted with the best record in nba history

how's that overrated?


It's already been shown that they have the 6th easiest strength of schedule.
http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/stats/rpi?season=2006&sortColumn=sos
 
Originally posted by: nateholtrop
Originally posted by: dafatha00
I think the Pistons are definitely the elite team in the league this year and I'm a Lakers fan.

That being said, Pistons fans are punks.

You are just angry over how the Pistons pretty much swept you guys in 04 save a lucky shot from Kobe at the end of I believe game 3.

Nah, Pistons deserved to win that year too. I told you Pistons are good.
 
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: nateholtrop
Originally posted by: dafatha00
I think the Pistons are definitely the elite team in the league this year and I'm a Lakers fan.

That being said, Pistons fans are punks.

You are just angry over how the Pistons pretty much swept you guys in 04 save a lucky shot from Kobe at the end of I believe game 3.

no, no. he'll undoubtedly bring into argument the palace brawl and make sweeping generalizations about pistons fans, detroit citizens, and michigan people.

You got it guy 😉
 
i agree about your comments about the all star game. arenas not making the team is just pathetic, especially when pieces of garbage like yao ming get the start.
 
Originally posted by: Kev
i agree about your comments about the all star game. arenas not making the team is just pathetic, especially when pieces of garbage like yao ming get the start.

Poor argument. All-Star starters are voted in by the fans as they are the ones that are the most popular. That's the very essence of the All-Star game.

Notwithstanding this obvious fact, you're comparing two completely different positions in two different conferences. You should be angered by the fact that players like Hamilton were voted in over Arenas.

For the sake of argument, who would you vote in to the All-Star game over Yao and why?
 
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: Phoenix86

Detroit the "only other elite team" for comparison.
94-88 (preseason) Mavs
103-97 (preseason) Mavs
119-82 Mavs

lol@the preseason games. Detroit's bench almost played the entire game vs. the Mav's starters in those game. but like i said above, the mavs are a solid team, imo.

Just listed for completeness (only 1 game played during regular), also why I noted preseason games. 😉

I'm sure the Mavs didn't play everyone either, but I didn't watch the games... Really it's a moot point given the regular season blowout.

Originally posted by: eelw
You really think either the Mavs or Suns have a chance against the Spurs in a best of 7? Dream on. Neither Dallas or Phoenix has the defense to win championships like the Spurs or Pistons.

😕
You know I posted this year's record against those teams for a reason... It was to prevent this type of reply.

*head+wall*
*repeats*

They alread beat those teams, so of course it can be done. Only a truely ignorant person could say otherwise.

Dallas handed the Pistons their ass in the regular season game (119-82).

Can they do it? Of course.
Will they do it? I'm not a fortune teller. Yeah, I'm the one dreaming here...
 
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: Inspector Jihad
that doesnt mean anything...the nba is so messed up in certain things. the allstars should be based just on stats...what the fvck does it have to do with how the team is doing. It is an individual accomplisment.

that's not ideal either. if it were just down to stats, it'd basically be a fantasy basketball team.

for anyone who knows about fantasy basketball, the All-Star starters would be: Andre Kirilenko, Shawn Marion, and Brad Miller.

whadday know...all three of them have been allstars :Q:Q:Q

vince hitting a jumper or putting his crotch in someones face while dunking would be the same two points in fantasy ball, but i have a feeling one would be much more fun to watch.

Look, I know you are a pistons fan, but stop being delusional. Unless you are a fanboi, in that case, continue your stupidity.
 
Of the 3 or 4 best teams in the league, the Pistons are number 1 right now regardless of recent losses.

All teams go through some sort of slumpt during a season. I am a spurs fan and I watched them play 2 injury riddled games against the pistons. Losing both. If you are a basketball fan you know that. Could the spurs beat them at full strength, probably. However Ginobli isn't playing very well this season, so someone has to make up for that lack of output.

Dallas is overrated. I said it, and I meant it. They can go hot or cold and when they are hot... damn, but when they are cold.... DAMN!

I think the east has a better chance of having another team come through than the west. Right now, Kobe can score 50 and lose, phoenix isn't even competetive with the big leaguers, and the rest of the field is weak. San Antonio vs. Dallas in the 2nd round of the playoffs may decide the west. In the east, hopefully miami can play together to give the Pistons a run for their money.
 
Back
Top