Originally posted by: TheUnk
It's far from a button masher. If you know what you are doing, a button masher will rarely ever win against you. It's an excellent game, assuming you liked the DOA series, if you didn't - DON'T BUY THIS ONE.
Also, visually it's hard to tell a difference (except for the fighting environments) unless you have a decent HDTV.
in story mode you can button mash your way thorugh the end guy like nothing.
story mode in this game is totally horrible and the only reason i'm doing it is because i have to in order to unlock chars/outfits.
online play is great, i will agree. so far most matches haven't been too laggy, but when they are, the game is just retarded.
ovreall:
pros: graphics are great, animation is good (though everything seems to clip into cloths when it should have collision detection on the cloths). online play against real people is cool, playing fields are even (when it isn't lagging like hell)
cons: story mode just blows, all single player aspects suck except the sparring mode when you can practice against the CPU in different modes (including standing still). this is very helpful. one huge con is that the computer counters just about every single damned thing you do and will destroy you in the process. i am only able to land about 10% of the counters i actually try for because the computer is so fast and the window is so small. most of the time they end up countering my counter (because i'm trying to counter their move they just did and the window is way over, leaving me open).
my final bug about the game is the counter/blocking system. the ONLY way you can counter/block a move is if you match if the attack is high medium or low. it is VERY hard to tell due to the graphics being so good and the motions being so fluid. most of the time you just have to guess and you really don't know if the attach that was landed was medium/high/low.
bottom line - single player blows, xbox live is thumbs up. while i can't say if the high reviews this has been getting is due to the online aspect only, i sure cant see them from the single player game vs. the cpu.
i'd give it an 8.0/10