Close call...

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

RedArmy

Platinum Member
Mar 1, 2005
2,648
0
0
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: lokiju
I'm sure others on here will disagree but if someone is breaking into my house, they deserve to die.

They are invading my home and potentially putting my life and my families life at risk.

There is no "oh maybe he just needed to steal something for money so he could provide for his family" bullshit. If I need more money I work more.

Just my $00.02.

until it's just a drunk that walked up to the wrong house.

Yes. What if he just had the wrong house? I think evidence of that is when the light came on and he was not fazed. He believed someone he lived with had gotten up upon hearing him.

A real burglar, upon a light coming on, would have not stuck around to hear you say "Get lost or I'll shoot".

Thus, you might have killed an innocent man.

I doubt it. He said "I ran into the kitchen and the molding around the frame near the dead bolt is starting to crack". That's the last thing I think a drunk person would be doing. You have to go into that situation with some sort of malicious intent to start doing something like that.
 

oiprocs

Diamond Member
Jun 20, 2001
3,780
2
0
Originally posted by: RedArmy
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: lokiju
I'm sure others on here will disagree but if someone is breaking into my house, they deserve to die.

They are invading my home and potentially putting my life and my families life at risk.

There is no "oh maybe he just needed to steal something for money so he could provide for his family" bullshit. If I need more money I work more.

Just my $00.02.

until it's just a drunk that walked up to the wrong house.

Yes. What if he just had the wrong house? I think evidence of that is when the light came on and he was not fazed. He believed someone he lived with had gotten up upon hearing him.

A real burglar, upon a light coming on, would have not stuck around to hear you say "Get lost or I'll shoot".

Thus, you might have killed an innocent man.

I doubt it. He said "I ran into the kitchen and the molding around the frame near the dead bolt is starting to crack". That's the last thing I think a drunk person would be doing. You have to go into that situation with some sort of malicious intent to start doing something like that.

Ok, point taken, but what about the light? What kind of intruder thinks a light turning on is nothing to worry about?
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Ok, point taken, but what about the light? What kind of intruder thinks a light turning on is nothing to worry about?

A determined or desperate one.
 

Proprioceptive

Golden Member
Feb 27, 2006
1,630
10
81
Originally posted by: spidey07
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Ok, point taken, but what about the light? What kind of intruder thinks a light turning on is nothing to worry about?

A determined or desperate one.

This is the only thing that really had me confused about the situation. Why WOULD he keep going if the light came on? For clarification, it was the kitchen light I turned on and not the outside light. Apparently (after all of this had happened) I found out that both back and front outside lights had burnt out that day. Talk about bad timing...
 

pstylesss

Platinum Member
Mar 21, 2007
2,914
0
0
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Originally posted by: joutlaw
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive
Originally posted by: lokiju
I'm sure others on here will disagree but if someone is breaking into my house, they deserve to die.

They are invading my home and potentially putting my life and my families life at risk.

There is no "oh maybe he just needed to steal something for money so he could provide for his family" bullshit. If I need more money I work more.

Just my $00.02.

Believe me, if he'd stood there for 1 more second I would have shot him. Castle law FTW!

I agree 100%.

The Castle Law has come into play in the news here. You need to understand the law before you use it. My understanding is that a felony has to be in the act on your property in order to use the castle law. So at your door would that constitute tresspassing or breaking and entering.

I don't know, the gun did exactly what it was supposed to do: scare off the intruder such that he leaves and you don't have to fire the gun.

I think everyone would hope for a situation like this, where just showing the gun resolves the situation.

Chambering a shotgun is a pretty intimidating sound, if it's not enough to scare off the would be intruder, they deserve to get it.
 

Proprioceptive

Golden Member
Feb 27, 2006
1,630
10
81
Originally posted by: joutlaw
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive
Originally posted by: lokiju
I'm sure others on here will disagree but if someone is breaking into my house, they deserve to die.

They are invading my home and potentially putting my life and my families life at risk.

There is no "oh maybe he just needed to steal something for money so he could provide for his family" bullshit. If I need more money I work more.

Just my $00.02.

Believe me, if he'd stood there for 1 more second I would have shot him. Castle law FTW!

I agree 100%.

The Castle Law has come into play in the news here. You need to understand the law before you use it. My understanding is that a felony has to be in the act on your property in order to use the castle law. So at your door would that constitute tresspassing or breaking and entering.

According to the castle law here in Missouri, even if it is just trespassing, and it is clear that this person is trespassing, you can claim your castle law rights. If you tell him to leave and he's running away and I shot him in the back as he ran, I could be persecuted. So, taking the shot right away would have been justified seeing as how he was using clear force to try and enter. If this was a guy who was just drunk and thought he was at his own place, then I'm not really sure how the law would handle it. But then again, how do you prove this?
 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Originally posted by: RedArmy

I doubt it. He said "I ran into the kitchen and the molding around the frame near the dead bolt is starting to crack". That's the last thing I think a drunk person would be doing. You have to go into that situation with some sort of malicious intent to start doing something like that.

at the same time a non-drunk would have just kicked the door in...if pushing on the door is cracking the molding though I'd seriously reframe it.
 

Proprioceptive

Golden Member
Feb 27, 2006
1,630
10
81
Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: RedArmy

I doubt it. He said "I ran into the kitchen and the molding around the frame near the dead bolt is starting to crack". That's the last thing I think a drunk person would be doing. You have to go into that situation with some sort of malicious intent to start doing something like that.

at the same time a non-drunk would have just kicked the door in...if pushing on the door is cracking the molding though I'd seriously reframe it.

Even better... we had the deadbolts replaced so that the bolt extends PAST the framing and into the wall. So much better.
 

Dead3ye

Platinum Member
Sep 21, 2000
2,917
1
81
Originally posted by: spidey07
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Ok, point taken, but what about the light? What kind of intruder thinks a light turning on is nothing to worry about?

A determined or desperate one.

Or one that was armed with an illegally acquired weapon that he would have gotten anyway even if guns were banned.

 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive
Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: RedArmy

I doubt it. He said "I ran into the kitchen and the molding around the frame near the dead bolt is starting to crack". That's the last thing I think a drunk person would be doing. You have to go into that situation with some sort of malicious intent to start doing something like that.

at the same time a non-drunk would have just kicked the door in...if pushing on the door is cracking the molding though I'd seriously reframe it.

Even better... we had the deadbolts replaced so that the bolt extends PAST the framing and into the wall. So much better.

A deadbolt only has so much throw...the stud is the best place for it to sit in...once it's past the stud into the 'wall' it's just in dead space. If your walls are only drywall it's not going to do much good anyway. Optimally you'd reinforce the stud with a steel receiver for the deadbolt.

Many doors I have seen have the bolt set too shallow and sometimes it's not even 'dead' and can be slid back easy. Also some are set to close to the edge of the stud, making for an easy kick in or pry out.
 

bob4432

Lifer
Sep 6, 2003
11,727
46
91
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive
Originally posted by: tranceport
Good Job.

I've done the same on one occasion while living in some apartments.

Figured this thread could use some pics. Here is the deterrent I used. http://tinyurl.com/d5wyqb

Nice! I am not too familiar with firearms myself, except the M-16A2 which I know like the back of my hand (enlisted), but I've recently gotten into educating myself a great deal. The shotgun I have is a model '48 Remington that was given to me by my late grandfather. RIP.

good job all the way around. why not pick up a ar15 that is a clone of your a2 that you have the familiarity and muscle memory with? you may have to do a little bit of searching w/ the current political climate, but there are still decent priced ones around if you look.

 

Pegun

Golden Member
Jan 18, 2004
1,334
0
71
In CT (And a few other states IIRC) Castle law applies after three steps. The three steps are to show the person has intent to harm you, your possessions or your family.
 

tefleming

Golden Member
Dec 1, 2003
1,128
0
0
Originally posted by: mugs
If you had shot him, it would have been easier to identify him.

Or if, as others have suggested, had your wife call the cops while you detained him at shotgun point so that he could go to jail.

A nice pic of you on the front page, shotgun in hand, as the cops are perp walking him past your house certainly would send a message.

Oh well, hindsight is always 20/20. Glad you and your family are okay. I'm also glad the intruder isn't dead.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
Originally posted by: Rubycon
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive

My wife HATES Family Guy... thinks it's inappropriate, but I think it's equal-opportunity hilarity. I told her what I was watching when this all happened and she sighed and says nothing when I watch it now. :D

Can't say I blame her. Characters with chins that look like a sack! :laugh:
They did of course make note of this once - Peter took off his chin with some surprise, "How's these get up there?" and placed them/it back down his pants.


And yes, it is quite inappropriate. But crude/dirty humor is simply more fun.
Though subtle, smarter humor, such as that perhaps found in Monty Python or Futurama can also be good. :)
Or the sign of a truly cultured viewing audience: MST3K


 

jamesbond007

Diamond Member
Dec 21, 2000
5,280
0
71
Originally posted by: tefleming
Or if, as others have suggested, had your wife call the cops while you detained him at shotgun point so that he could go to jail.

A nice pic of you on the front page, shotgun in hand, as the cops are perp walking him past your house certainly would send a message.

Oh well, hindsight is always 20/20. Glad you and your family are okay. I'm also glad the intruder isn't dead.

Could there ever be any negative repercussion to holding someone at gunpoint if they tried to break into your house? What if the guy tried to run away, but you maybe fired a warning shot to get him to stop so the police could jail the person? Is that legal?

Could you put someone at gunpoint if they entered your apartment (not just the building but the apartment you rent) without you opening the door? Say forced entrance or if they used a bump key to enter.

I'm definitely going to look up this "Castle Law", too! I am not a home-owning citizen yet, but these are things I need to look into.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,872
31,379
146
Originally posted by: Modular
Shoulda let the fucker open the door. Shoot right when his foot comes in the door.

two barrels of rock salt in the chest for added hilarity and pain that he'll have to live through.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,872
31,379
146
Originally posted by: oiprocs
Originally posted by: joutlaw
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive
Originally posted by: lokiju
I'm sure others on here will disagree but if someone is breaking into my house, they deserve to die.

They are invading my home and potentially putting my life and my families life at risk.

There is no "oh maybe he just needed to steal something for money so he could provide for his family" bullshit. If I need more money I work more.

Just my $00.02.

Believe me, if he'd stood there for 1 more second I would have shot him. Castle law FTW!

I agree 100%.

The Castle Law has come into play in the news here. You need to understand the law before you use it. My understanding is that a felony has to be in the act on your property in order to use the castle law. So at your door would that constitute tresspassing or breaking and entering.

I don't know, the gun did exactly what it was supposed to do: scare off the intruder such that he leaves and you don't have to fire the gun.

I think everyone would hope for a situation like this, where just showing the gun resolves the situation.

indeed.

sucks that OP didn't get a positive ID on the perp, though. While he did see the suspect at the station and will probably notice him in the future, I'd feel more comfortable knowing I could ID such a neighbor on the street knowing that they can certainly ID me.
 

SarcasticDwarf

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2001
9,574
2
76
Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: Proprioceptive
Originally posted by: alkemyst
Originally posted by: RedArmy

I doubt it. He said "I ran into the kitchen and the molding around the frame near the dead bolt is starting to crack". That's the last thing I think a drunk person would be doing. You have to go into that situation with some sort of malicious intent to start doing something like that.

at the same time a non-drunk would have just kicked the door in...if pushing on the door is cracking the molding though I'd seriously reframe it.

Even better... we had the deadbolts replaced so that the bolt extends PAST the framing and into the wall. So much better.

A deadbolt only has so much throw...the stud is the best place for it to sit in...once it's past the stud into the 'wall' it's just in dead space. If your walls are only drywall it's not going to do much good anyway. Optimally you'd reinforce the stud with a steel receiver for the deadbolt.

Many doors I have seen have the bolt set too shallow and sometimes it's not even 'dead' and can be slid back easy. Also some are set to close to the edge of the stud, making for an easy kick in or pry out.

All exterior doors should be set in steel frames. There are very few doors in the US that CAN'T be kicked in with just a couple of kicks. It is pathetic how much people think that doors can actually stop physical force.
 
Sep 29, 2004
18,656
68
91
Way to go:

1) get shotgun
2) call cops

GENIOUS!

I would have called the cops, let the guy break in and get his ass on the ground.
 
May 16, 2000
13,522
0
0
Originally posted by: jamesbond007
Originally posted by: tefleming
Or if, as others have suggested, had your wife call the cops while you detained him at shotgun point so that he could go to jail.

A nice pic of you on the front page, shotgun in hand, as the cops are perp walking him past your house certainly would send a message.

Oh well, hindsight is always 20/20. Glad you and your family are okay. I'm also glad the intruder isn't dead.

Could there ever be any negative repercussion to holding someone at gunpoint if they tried to break into your house? What if the guy tried to run away, but you maybe fired a warning shot to get him to stop so the police could jail the person? Is that legal?

Could you put someone at gunpoint if they entered your apartment (not just the building but the apartment you rent) without you opening the door? Say forced entrance or if they used a bump key to enter.

I'm definitely going to look up this "Castle Law", too! I am not a home-owning citizen yet, but these are things I need to look into.

It depends on the state, and the circumstances. I can tell you that even if it's actually legal you may have to fight a bit. When I caught two repeat thieves in our shed I held them at sword point till the cops arrived (it's what I had handy at the time). We got called to the courthouse about it and were threatened with charges by the Sheriff and prosecutor for what we'd done because I used a sword (but were told to use a gun in the future and there'd be no issue). The final disposition was that although no laws were broken by us, if we didn't drop all charges against the thieves the county was going after us anyway just to cost us money and make things difficult as a lesson. To this day I have no idea if it really was the use of sword to hold them, or if the thieves were somehow related to someone in power and it was all about getting them out of trouble. *shrug*

My bottom line is, live to be judged by your peers. I'll do whatever I have to in order to stay safe from harm.