Originally posted by: 3chordcharlie
No it isn't.
At a party-poker table (esp. play money) you can expect 1/3 hands to call all in preflop raises. Even AA isn't a lock to win against 2-3 random hands; neither is KK. The variance of the outcome is too high - you might be right to make the play at an open table, but not in an elimination tournament.
Actually my understanding of EV is quite good - I wouldn't have a problem playing that exact sequence at an open table.Originally posted by: amoeba
your understanding of EV is very bad. you want as many callers as you can get when you all in preflop with AA. sure, you'll only win 1/3 of the time but you win 9x your stack the times you do win.
and you can't use play money situations to define real money tourney play. I push 27o in play money to blow off steam, it doesn't mean I don't kill the real money games.
as to your statement about elimination touney, its even more correct in this case. blinds are 25/50. Hero has 1000 or so. he can only see a couple more cycles until he is blinded off. he gets KK and there is a preflop raiser to 250, 1/4 of his stack. if he reraises anything less than all in, he is pot committed anyways.
If he doesn't reraise and play his kings like trapping hand, he runs the risk of an ace flopping and either killing his action or causing him to fold. and judging by how short stacked the preflop raiser is, I think an all in will be called if preflop raiser had JJ, QQ, TT (hell, in the real example he called with KQo, talk about dominated).
The point is that hero will not find better chance to double up. reraise all in is definitely right move. This is not first hand of tourney. This is already well in to it.
Originally posted by: DBL
This reasoning kills me. You are advocating not playing certain dominating hands b/c the rest of your competition is reckless? Sure, you will take your share of bad beats but with competition like that, you would absolutely clean up way more than your fair share of time. Understand that in holdem, any one hand can beat another. It is your job to get all your money in the pot with the best hand. The rest is just luck. However, if you succeed in getting your money in with the best hand most of the time, you will be a profitable player.
Besides, are you telling me you wouldn't play as many tournaments as you could (assuming no single tournament would cripple your bankroll) where you are guaranteed AA every hand and where everybody moves all-in pre-flop?
Originally posted by: 3chordcharlie
Of course you play the hand - I'm just saying I rarely push all in preflop against reckless players. I might call the all in, late in the betting round.
As to your second question of course I would; that's not an option though.
Originally posted by: KMDupont64
Everyone is a poker expert, why doesn't everyone get in on an ATOT table and play each other.
Originally posted by: Legendary
Why is this hand noteworthy? Straights on the board are rare, yes, but not worth posting about methinks.
Originally posted by: amoeba
Originally posted by: KMDupont64
Everyone is a poker expert, why doesn't everyone get in on an ATOT table and play each other.
we play at different sites and different formats, limits. Besides, because we are discussing an actual situation, playing each other doesn't really examine whats the right play in this specific situation.
I am always happy to play against any ATOT players at NL 25 or NL50. nothing too big to sow bad feelings but big enough where winning still matters.
Originally posted by: Kev
all in with KK preflop that early is really dumb, you should at the most do a raise and then hope an ace doesn't pop up. on the flop & turn then you can really push it.
Originally posted by: KMDupont64
Originally posted by: amoeba
Originally posted by: KMDupont64
Everyone is a poker expert, why doesn't everyone get in on an ATOT table and play each other.
we play at different sites and different formats, limits. Besides, because we are discussing an actual situation, playing each other doesn't really examine whats the right play in this specific situation.
I am always happy to play against any ATOT players at NL 25 or NL50. nothing too big to sow bad feelings but big enough where winning still matters.
Playing each other will shut you up though. All talk, no play. He showed one hand, nothing about how the rest of the game was played. You don't play poker hand to hand. Play each other, and the winner can talk, the losers can continue to play nickle slots.
Originally posted by: Kev
all in with KK preflop that early is really dumb, you should at the most do a raise and then hope an ace doesn't pop up. on the flop & turn then you can really push it.
Originally posted by: purbeast0
so who's e-penis is the biggest in this thread?
seriously, there is NO CORRECT WAY TO PLAY POKER!! play how YOU want. sure there are "smarter" ways to play, which are smarter because you are playing the greater odds. but in the end, it is all down to luck and how you can read people. just have fun playing.
Originally posted by: DBL
Originally posted by: 3chordcharlie
Of course you play the hand - I'm just saying I rarely push all in preflop against reckless players. I might call the all in, late in the betting round.
I think you have a serious hole in your game then.
As to your second question of course I would; that's not an option though.
I was just trying to explain why you would want 2 - 3 callers or more even in an elimination tournament holding AA. The only exception I can think of would be if your were a spot or two away from the money or something similar.
Originally posted by: amoeba
Originally posted by: purbeast0
so who's e-penis is the biggest in this thread?
seriously, there is NO CORRECT WAY TO PLAY POKER!! play how YOU want. sure there are "smarter" ways to play, which are smarter because you are playing the greater odds. but in the end, it is all down to luck and how you can read people. just have fun playing.
Isn't the smarter way to play the same as the correct way?
Originally posted by: purbeast0
Originally posted by: amoeba
Originally posted by: purbeast0
so who's e-penis is the biggest in this thread?
seriously, there is NO CORRECT WAY TO PLAY POKER!! play how YOU want. sure there are "smarter" ways to play, which are smarter because you are playing the greater odds. but in the end, it is all down to luck and how you can read people. just have fun playing.
Isn't the smarter way to play the same as the correct way?
not necessarily. just play to have fun.
Originally posted by: purbeast0
so who's e-penis is the biggest in this thread?
seriously, there is NO CORRECT WAY TO PLAY POKER!! play how YOU want. sure there are "smarter" ways to play, which are smarter because you are playing the greater odds. but in the end, it is all down to luck and how you can read people. just have fun playing.
