etech:
You just want OT taken out of AT, right? would that solve everything? sure there are the people that just quote what the other person said. or make just a smiley. but those people don't stick around much anyway, and if they do what is the harm in it (using just a smiley to reply)? it tells the originator of the thread that people are reading and enjoyed it or think it is funny or whatever. .
i also saw from the Forum Issues thread that you complain when someone says they can't help. well it keeps the thread bumped to the top and then maybe someone will see it so they can get the help they need.
it isn't like this is the all ending crisis of the world. it really doesn't seem to be much of a problem as you point out. anyway, i've paid for the bandwidth, and as long as i stay in the scope of the rules, i can use it as i wish (which obviously i do, if i am still allowed to post here).