Bin Laden Guards Captured = Bin Laden Dead?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

rudder

Lifer
Nov 9, 2000
19,441
86
91
I think he is buried under rubble. If he were to convince the world he was alive by releasing a video, don't you think that would boost the moral of all those freakin terrorists all over the world. Especially some skinny ass freak withstanding some poundings from a B-52.
 

skace

Lifer
Jan 23, 2001
14,488
7
81
I think he is buried under rubble. If he were to convince the world he was alive by releasing a video, don't you think that would boost the moral of all those freakin terrorists all over the world. Especially some skinny ass freak withstanding some poundings from a B-52.


I think that would be about as smart as shooting yourself again just because the first shot didn't cause enough damage. If he is alive, his smartest option is to keep out of the spotlight for the time being.
 

ToBeMe

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2000
5,711
0
0
Originally posted by: skace
I think he is buried under rubble. If he were to convince the world he was alive by releasing a video, don't you think that would boost the moral of all those freakin terrorists all over the world. Especially some skinny ass freak withstanding some poundings from a B-52.


I think that would be about as smart as shooting yourself again just because the first shot didn't cause enough damage. If he is alive, his smartest option is to keep out of the spotlight for the time being.
That might be true.............normally............but this situation isn't normal, and the man in question never had any qualms about speaking before........hell, even the local media in Pakistan and the almighty (in that area) al Jareaz (sp?) agreed that his not producing some evidence of his well being is very unlike bin Laden. He was instanly in the media when Clinton sent in missiles.............he had no qualms showing himself after the Cole incident.................no, his lack of producing eveidence of his own well being may be proof he is either not well, or dead!

 

DaiShan

Diamond Member
Jul 5, 2001
9,617
1
0
I for one hope we never catch him, for one it would be horribly anti-climactic to finally catch him, there is no way we can possibly live up the hype we have enforced on ourselves, besides, he doesn't command operations any more (not likely anyways) and if we catch him it may bestow a false sense of security on the country. We must be vigilant.
 

Ludacris

Senior member
Oct 4, 2001
516
0
0
He has been quiet on the video seen but from time to time he will release hand written letters. Here is the latest letter that he released a week ago:

KABUL, Afghanistan ? Usama bin Laden allegedly sent out a handwritten letter to rally the Al Qaeda and assure them that the United States will be defeated, even as Afghanistan's foreign minister said he thinks the terrorist mastermind and his supporters are hiding in northwest Pakistan.

"We will closely witness, Allah willing, the fall of the United States of America, which ignored all human values, passed over all limits, and understands no logic but that one of power and Jihad,? bin Laden allegedly wrote in a letter obtained Saturday by IslamOnline.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I think he is alive, but he has to be considered for the "Biggest Pussy on Earth" award.
 

Dhruv

Senior member
May 15, 2001
729
0
0
Originally posted by: MichaelD
Bin Laden is driving a yellow taxi cab in Manhattan. There are literally THOUSANDS of men of Arab/Indian (the average white person cannot tell the diff b/t an Arab and an Indian...trust me, I used to live there) decent living in NYC. He would blend in perfectly. He would live in a neighborhood that had just as many people of his race as his homeland overseas. They hide him and treat him like a demigod.

Tens of times, on a daily basis, he ferries rich white men from the Wall Street area past the site where the World Trade Center once stood. He smiles smugly as he passes by this slient tomb where so many Amercians died. He smiles even more smugly when said white guy passenger pays the fare and gives him a nice tip too boot.

Oh yeah, he's alive. And God help him when we catch him.


"They hide him and treat him like a demigod." You may refer to Arabs as doing this but don't say Indians do this you stupid motherfcker. Indians have suffered more from the likes of him than Americans of any nationality have. What is happening in Kashmir has been happening for 15 years, just because Islamic terrorism is at the forefront now doesn't mean it hasn't happened before. It happens on a daily basis in central-south asia. Would you say that Jews support Bin Laden? Then how can you say Indians do?

Get your facts straight before you talk MichaelD you fcking biitch. My parents are from there and people like us have suffered 10 times more than what happened on 9/11. About 35,000 people have been killed by Islamic militants in Kashmir since the past 15 years. 3,000 people die in the WTC (more than 250 were Indian) and you think all of a sudden that only people outside of that region are against him?

you've got some fcking nerve man.
 

FrancesBeansRevenge

Platinum Member
Jun 6, 2001
2,181
0
0
Originally posted by: Dhruv
Originally posted by: MichaelD
Bin Laden is driving a yellow taxi cab in Manhattan. There are literally THOUSANDS of men of Arab/Indian (the average white person cannot tell the diff b/t an Arab and an Indian...trust me, I used to live there) decent living in NYC. He would blend in perfectly. He would live in a neighborhood that had just as many people of his race as his homeland overseas. They hide him and treat him like a demigod.

Tens of times, on a daily basis, he ferries rich white men from the Wall Street area past the site where the World Trade Center once stood. He smiles smugly as he passes by this slient tomb where so many Amercians died. He smiles even more smugly when said white guy passenger pays the fare and gives him a nice tip too boot.

Oh yeah, he's alive. And God help him when we catch him.


"They hide him and treat him like a demigod." You may refer to Arabs as doing this but don't say Indians do this you stupid motherfcker. WHAT IS BECOMING OF MY SOULESS SEARCH FOR THE EVERLASTING KNOBSUCKLER?Indians have suffered more from the likes of him than Americans of any nationality have. What is happening in Kashmir has been happening for 15 years, just because Islamic terrorism is at the forefront now doesn't mean it hasn't happened before. It happens on a daily basis in central-south asia. Would you say that Jews support Bin Laden? Then how can you say Indians do?

Get your facts straight before you talk MichaelD you fcking biitch. My parents are from there and people like us have suffered 10 times more than what happened on 9/11. About 35,000 people have been killed by Islamic militants in Kashmir since the past 15 years. 3,000 people die in the WTC (more than 250 were Indian) and you think all of a sudden that only people outside of that region are against him?

you've got some fcking nerve man.

You'll have to excuse him. To him all 'brown people' look the same.
He probably couldn't tell the difference between Bin Laden and Gandhi.

 

rbhawcroft

Senior member
May 16, 2002
897
0
0
Originally posted by: Dhruv
Originally posted by: MichaelDBin Laden is driving a yellow taxi cab in Manhattan. There are literally THOUSANDS of men of Arab/Indian (the average white person cannot tell the diff b/t an Arab and an Indian...trust me, I used to live there) decent living in NYC. He would blend in perfectly. He would live in a neighborhood that had just as many people of his race as his homeland overseas. They hide him and treat him like a demigod.Tens of times, on a daily basis, he ferries rich white men from the Wall Street area past the site where the World Trade Center once stood. He smiles smugly as he passes by this slient tomb where so many Amercians died. He smiles even more smugly when said white guy passenger pays the fare and gives him a nice tip too boot.Oh yeah, he's alive. And God help him when we catch him.
"They hide him and treat him like a demigod." You may refer to Arabs as doing this but don't say Indians do this you stupid motherfcker. Indians have suffered more from the likes of him than Americans of any nationality have. What is happening in Kashmir has been happening for 15 years, just because Islamic terrorism is at the forefront now doesn't mean it hasn't happened before. It happens on a daily basis in central-south asia. Would you say that Jews support Bin Laden? Then how can you say Indians do?Get your facts straight before you talk MichaelD you fcking biitch. My parents are from there and people like us have suffered 10 times more than what happened on 9/11. About 35,000 people have been killed by Islamic militants in Kashmir since the past 15 years. 3,000 people die in the WTC (more than 250 were Indian) and you think all of a sudden that only people outside of that region are against him?you've got some fcking nerve man.


old man there is a saying: where ever there is a terrorist there is an injustice.

its a testimony to the thickness of the bin-dians that they have taken 35000 killed and still not realised this, and a tribute to the nationalist leaders that they have cunjured up a good reason to keep them in power.
 

MadRat

Lifer
Oct 14, 1999
11,999
308
126
Excuse me, but India has been suffering the Muslim culture for 1000 years, not just 15!
 

Dhruv

Senior member
May 15, 2001
729
0
0
old man there is a saying: where ever there is a terrorist there is an injustice.

its a testimony to the thickness of the bin-dians that they have taken 35000 killed and still not realised this, and a tribute to the nationalist leaders that they have cunjured up a good reason to keep them in power.

By not realizing this are you implying that the actions that these Islamic terrorists take is justified? What is an injustice? What has happened in Kashmir is FAR from what has happened in Palestine. 35% of Kashmir used to be Hindu. Kashmir was ALWAYS ALWAYS ALWAYS a part of India. It was ALWAYS a part of Hindu land, with ancient temples abound there. Hundreds of thousands of families have become refugees in their own countries due to ethnic cleansing in the Kashmir Valley. And there is a direct role by outsiders because When India helped divide Pakistan into two in 1971 (West Pakistan and East Pakistan - modern day Bangladesh), Pakistan vowed to split India as it felt India had done to it. However, if you look at a map of South Asia you will realize how stupid the East-West Pakistan border was. East Pakistan was completely disjointed from west. It was unpractical, and the people were completely different. Different culture, race, language, yes they had the same religion but that doesn' t mean that it should become a part of one another. Should Skokie, Illinois become a part of Israel? Should downtown Detroit become a part of Africa? This is the logic that many Pakistanis use when they say Kashmir should become a part of their territory.

Yes, the Indian army has committed atrocities, but we Americans are the last to talk when it comes to this. We have to look at the general picture. If India has killed some innocent people while trying to root out people, that is a justified cost of war. Don't you think when America bombed the hell out of Iraq that innocents didn't die? We all know the fact is more innocents died than were guilty in Iraq. The guilty party, the politicians, leaders were oppressing their own people for a number of years. I'm very pro-American and so realize that this is in the general intersest of the world, that to destabilize Iraq as much as possible. So when there are injustices in Kashmir why hold it to a different standard? By the way, the amount of civilians we have wrongfully killed in Afghanistan or Iraq far surpasses the amount killed in Kashmir, but no one seems to talk about that.

To kill 100 bad guys may take the loss of 1 or 2 innocents. in the general picture it is worth it.


old man there is a saying: where ever there is a terrorist there is an injustice.

its a testimony to the thickness of the bin-dians that they have taken 35000 killed and still not realised this, and a tribute to the nationalist leaders that they have cunjured up a good reason to keep them in power.

So, with this logic, are you saying that the U.S. justifiably suffered from the WTC attacks? After all, in the eyes of the Muslims, we had done injustice to them.


 

Dhruv

Senior member
May 15, 2001
729
0
0
i would like to also point out something. Where were all the Muslim rallies and peace protests after 9/11? The community was mysteriously quiet, kinda like they are taking the Fifth on this one.

Tacit approval.


 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: Ernieb
People are saying that the U.S President sent their Armys there for other reasons.
And I think that U.S is #1 in many ways. They have no problem for locating the drug dealers..
the criminals .. they can easily arrest them and put them in jail..how come it takes to many people (the soliders) and so much of the money to get the Bin Laden person.. and this process is still on for almost one year already.. it's a lot of manpower and money in this catching this one middle aged man.. sometimes i don't understand..
Can somebody explaine more to me? cuz personaly I don't really think that the U.S president sent his soliders there to Middle East are really for catching that one little middle aged laden..
:frown:

2 words my friend...Eric Rudolph.
It's kind of hard to find somebody when your "allies" are hiding him isn't it?
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: Dhruv
i would like to also point out something. Where were all the Muslim rallies and peace protests after 9/11? The community was mysteriously quiet, kinda like they are taking the Fifth on this one.

Tacit approval.

Where were the Christian rallies after Waco and the Halley Bop incident?

You can't blame a whole religion on the works of a cult(be they muslim or christian).
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,402
8,574
126
drug lords? we usually have a bit of a problem finding those guys.
 

Dhruv

Senior member
May 15, 2001
729
0
0
i suggest you learn Urdu or Arabic or Pashto.

Whenever they speak in English it is nice words for Westerners. If you know one of those languages and hear what they say in their native tongue you'd be shocked. Most of Pakistan and Arabian territories chant Bin Laden Zindabad which means long live Bin laden. When they interview a Pakistani the first thing they say "Pakistan was the forefront in helping the U.S. We are risking a lot helping them out..."

fact is: Pakistan would be even an even poorer, isolated country if it DIDN'T take this opportunity to help the U.S.

We MUST not confuse self-interest for friendship.

What you must read is that the Taliban WAS created by our 'ally' pakistan in 1996. this is not unsupported, this is fact.


PROOF:

1) what the national review has to say

2) <a target=new class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://www.cbc.ca/news/indepth/targetterrorism/backgrounders/pakistan.html">(read under Taliban take control) "Since the Taliban was created and funded by ISI, Pakistan could marshal its men and resources on the all-important southern border against archrival India." The ISI is the Intelligence unit of Pakistan, much like our CIA.
</a>

3)
what an Afghan Ambassador has to say about this: scroll 3/4ths down the page, mentions ISI (Pakistans involvement in creating the Taliban and helping Bin Laden)


4) <a target=new class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://www.pakistanlink.com/Opinion/2000/Mar/17/01.html">A Pakistani website's own admission to creating the Taliban: "But Pakistan?s biggest mistake, one that we will regret more with the passing of years, has to be the creation of the Taliban"
source:</a>

5) read under 'introduction' What the united states institute for peace has to say

Nitemare: i totally agree with you. I too hate the stereotyping of an entire group of people based on any lines, whether it be religion, race, culture, nationality, etc. But, in the recent years, and after more and more research on Islamic (I used to use the word Islamist as it is more politically correct) terrorism, i have really changed my views quite a bit.

The fact is, there are great people on this planet, and that attribute has nothing to do with their religion, background, race, etc.

The fact is, there are horrible people on this planet, and that attribute has nothing to do with their religion, background, race, etc.

This being said, in real life there are real problems. There ARE patterns of behavior, there are statistics, probabilities, and other systems of science that must be accounted for. Whether we know it or not, we do give importance to these things. For example, you would rather fly in a plane model that has a .0000001% chance of crash than say a plane that has a .005% chance of crash. Maybe some of the planes that have the .005% chance of crash will never crash and maybe they are even more stable than the other model. But that is something we cannot know. What we DO know is that most of the time, the first plane is safer to fly than the second. So we can safely say we would rather fly in the first plane. I don't mean to go crazy here talking about planes, but i'm trying to make a point.

I'm not going to guess of what background you are from Nitemare, but I have many friends that are Muslim. I have Iranian, Pakistani, Indian, Afghan, and Indian friends who are Muslim. They are very devout people and have a strong loyalty and a lot of pride of their religion. And that is fine. But what really did it for me was when some of my friends, who were Muslim, made comments like:

this dialogue transpired with a friend of mine, who is Sunni, Muslim. November 2001

my friend:
"What proof does the U.S. have that Bin Laden sent those hijackers? Where's the proof? How do we not know, if, lets say, the Israelis hired the Arabs because Jews are very rich to fly the planes through the World Trade Center."

Me: "how can you POSSIBLE say something like this?"

Him: "Hey, I'm just saying there is NO proof. Americans always do this....."

Me: dude whatever (i was getting really really burnt up and didn't want to start a fight)

and no, i'm not taking fragments of our conversation to make a point, this was the first and only statements he made. He never even warmed up to the lack of evidence thing, that was his first point. like maybe if had said, man, what happened was terrible, i can't believe it, etc. etc. etc. but he started off with that tirade.

this was the first and last conversation i decided to conduct with a Muslim person. He is educated, comes from a wealthy family, has a family, does not do Namaaz five times a day, does not have a beard, he is quite liberal and westernized as far as they go actually. He's actually a nice guy, never seen him angry at anyone or anything. That is what makes it so much more shocking for me.

I've had several other talks with my muslim friends thru email, in person etc. but i decided to never question them. But when the topic of 9/11 came up and they were around not ONCE have i heard them say those damn people should be shot, or anything that would prove to me that they were angry people. they would make comments like "Muslims did not do this. A true Muslim does not do this. Bin Laden is not a true muslim." And a minute later I'd hear, "Americans always go around to Muslim countries. They help the Jews. The Jews dominate American Tel-Avivison..."

Believe me Nitemare, just because someone doesn't pick up a gun, doesn't make then any less innocent. if they support, even in their hearts and not aloud, the behavior of the Islamic extremists, they are just as guilty, because, put in the right situation, these people who were once our friends will turn on us with a vengance. I dont' know a single militant, as far as I know, but I do know a lot of Muslims that give to 'charity,', to their mosque, etc. Their mosque and these 'charities' funnel money out of the West and it goes back to that region to do kill others. I knew this before this was all news to Americans, before the crackdown on the illicit charities began here. Being from that region, I know a lot more than other Americans do on the subject. The links i provided you above are done by 3rd party, unbiased people. Some are by Western sources, one by an Afghan, and one by a Pakistani. I felt the need to give you a balanced report. My point in this was not to pick on Pakistan, but to show you that ENTIRE countries can and do support and create elements that are against our interest, even under the guise of being our 'ally.'

I have realized that the average American is truly poor in world events and current affairs. I am reminded of a time Jay Leno went street walking and asked people basic questions even on on our own government, such as "when did we win independence, and from what country..." and the answers ranged from the 1800's to being liberated from Canada. Pathetic. I remember the time when George W. Bush thought the Taliban was some sort of rock band. When he didnt' know the prime minister of Indias name. I mean, come on India isn't the most powerful nation, but it is a major country and this guy is our president!! Europeans are much better in this respect. I wish that more Americans like myself, particularly the young people would know about what is really happening in the world. Unfortunately, the Average american does not know the difference between Sikhism, Hinduism, or Islam. All they know is these people range from fair to dark skinned, are hirsuit, have similar accents, and similar food. I know its hard to tell who is who but instances such as this READ should never happen, whether the person is known to be a Muslim or not.

This thread is already getting too long but think that you have had some information kept from you, not just you but the average American has information kept from them, when it was really there all along, it just wasn't marketed. Please refer to this to see just where most Muslims stand. Unless someone thinks of a way to read their minds and see what they believe we will not know who is 'bad' and who is not. Better be safe than sorry I say. If this was done by any other demographic group, I'm sure that group would be in the streets showing their support for the U.S. instead of sitting at home and staying quiet. Believe me, what is told to me by many American Muslims and what is told to Anglo Americans is completely different.
 

NogginBoink

Diamond Member
Feb 17, 2002
5,322
0
0
Personally, I think he's dead.

He's just too egotistcal to remain quiet. And the morale of his troops would be boosted by him making an appearance, as others have said.

I believe that he has nothing to loose and everything to gain for his cause by making a public appearance. Since he hasn't, I'm inclined to believe he's Bin Dusted.
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,402
8,574
126
What you must read is that the Taliban WAS created by our 'ally' pakistan in 1996. this is not unsupported, this is fact.
the problem is that since then theres been a coup and a completely different gov't is in place.
 

GoodToGo

Diamond Member
Jul 16, 2000
3,516
1
0
I could not possibly agree more with you Dhruv. Indians have been suffering for so many years but the whole world has turned a blind eye towards them :( :|
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: ffmcobalt
Very nice read, Dhruv.

nik

Indeed.

What else do you expect from people who are brainwashed and spoon-fed hate though? Like the article in which Jews drank the blood of Arab children during a religious ceremony. Everyone would easily dismiss this right? Not so...The Islamic Fundamentalists are nothing more than a religious cult with automatic weapons and explosives. Combine that with an idiot savant the likes of Bin Laden and you have a dangerous combination.
Look at Germany pre-Hitler, they were struggling and looking for a solution to their problems...and we all know where that led. Arab culture as a whole sucks for your everyday Arab, unless you are fortunate to be born into money. If you take Prince Abdullah and his families money away from the region, you are left with an annual salary of about half a days pay for a programmer in San Jose. Then comes the priests, symbols of faith and righteousness blaming Great Satan(US) and jews for all their problems and a right good many see it as a way out. It's always easier to blame someone else than to look within.

The Koran as a whole isn't that much more barbaric than our old testament. Examine Judge 29 I think..something about the raping and dismemberment of a concubine. All it is is opportunists "Capitalizing"(Capitalism....the root of all evil) on the misery of others.

Ask not what your country can do for you, because it won't do a damn thing...but ask what you can do for Prince Abdullah
 

Dhruv

Senior member
May 15, 2001
729
0
0
Originally posted by: ElFenix
What you must read is that the Taliban WAS created by our 'ally' pakistan in 1996. this is not unsupported, this is fact.
the problem is that since then theres been a coup and a completely different gov't is in place.


ElFenix: Actually, we cannot forget that the Pakistani military was involved with the Taliban as well. The U.S. CIA and our military work together, so lets not forget that the ISI and Pakistani military work together.

Now, who was the army general at the time? General Pervez Musharraf, otherwise known as the current Prime Minister! Completely different government? Nope, same guy.
 

yllus

Elite Member & Lifer
Aug 20, 2000
20,577
432
126
I won't argue that a good number of Western-born sons and daughters of Muslims start up with the Jewish conspiracy garbage if you raise the issue of 9/11 behind closed doors. Being of the culture I hear it more than any of you do. These, simply, are just dumb people who are spoon-fed a little too easily by their 40 to 60 year old blue collar mothers and fathers who somehow are experts of world politics and religion. It's just SORT OF similar to the way your own parents have doubtless told you about how the Kashmiri people long to be a part of India in spite of the whole predominant religion thing and the refusal to vote in a referendum to join the country of their choosing or strike on out alone.

The Koran as a whole isn't that much more barbaric than our old testament. Examine Judge 29 I think..something about the raping and dismemberment of a concubine.
rolleye.gif
"You think." Surely the words of someone who's read the book before commenting. Once again, a link to this thread: The Bible vs. The Koran on various issues of Man.
 

Dhruv

Senior member
May 15, 2001
729
0
0
Originally posted by: Nitemare
Originally posted by: ffmcobalt
Very nice read, Dhruv.

nik

Indeed.

What else do you expect from people who are brainwashed and spoon-fed hate though? Like the article in which Jews drank the blood of Arab children during a religious ceremony. Everyone would easily dismiss this right? Not so...The Islamic Fundamentalists are nothing more than a religious cult with automatic weapons and explosives. Combine that with an idiot savant the likes of Bin Laden and you have a dangerous combination.
Look at Germany pre-Hitler, they were struggling and looking for a solution to their problems...and we all know where that led. Arab culture as a whole sucks for your everyday Arab, unless you are fortunate to be born into money. If you take Prince Abdullah and his families money away from the region, you are left with an annual salary of about half a days pay for a programmer in San Jose. Then comes the priests, symbols of faith and righteousness blaming Great Satan(US) and jews for all their problems and a right good many see it as a way out. It's always easier to blame someone else than to look within.

The Koran as a whole isn't that much more barbaric than our old testament. Examine Judge 29 I think..something about the raping and dismemberment of a concubine. All it is is opportunists "Capitalizing"(Capitalism....the root of all evil) on the misery of others.

Ask not what your country can do for you, because it won't do a damn thing...but ask what you can do for Prince Abdullah

Okay Nitmare, point taken. The Muslims in this world have been fed a lot of false information. They have been brainwashed. Everything you said is true. I'm not advocating that we go out and round them all up and kill them, as Hitler did, I am merely saying that we need to change our thinking and better separate fact from fiction. If Islam meant peace in 620 A.D., certainly, today Islamic people are not peaceful. Instead of having sit ins, peaceful boycotts, peace marches, etc to act against their perceived (and many times true) injustices, they resort to bombings, hijackings, beheadings, shootings, etc. etc. They resort to VIOLENCE. They should realize that they will never win in this game. This is not morally, or practically correct. Gandhi, Dalai Lama, Martin Luther King Jr. are all examples of where peace will take you, it is the 'higher' ground in fighting tyranny. Why can't Muslims do this? Why is it okay to kill their sisters when their sisters were raped ("honor killings")? Yet our president openly declares that "Islam means peace."

I'm saying lets face the reality, stop bullshiitin around. We have a major problem with many people of this religion. Let's not gloss over it. Let's find out why their religion:

a) Preaches it is the only righteous path (yes i know Christianity does this too, but when Christians start becoming terrorists in the hundreds of thousands, I'll be the first to complain).

b) Tolerates murder against others.

Look, there are hundreds of millions of people in other religions as well, such as Christianity, Hinduism, Judaism, and Buddhism, but these religions do not have this problem. Buddhists are CONSTANTLY persecuted much worse than most Muslims are in Tibet by the Chinese army, yet they do not behave like this. I have to disagree with Bush when he says Islam means peace. If Islam meant peace, why can Muslims not behave in a more peaceful way?

Yes, I do believe if any one religion can produce this magnitude of hate, this mass of terrorists, the religion needs to be scrutinized. Just because a lot of people follow something doesn't always make it right. Maybe the original Quu'ran was a great book, it probably is, doesn't change the fact that Muslims today are acting inappropriately. To me, a religion is more than a book, it is a way of life. Maybe this is because I am from an Eastern background.. i don't know, but what I do think is that just because something was great 1300 years ago doesn't mean it is going to be great today. Religion is dynamic, not static. If it changes and becomes a religion thats modern practicioners use to preach hate, intolerance, bigotry, homophobia, classisim, sexism, etc. etc., I will say that the religion was once great but now it sucks.

They have been brainwashed, yes I agree, but what do you propose? We sit down 1.2 billion people (or however many) and teach them, "Look Mohammed Razi Khan Akhmed Shamood, your Mullah is wrong, Islam is not supposed to be practiced this way, your president is wrong, your friend is wrong, your parents are wrong. Listen to Me, Joe Smith, you dont' know me, I dont' speak your language, I dont' know where you came from or what you're about, but I'm right!"

In an ideal world, maybe. Lets face it. Not gonna happen. We need a backup plan.

Okay, backup plan: The U.S. stops interfering with the Muslim world. They *yeah right* stop their greed for oil cold turkey. We Westerners mind our own business and we let the Muslim world mind theirs. What will that do? Will that stop them from fighting each other (Iran vs. Iraq, Shiite Vs. Sunni, Kurd Vs. Arab, Jew Vs. Arab)? Will that stop them from killing their sisters, mothers, gays, etc.?
Probably not. How can we live in a world with two very different systems of life co-existing? There will be friction, there will be attacks on Westerners, whether we are involved or not. If we were able to push a button and stop all the so-called injustices faced by these people today do you honestly believe that would be the end of it.?

Hey, I dont' know what the solution is either man. All I know is we need to face the reality, that has always been the best way of handling a situation.


***I hope you guys have read my previous post (the long as5 one), it was long but took me a while to write and link. I hope you find it balanced. I hate reading long posts but think its worth reading.
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: yllus
I won't argue that a good number of Western-born sons and daughters of Muslims start up with the Jewish conspiracy garbage if you raise the issue of 9/11 behind closed doors. Being of the culture I hear it more than any of you do. These, simply, are just dumb people who are spoon-fed a little too easily by their 40 to 60 year old blue collar mothers and fathers who somehow are experts of world politics and religion. It's just SORT OF similar to the way your own parents have doubtless told you about how the Kashmiri people long to be a part of India in spite of the whole predominant religion thing and the refusal to vote in a referendum to join the country of their choosing or strike on out alone.

The Koran as a whole isn't that much more barbaric than our old testament. Examine Judge 29 I think..something about the raping and dismemberment of a concubine.
rolleye.gif
"You think." Surely the words of someone who's read the book before commenting. Once again, a link to this thread: The Bible vs. The Koran on various issues of Man.
1 In those days Israel had no king.
Now a Levite who lived in a remote area in the hill country of Ephraim took a concubine from
Bethlehem in Judah. 2 But she was unfaithful to him. She left him and went back to her father's
house in Bethlehem, Judah. After she had been there four months, 3 her husband went to her to
persuade her to return. He had with him his servant and two donkeys. She took him into her
father's house, and when her father saw him, he gladly welcomed him. 4 His father-in-law, the
girl's father, prevailed upon him to stay; so he remained with him three days, eating and drinking,
and sleeping there.
5 On the fourth day they got up early and he prepared to leave, but the girl's father said to his
son-in-law, "Refresh yourself with something to eat; then you can go." 6 So the two of them sat
down to eat and drink together. Afterward the girl's father said, "Please stay tonight and enjoy
yourself." 7 And when the man got up to go, his father-in-law persuaded him, so he stayed there
that night. 8 On the morning of the fifth day, when he rose to go, the girl's father said, "Refresh
yourself. Wait till afternoon!" So the two of them ate together.
9 Then when the man, with his concubine and his servant, got up to leave, his father-in-law, the
girl's father, said, "Now look, it's almost evening. Spend the night here; the day is nearly over. Stay
and enjoy yourself. Early tomorrow morning you can get up and be on your way home." 10 But,
unwilling to stay another night, the man left and went toward Jebus (that is, Jerusalem), with his
two saddled donkeys and his concubine.
11 When they were near Jebus and the day was almost gone, the servant said to his master, "Come,
let's stop at this city of the Jebusites and spend the night."
12 His master replied, "No. We won't go into an alien city, whose people are not Israelites. We will
go on to Gibeah." 13 He added, "Come, let's try to reach Gibeah or Ramah and spend the night in
one of those places." 14 So they went on, and the sun set as they neared Gibeah in Benjamin. 15
There they stopped to spend the night. They went and sat in the city square, but no one took them
into his home for the night.
16 That evening an old man from the hill country of Ephraim, who was living in Gibeah (the men
of the place were Benjamites), came in from his work in the fields. 17 When he looked and saw the
traveler in the city square, the old man asked, "Where are you going? Where did you come from?"

18 He answered, "We are on our way from Bethlehem in Judah to a remote area in the hill
country of Ephraim where I live. I have been to Bethlehem in Judah and now I am going to the
house of the LORD . No one has taken me into his house. 19 We have both straw and fodder for
our donkeys and bread and wine for ourselves your servants-me, your maidservant, and the young
man with us. We don't need anything."
20 "You are welcome at my house," the old man said. "Let me supply whatever you need. Only
don't spend the night in the square." 21 So he took him into his house and fed his donkeys. After
they had washed their feet, they had something to eat and drink.
22 While they were enjoying themselves, some of the wicked men of the city surrounded the house.
Pounding on the door, they shouted to the old man who owned the house, "Bring out the man who
came to your house so we can have sex with him."
23 The owner of the house went outside and said to them, "No, my friends, don't be so vile. Since
this man is my guest, don't do this disgraceful thing. 24 Look, here is my virgin daughter, and his
concubine. I will bring them out to you now, and you can use them and do to them whatever you
wish. But to this man, don't do such a disgraceful thing."
25 But the men would not listen to him. So the man took his concubine and sent her outside to
them, and they raped her and abused her throughout the night, and at dawn they let her go. 26 At
daybreak the woman went back to the house where her master was staying, fell down at the door
and lay there until daylight.
27 When her master got up in the morning and opened the door of the house and stepped out to
continue on his way, there lay his concubine, fallen in the doorway of the house, with her hands on
the threshold. 28 He said to her, "Get up; let's go." But there was no answer. Then the man put her
on his donkey and set out for home.
29 When he reached home, he took a knife and cut up his concubine, limb by limb, into twelve
parts and sent them into all the areas of Israel. 30 Everyone who saw it said, "Such a thing has
never been seen or done, not since the day the Israelites came up out of Egypt. Think about it!
Consider it! Tell us what to do!"

Can't recall seeing anything like that in the Koran nor in Bible study class. The Old Testament has alot of things you don't typically hear about...why don't you pick up the good book once in awhile and you will see for yourself
rolleye.gif
:D
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: Dhruv
Originally posted by: Nitemare
Originally posted by: ffmcobalt
Very nice read, Dhruv.

nik

Indeed.

What else do you expect from people who are brainwashed and spoon-fed hate though? Like the article in which Jews drank the blood of Arab children during a religious ceremony. Everyone would easily dismiss this right? Not so...The Islamic Fundamentalists are nothing more than a religious cult with automatic weapons and explosives. Combine that with an idiot savant the likes of Bin Laden and you have a dangerous combination.
Look at Germany pre-Hitler, they were struggling and looking for a solution to their problems...and we all know where that led. Arab culture as a whole sucks for your everyday Arab, unless you are fortunate to be born into money. If you take Prince Abdullah and his families money away from the region, you are left with an annual salary of about half a days pay for a programmer in San Jose. Then comes the priests, symbols of faith and righteousness blaming Great Satan(US) and jews for all their problems and a right good many see it as a way out. It's always easier to blame someone else than to look within.

The Koran as a whole isn't that much more barbaric than our old testament. Examine Judge 29 I think..something about the raping and dismemberment of a concubine. All it is is opportunists "Capitalizing"(Capitalism....the root of all evil) on the misery of others.

Ask not what your country can do for you, because it won't do a damn thing...but ask what you can do for Prince Abdullah

Okay Nitmare, point taken. The Muslims in this world have been fed a lot of false information. They have been brainwashed. Everything you said is true. I'm not advocating that we go out and round them all up and kill them, as Hitler did, I am merely saying that we need to change our thinking and better separate fact from fiction. If Islam meant peace in 620 A.D., certainly, today Islamic people are not peaceful. Instead of having sit ins, peaceful boycotts, peace marches, etc to act against their perceived (and many times true) injustices, they resort to bombings, hijackings, beheadings, shootings, etc. etc. They resort to VIOLENCE. They should realize that they will never win in this game. This is not morally, or practically correct. Gandhi, Dalai Lama, Martin Luther King Jr. are all examples of where peace will take you, it is the 'higher' ground in fighting tyranny. Why can't Muslims do this? Why is it okay to kill their sisters when their sisters were raped ("honor killings")? Yet our president openly declares that "Islam means peace."

I'm saying lets face the reality, stop bullshiitin around. We have a major problem with many people of this religion. Let's not gloss over it. Let's find out why their religion:

a) Preaches it is the only righteous path (yes i know Christianity does this too, but when Christians start becoming terrorists in the hundreds of thousands, I'll be the first to complain).

b) Tolerates murder against others.

Look, there are hundreds of millions of people in other religions as well, such as Christianity, Hinduism, Judaism, and Buddhism, but these religions do not have this problem. Buddhists are CONSTANTLY persecuted much worse than most Muslims are in Tibet by the Chinese army, yet they do not behave like this. I have to disagree with Bush when he says Islam means peace. If Islam meant peace, why can Muslims not behave in a more peaceful way?

Yes, I do believe if any one religion can produce this magnitude of hate, this mass of terrorists, the religion needs to be scrutinized. Just because a lot of people follow something doesn't always make it right. Maybe the original Quu'ran was a great book, it probably is, doesn't change the fact that Muslims today are acting inappropriately. To me, a religion is more than a book, it is a way of life. Maybe this is because I am from an Eastern background.. i don't know, but what I do think is that just because something was great 1300 years ago doesn't mean it is going to be great today. Religion is dynamic, not static. If it changes and becomes a religion thats modern practicioners use to preach hate, intolerance, bigotry, homophobia, classisim, sexism, etc. etc., I will say that the religion was once great but now it sucks.

They have been brainwashed, yes I agree, but what do you propose? We sit down 1.2 billion people (or however many) and teach them, "Look Mohammed Razi Khan Akhmed Shamood, your Mullah is wrong, Islam is not supposed to be practiced this way, your president is wrong, your friend is wrong, your parents are wrong. Listen to Me, Joe Smith, you dont' know me, I dont' speak your language, I dont' know where you came from or what you're about, but I'm right!"

In an ideal world, maybe. Lets face it. Not gonna happen. We need a backup plan.

Okay, backup plan: The U.S. stops interfering with the Muslim world. They *yeah right* stop their greed for oil cold turkey. We Westerners mind our own business and we let the Muslim world mind theirs. What will that do? Will that stop them from fighting each other (Iran vs. Iraq, Shiite Vs. Sunni, Kurd Vs. Arab, Jew Vs. Arab)? Will that stop them from killing their sisters, mothers, gays, etc.?
Probably not. How can we live in a world with two very different systems of life co-existing? There will be friction, there will be attacks on Westerners, whether we are involved or not. If we were able to push a button and stop all the so-called injustices faced by these people today do you honestly believe that would be the end of it.?

Hey, I dont' know what the solution is either man. All I know is we need to face the reality, that has always been the best way of handling a situation.


***I hope you guys have read my previous post (the long as5 one), it was long but took me a while to write and link. I hope you find it balanced. I hate reading long posts but think its worth reading.

Is there a pretty solution? No
Several alternatives, but really the only thing that is going to help is time. We are not going to change their minds, unless we can isolate them in a holding facility in Cuba and show them that their mullah, priests and the likes are wrong, and that Allah does not want you to kill as many non-muslims as you can...

I don't have a solution either. It's farked up the way their rulers treat them, and it's even more farked up that they hate us because of it. The only way out is to come up with another fuel alternative or to have all that Arab oil dry up.

While they control the oil and lifeline of most of the civilized world, we will have to continue to kiss their shiny round heiny's...including our very own president and all of the European Coalition that have been kissing it since God knows when.

My proposition would involve taking out Saddam, and establishing a US friendly government in it's stead. This would give us a presence over there. Make it a republic of the US, grant these people limited citizenship and exchange the oil and its profits that John Doe Iraqi would never see anyways with sanitary conditions, food, and health care. It's a win win situation for everyone involved.
;)