Originally posted by: ProfJohn
Originally posted by: UberNeuman
ProfJohn - why and, in your own words - didn't the Bush administration pick up from Clinton's administration when OBL was labeled a threat? To keep proclaiming Clinton could have done more, then ignore the info that had been passed to the Bush team and that they did nothing in that time - it's a false viewpoint.....
In my own words:
1. Bush was in the process of changing the way in which they approached the war in terror. The record is there for anyone to see. The problem is that the time table did not give them enough time before 9-11 to make a significant enough of a change in policy to actually do something. Bush takes office around January 20, his appointees start taking office in March and April during the summer they developed a new plan for the war on terror, in late August they got together and agreed on said plan the plan did not hit Bush's desk till September 10. (This timeline is based on what Richard Clarke said)
That is what Bush was in the process of doing before 9-11, he was going to change how we went after al-Qaida.
I don't think any of that really matters because that plan would most likely not have stopped 9-11 anyway, it was to far along in planning by then to stop it. We could have killed bin Laden in the spring of 2001 and still not stopped 9-11. The only way to stop 9-11 would have been for us to either "get lucky" as happened in the millennium attacks or for the FBI, CIA etc to connect all the dots and realize what the plan was and came up with measures to stop it. (see my thoughts on stopping 9-11 below)
2. on Clinton: My problem with Clinton is not that he could have done more or should have done more, which he could have tried, but we don't know if that would have made a difference.
My problem is his excuses, well I couldn't take Osama because I had no legal reasons. I couldn't order the CIA to kill him without a "finding stating I can do so" etc etc. President Ford wrote a Presidential order outlawing assassination, Clinton could have written a new one re-allowing it, no one could have stopped him.
In August 1996 Osama declared war on the US "Declaration of War against the Americans Occupying the Land of the Two Holy Places." At that point Clinton could have signed an order for Osama to be killed or captured and justified it using his "war powers" as commander and chief.
Clinton sent thousands of troops in to Bosnia using the "war powers resolution."
Clinton launched an extended air war in Kosovo because of humanitarian issues.
Clinton sent troops to Haiti in order to return President Aristide to power.
Clinton sent troops into Somalia in order to protect humanitarian relief from armed gangs.
All this use of the military around the world, and yet Clinton was afraid of taking action against Osama because he lacked ?findings? or lacked the legal right to do so?
We bombed Kosovo for 78 days, according to Nato 720 aircraft flew almost 36,000 sorties - an average of 455 every 24 hours dropping over 20,000 bombs.
And against Osama and al-Qaida AFTER the embassy bombings we launch all of 75 missiles?????!!!!!
Do you at least understand why those of us on the right don?t believe him when he said he did everything he could??
(BTW: on stopping 9-11, one of the planes on the morning of 9-11 was given a warning about attempted hijackings, it did no good that plane was still hijacked. Now if we can tell the pilots to be alert and on the look out for a hijacking after 2 planes had already been hijacked and still have the warning do no good I do not think some generic warning would have done any good. Once they are on the plane it was too late, now they could have started searching everyone?s luggage and banning knifes etc before hand, but who knows if anyone had the political will to give that a try pre-9-11. Just look at the out cry over the ban on liquids on airplanes after we learn of a plot to blow up planes with liquid explosives, imagine what these people would have said pre 9-11. Heck, we can't even search Arab men now after 9-11, London and Madrid, the civil rights people would flip out if we did that, imagine if we even TRIED it before 9-11.)