Couple of comments:
I'd consider another "as is" case but it depends on what I was building it for. The computer I'm assembling (or rather re-assembling) didn't need an expensive case so this one that cost me $21 was perfect, even with the bezel in the condition that it was in. (it wasn't as if the bezel was cracked in the front, or otherwise damaged... it was just somewhat loose and that was kind of annoying.)
I figured that with the number of different cases available, that somewhere someone might/must sell bezels since what is the point of getting a whole new case if you just want to change the front of the case? It makes no sense to me to limit people like that. Evidently I was wrong. Oh well.
Thanks everyone for your input. I'll try that Plastix stuff if I can find it.