Best video game of all time POLL

[ruffilb]

OP updated with master list.

 

[GhettoFob]

River City Ransom

 

[tfinch2]

How can you pit Super Mario 3 and Super Mario Kart against each other in round 1?

 

[thesurge]

Warcraft III:Frozen Throne

(wtf is up with Pong vs. Tetris first round)

 

[HamburgerBoy]

Originally posted by: thesurge
Warcraft III:Frozen Throne

(wtf is up with Pong vs. Tetris first round)

What's so bad about Pong vs Tetris? The classics deserve a spot.

 

[wazzledoozle]

Resident Evil 4 should go up in the polls too

 

[ruffilb]

If you think a particular matchup is unfair, PM me about it. Read the OP again, I updated it.

 

[ElFenix]

mario kart and mario 3 facing off in the first round? you suck at making a bracket, ruff.



who here has even played x-com? (god that was a great game)

 

[ruffilb]

Bedtime bump. Keep votin' & postin'

 

[astralusion]

i agree re4 should be there and shouldn't baldur's gate of some iteration be in there, and if halo 1 and 2 get to be there then fallout 2 should be there, as should planescape (though it's not from the series, it just should be there) and btw, you might want to remind people that FF6 is what many of us know as 3...in other words many times more awesome than 7 (at least the snes version, never played the ps version).

 

[dsfunk]

another nomination for planescape torment

 

[ElFenix]

Originally posted by: astralusion
i agree re4 should be there and shouldn't baldur's gate of some iteration be in there, and if halo 1 and 2 get to be there then fallout 2 should be there, as should planescape (though it's not from the series, it just should be there) and btw, you might want to remind people that FF6 is what many of us know as 3...in other words many times more awesome than 7 (at least the snes version, never played the ps version).

wow, just learned that FF6 only sold 550,000 copies in the US... wtf?

IGN is like me and ranks FF4 higher than FF6, which is ranked higher than FF7

 

[Iron Woode]

Unreal Tournament

/thread

 

[secretanchitman]

secret of mana
half life 1
counterstrike
super mario bros
tetris
doom
WoW
quake 2
shenmue (spelt wrong in poll btw)
ff6 (i prefer ff8 and i HATE ff7)
super mario bros 3
starcraft
chrono cross
descent 2 FTW!!!!
duke nukem 3D (screw n64)

 

[Eeezee]

As much as I disliked Chrono Cross, I dislike the Sims more.

 

[foghorn67]

TIE Fighter and expansions

 

[Conky]

Originally posted by: Iron Woode
Unreal Tournament

/thread

As much as I love the Quake series I could go with this...

 

[Fenixgoon]

Originally posted by: HamburgerBoy

Originally posted by: Crazyfool
Quake 2, best game ever.

/thread

Not as if that post wasn't blasphemous enough, but you also voted for it over Deus Ex. :thumbsdown:

qft.. i dont know how quake2 is beating deus ex... JC Denton is way too badass to lose this poll

 

[mundane]

Good job, I hope you can keep up with all the requests / voting =)

I respectfully request you change "Tecmo Bowl" to "Tecmo Super Bowl", as I suspect that's what the poster intended.

I also think "Descent II" should be "Descent", but wth ...

Some more additions:
Jedi Knight II : Outcast
Sim City
Wing Commander Series
GTA Series
Blood
Command HQ (_really old school_)
Nobunaga's Ambition [series, but I prefer 2 for NES]
Edit: Anachronox, post-patch

 

[SirStev0]

i like this...

 

[JujuFish]

Of the games in the current poll, Chrono Trigger and Civilization are my favorites.

 

[b0mbrman]

Where's Pirates! Gold?

 

[BirdDad]

Chrono Trigger(by far) SNES it had the absolute best plot(being able to travel through time and when you did something in a previous time it would affect future time).
I'm supprised that Ultima 5 didn't make it,that was the best at the time(on a comodore 128 with music it was the best),I remember me and my friend taking shifts to build up our characters on our big screen projection TV.He would play then when it was time for him to sleep I would play then visa versa.
Heros of might and magic was also extremly good and was probably the best PC game of all time.
I'm sorry,I posted in the old poll before I read it all.

 

[Brutuskend]

Quake Wars: Enemy Territory

OK, so it's not released yet.

It will RULE!

 

[ForumMaster]

i nominate this as stupidest video game thread ever. you can't compare games that aren't similar at all. how can you compare Solitare and Doom?
i like these games:
Secret of Mana

Half-Life 1

CounterStrike

Super Mario Bros

Tetris

Doom

World of Warcraft

Quake II

Halo 1

Civilization

Final Fantasy VII

Super Mario Bros III

Starcraft (how can you compare a startegy game to a racing game?

Chrono Cross (tho both suck)

Halo II

Duke Nukem 64