• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Best PC speakers?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Now I have a question. I really like bass. With the BA4800 could I turn up the bass enough to get that real deep hard wall shaking bass?
 
another vote for the ba4800's. i think they are the best and most accurate sounding speakers for that amount of money
 
Zorba- You sound like me when I was asking about the bs4800s. I was really worried about not being satisfied with the amount of bass it pumped out and one time I went to Compusa a while ago and the bass was little to none. So that reall scared me but I bought them yesterday nonetheless just to try them out and maybe return them. Well, the bass is full, and powerful. I am very satisfied! The bass may not be as powerful as the Klipschs but the bass on the ba4800s NEVER distorts.
 
Well I hate the bass on my FPS2000. I like a balanced sound most of the time. But sometime I want to turn up that sub and really feel it. 😉

I think I am going to run up to Crapusa and listen to the BA's and Klipschs.
 
You can't really tell any anything from the speakers at CompUSA since they dont simulate the small room you are going to be in and the bass on the ba4800s was little or none, and the input into the speakers is really weak so the speakers at full volume are nothing.
 
I haven't heard the BA yet but my grandfather has the Klipsch set and every single song that I played on it has a very boomy bass where the bass should be nonexistant. The FPS2000 has a balanced sound but the bass might not satisfy you at time although it is perfect for me. One thing bad about the FPS2000 is that in UT Tactic OPs area when there are a lot of gun firing, the sounds seem strained.
 
"No tweeters. A full range speaker can't vibrate quickly enough to reproduce highs."

You should look at the Klipsch a little more closely, they have a tweeter. The highs they produce are very accurate.
 


<< You should look at the Klipsch a little more closely, they have a tweeter. The highs they produce are very accurate. >>


That was what I was saying. You should read my post and sig a little more closely.
 
JoeDaddy:


I have a similar setup to what you are planning on. I have two sets of Promedia's in a smaller room with a 27&quot; TV that I watch all my DVD's on with my H+ card. I am not sure what soundcard you have, but I would highly suggest a Philips AE paired with a set of the new Klipsch Promedia's. I had the BA4800's and they were very nice, but they really only have the edge in music clarity, they just can't match the DVD and gaming performance of the Promedia's, IMO. Don't get me wrong, I am not saying the BA4800's are not good with DVD's and games, the more powerful PM's just are a little better in these areas. Also, a 5.1 setup is not really needed in a smaller room unless you have people sitting way off to the side of the screen alot, otherwise the &quot;phantom&quot; center channel of a 4.1 setup like the BA's or the PM's does a very good job with 5.1 downmixing. The DVD performance really must be heard with a Promedia/Acoustic Edge with QMSS setup. I actually had a dedicated 5.1 DD decoder that I returned because the QMSS sounds so much better. Anyway, make sure you get what is best for you, and don't worry because either set is a quality set and they will both perform well. Check out this review from 3D Soundsurge...

&quot; Getting back to the Promedia?s, I found their DVD performance to be excellent using both the SB Live/Dxr3 and Skywell Magic Sound Live/winDVD combinations that I tested with. As I noted before, Klipsch decided to put their muscle into the speaker and amplifier performance instead of decoding and the results are startling. DVD playback is a great test of the dynamic range of a system and the Promedia?s excel in this regard. The Promedia?s have more than enough power to completely fill an above average size computer room or small living room with loud, clean crisp sound with the high end sparkling and explosions thundering! This is not surprising given the systems Multimedia THX speaker certification but it was nice to hear that they lived up to advance billing.&quot;




Promedia Review
 
I decided to be the guinea pig and order the Yamaha TSS-1's. I'll post a review once I get them. What sold me is that it has both coaxial and optical inputs - I have an Aureal Vortex2 SQ2500 with TOSLink, and nearly all the other speaker systems have only coaxial inputs. Saves me the cost of buying a SB Live, and decodes in DTS, I figure it's worth the shot.
 
i'm not really impressed with the specs of that yamaha system. well the subwoofer actually, it's a 5inch 😛
 


<< how do you guys feel about the Videologic Sirocco Crossfire?? >>

Never heard them personally, but from everything I've read they are the best computer speakers you can buy. But they are damn expensive.
 
Noriaki: I got the set at Computers4Sure.com. Price was $172.99 + $13.10 UPS Ground. I found a $10 off $100 at techbargains, and went through Brands4Less (check this link) to get a rebate on the shipping. After I get my rebate check the total cost will be $162.99. The only drawback is that C4S doesn't list whether it's in black or white like Egghead does. Egghead has either color for about $167 + $7 flat rate shipping, which might be worth it if you want to be sure which one you're getting and you don't want to wait for the rebate.

yo2tup: Yeah, these speakers aren't powerful enough for a home theater, but it looks good for a bedroom.

I found this press release on the TSS-1. The MSRP is $229.99, and was set for release in December 2000.
 
another vote for klipsch, you gotta have the tweets, and you gotta have that bass🙂 distortion? Hahaha, yea right, you'll be deaf once you hear it.
 
my promedia's never distort 😛


but i would LOVE to have a set of crossfires.

but if i were to by a new set of speakers for my computer, they wouldn't be multimedia speakers. i'd put together a set of home theater speakers 🙂
 
Keep in mind that speaker preferences are very subjective. (Probably the most subjective of any PC component choice.)

For instance, I don't care for the &quot;shrilly&quot; sound of Klipsch's horn tweeter. Actually, I don't like horn tweeters in general. Even though the BA's don't have a separate tweeter, I still like the quality of the highs better.

I was all set to purchase the Klipsch, when I saw divinemartyr recommend that I listen to the BA's first. And I'm glad he did.

Like I said, it's all subjective. Listen to all of the speakers you are considering.
 
Got my TSS-1's today (finally). Here's a run-down of my first impressions.

Features
5 satellites, amplifier/decoder, and subwoofer. The satellites are deceptively small, cloth covered, with 2&quot; spruce cone drivers. Wasn't very impressed with their appearance at first. The subwoofer is also comparatively small, also with a cloth cover, and a 5&quot; cone driver. All 6 speakers are magnetically shielded. The amp is nice and compact with a small footprint. It has a dial for master volume, and balance dials for the center, surround, and subwoofer speakers. There's also a headphone jack and a power button in the front. There are four keys: Input (toggles among digital, 4 channel, and 2 channel inputs), Mode (toggles between DTS, DD5.1, DD Pro Logic, and off), Test (outputs an alternating pink noise signal that lets you set the balance levels), and Mute.

All the speakers connect via RCA-type plugs to the amp. The 3 center speakers have a 3 m cord and the 2 surrounds have a 7 m cord. I found all the cord lengths to be more than adequate in my bedroom. The TSS-1 comes with an RCA coaxial cable, 2 mini cables, and a cheap looking optical cable (I used a Sony cable instead). The amp has front and rear mini jacks for connections for 4-speaker sound cards in addition to the coaxial and optical S/PDIF inputs. There's also a switch in the back that allows you to switch among 5, 4, and 3 channels. 6W x 5 satellites + 18W x 1 subwoofer = 48W RMS.

Sound
I am connecting through optical S/PDIF to a Vortex2 Superquad. Desktop sounds come across clear, MP3's and CD's play great. The satellites have a nice frequency response and the subwoofer has very tight bass to it, gives a nice powerful 'boom' when needed. Compared to my old speakers (Altec Lansing ACS66), the satellites are much more articulate and less muddy. The Active Servo technology, which was designed to increase the efficiency of bass output, seems well applied. Volume wasn't an issue for me; I couldn't turn it up over 1/3 because I might piss off the people living above. DVD sound was also excellent in PowerDVD 3.0. I played chapters of Goldeneye, True Lies, and M:I-2 using DD5.1 (except for True Lies, for some reason it would default to Pro Logic) and each of the channels sounds discrete and articulated. At times it was a little hard to hear dialogue from the center speaker, but it was improved by adjusting the balance controls. Since this is my first 5.1 system, I was initially wondering why the surrounds were so inaudible, but during action sequences they were involved pretty nicely. My only real complaint is that audio seems too soft in quiet scenes but too loud in action sequences. This might just be a characteristic of DVD, though. Haven't tried DTS yet but the results from DD5.1 look promising. I haven't heard other comparable systems (like the DTT2500) so I can't comment on that. To a audio novice like me, though, it does seem very well powered for a 48W system. Haven't noticed any distortion, and there's no perceptible hiss from any of the speakers (major plus). Overall, looks like a ~$165 well spent on some quality speakers.

BTW, these were in white, which look nice, but I was really hoping I'd get the black ones 😉
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top