Asking for a raise and saying if dont get it you will quit, is that fair?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
you are a contractor because your position is expendable.
you have no ground to stand on.
 

fisheerman

Senior member
Oct 25, 2006
733
0
0
Originally posted by: ZeroIQ
Originally posted by: fisheerman
Originally posted by: ZeroIQ
Originally posted by: GoPackGo
I actually I am in a similar position.

When I started with the company I work for it was for basically local pc and server support.

It has grown to enterprise pc server and support.

and Cisco IP telephony administration

and leading projects such as WSUS deployment, enterprise anti-virus deployment and the Daylight Saving Time project this year.

So I really think I have increased my value but am grossly underpaid.

Our review period is coming up soon...so wish me luck!



Similar situation that I'm in...

I'm doing all the work as a network administrator and a website developer for 12.50... That "intern" title really gets you.

The City council just approved my full time + benefits position for next year, underpaid still. woohoo.


But it's typically not a good idea to tell them you'll quit if you don't get a raise. Even if they do need you, upper management usually has an ego problem.


Um Im not trying to sound like a d%&k but if you are looking for any kinda of fast track growth potential in the IT world then sticking around a government agency is career suicide....It isn't that there aren't great jobs in the government agencies but it is almost impossible to advance rapidly even if you are the best(programmer/analyst/developer/sys admin). Government agency don't have the ability (or will) to fasttrac great employees.

If I were you and you are confident in your skills then I would start looking and ditch that job for a private sector one that will be able to see your potential and profit from it. Once you become an valuable (money generating) producer then the additional pay will follow.

get a good 5-10 years of private experience and then apply for a high end analyst/programmer job in the government if that is your ultimate work environment.

youll command more money and have a lot more experience to back it up.

my 2 cents

-fish

Yeah... I know. But it's a solid job, great resume builder and I'm building tons of references, so by no means is it a bad career choice for the time being. I'll be going to college in October for my bachelors in web development and a masters in business administration while working on all the certificates I can. The private sector really isn't looking for a 19 year old with no degree... and they definitely won't be as willing to work around my schooling. So for now I'm staying, probably until I'm done with school unless they throw more money at me.

/hijack

OP, you can have your topic back now =P

ZeroIQ

I am going to do something that I don't do very often and that is take back my statements. That job may be the best place for you at this point. If you can get some experience as well as the degrees then you will be more marketable. so there i said i may have jumped to conclusions about your situation too fast. I tend to do that sometimes.


But I would challenge you that there are companies (a lot of them) that are willing to take on a 19 year old with no degree. That has been the little secret of the IT realm for a long time (although it is getting harder) is that if you have a passion for this kind of work, can stay on the cutting edge and kick ass in the development environment you can pretty much write your own ticket.

The degrees will mater once you get into the management side of the work (if that is what you are shouting for) but for alot of hard core techies management just ain't in the cards....

I just wanted to point out don't sell yourself short on the age and non degree thing.
the job market is what you make of it. Mold it to what you want it to be.

-fish



 

Syrch

Diamond Member
May 21, 2004
3,382
2
0
ironically heres an article on MSN thats on their home page today...

http://msn.careerbuilder.com/c...b7bba49-237986228-RP-4

You want a raise

Self-audit: Before rushing to your boss and demanding a bump in pay, it's important that you build a case for why you deserve increased compensation. Prepare a list of recent accomplishments that show how you've helped increase profits, improved efficiencies or saved costs to support your cause. Be as specific as possible. If you're in sales, for example, note your year-over-year account comparisons, quarterly highlights and client wins.

Comparison shop: Also find out how much other individuals with your qualifications are being paid in the local market. Many career Web sites, professional associations and staffing services such as Robert Half International publish information about current compensation trends.

Timing is everything: It's also necessary to choose the right time to speak with your manager. Make sure the company can afford to offer raises, that it hasn't recently announced layoffs, for example, and when setting up the meeting, let your supervisor know what you want to discuss so he or she is not caught off guard.

Be professional: Lastly, during the meeting, keep the conversation friendly, even if you two don't see eye-to-eye. After all, in the end, the discussion is between two colleagues working on a single problem: how best to reward your hard work.
 

Axoliien

Senior member
Mar 6, 2002
342
0
0
Don't demand a raise, that's rude and immature. In fact, you would show that you obviously don't understand business practice, business relations, professional courtesy, and professional communication, which are all important aspects to [enter job description here] and therefore are grounds for termination. If you are unhappy then move on and find a new job. You are a professional so act like one.

 

Mxylplyx

Diamond Member
Mar 21, 2007
4,197
101
106
Originally posted by: FoBoT
sure, if you like the job and company, ask for anything

but if they don't respond in a reasonable fashion to a reasonable request (i.e. if you ask for something unreasonable, don't expect anything) then they must not think you are as valuable as you do

this is what i don't get, people that get an "average" rating year after year they, get the average raise, year after year
yet they don't ask the boss what they need to do (or just figure it out themselves) to be a top performer to get the top raises

why would the company give an average guy an above average raise? :confused:

you need to show your boss how you "Added value" to the business and then they'll understand why you should get the "big bucks"

good luck OP :sun: :moon: :clock: :cookie:

In my experience, it's usually the average guys that have the big chip on their shoulder and think their underpaid. People that excel at their work are usually noticed, and they know that they are noticed. Most the ranting I see around this forum about being underappreciated is from PC tech support people. I got news for them. PC Tech support people are a dime a dozen. It doesnt matter if you have 10yrs experience, your still a dime a dozen, so dont expect to ever be paid a high wage. I guess they feel really smart and high valued because the users they deal with on a daily basis are complete idiots.
 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.


I don't know of many supervisors capable of even addressing those concerns. Also you views on that the employee 'owes you' since they knocked on your door is laughable. Most of the time higher level people are contacted by those that find their resumes through recruiters/word of mouth. Your analogy is akin to me walking into a car dealership and telling them to get bent over their invoice pricing; if they want to sell me the car here is $50 bucks and I want it detailed and delivered.

Employment changes...I was hired at one rate for a set of responsibilities. Those responsibilities grew as did my salary.

In today's market depending on what sector you work, you will either be graced with a stream of raises regularly or have to chomp at the bit for them. Usually when I have to go to the table I am asking for more than what I would have expected since now I have to work extra for it and chances are the next one will be the same way.

All in all though threatening off the bat is bad news. First if they absolutely have to have you (this is rare) then they more than likely will meet your needs until they can replace you.

Now if it comes down to them not being able/wanting to meet your demands and you know you have employment at that rate elsewhere (assuming the full packages are equal as hourly wage/salary is really not the biggest part of a package at higher levels)..then you'd be an idiot to stay and they'd be idiots to think you would.

At that stages it's best to agree on a exit strategy that makes everyone at least 'ok'.

If when all is said and done and you feel secure in your ability to find employment elsewhere should they tell you that the cannot or will not listen to your requests at all, then it is absolutely fair to tell them that you will have to look for work elsewhere. Just don't be shocked should they terminate you immediately.


 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Originally posted by: Wheezer

sorry to disappoint but it was a multi billion dollar beverage manufacture.

Toilets need to be cleaned everywhere apparently and someone supervises it.

Originally posted by: Wheezer

In some cases yes...of a head hunter...BUT if YOU initiated contact first AND upon the interview agreed to everything that is laid out then that is your problem to deal with.

Wrong...people change as do jobs, it is both parties problem.

Originally posted by: Wheezer
Feel you are overworked? (who doesn't) leave
Feel your pay is fvcked with? (who doesn't) leave
got a line of potential employers lined around the block to interview you? leave
Wow just wow on those brainstorms. A large portion of the world's workforce would be out seeking new employment if answering 'yes' to anyone of the above dictated that.

Originally posted by: Wheezer
Jobs are not all about money, they are many time about security, benefits and maintaining a good reference, or should you need to go back.

Jobs should never be about maintaining good references or needing to go back to them. You usually don't want to burn any bridges as even if that employer is one you'd never go back to; everyone talks or knows someone else. Kissing ass just to keep up a good reference should you even have too/or get asked to leave is ridiculous.

A job can be about security, but that is a terrible reason just to stay with a job...but like many in bad relationships that is what they go with.

A job should be about satisfaction...plain and simple. One should be satisfied with the pay they are recieving and the work they are doing. For some that satisfaction comes with more pay vs work happiness and others more work happiness vs pay. Usually even with this, you will be overworked at times, you will have situations where you thought compensation would be awarded differently and there will be times when you are simply hot in the market and get contacted to jump ship.

All that said, there are plenty that barely work everyday, have a million resumes out there with nothing to say and have simply no game. They just tread through their lives thinking there is not upward mobility for anyone. There are also those that are so hot, they dictate exactly what they want and when they want it. They jump ship usually at the first opportunity for more money despite any projects left unfinished. Employers usually know this picking them up...but they produce and that's what some need.

 

Cruisin1

Golden Member
Oct 10, 1999
1,119
0
71
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You sure sound like a prick.. thank god I don't work for you.
 

ahartman

Member
Sep 3, 2002
147
0
76
Originally posted by: KrillBee
Has anyone ever been in this situation? Where their current job just isnt paying enough, they are a contractor and want to be an employee, etc.

Suppose the whole compensation package influenced your decision of whether u wanted to stick around or not.
I suppose you could just ask for a raise and quit if you didnt get it. But wouldn't the employer want to know that you might quit if you didnt get the raise?

But if you mentioned the quitting possibility earlier, it would be rude to make it seem like a threat that you'd quit if you didnt get a raise, right?

If you came to me with an ultimatum, ESPECIALLY as a contractor, I'd fire you on general principal.
 

jinduy

Diamond Member
Jan 24, 2002
4,781
1
81
some people are overreacting to wheezer's post... i agree with his statement that you shouldn't threaten off the bat as it's a rather rude business practice and that the right thing to do is negotiate. however you have to come up with LEVERAGE if you're going to negotiate...

do you have a job waiting on the side?
do you 'own' something that few others have knowledge of?
are you a superstar of some sort?
etc.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: Cruisin1
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You sure sound like a prick.. thank god I don't work for you.

I must admit I feel the same way (that Wheezer sounds like a prick).

I would not respond well to an employee threatening to quit over money, but Wheezer sounds like a terrible manager. No one I would ever want to work for.
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
Originally posted by: Cruisin1
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You sure sound like a prick.. thank god I don't work for you.

He may sound like a prick, but that IS the way it works. Wheezer knows he can be easily replaced, so he demands the best from his people. Because his performance is on the line just as staff is.

I was called a troll earlier, but that is the flat out truth. Anybody can be replaced no matter what their level. It's just business. Seriously, it's just business. Learn to play or don't play the game.
 

r6ashih

Senior member
May 29, 2003
667
0
0
I just approached my boss today to express interest in getting picked up full time. I started 2 months ago as a contractor as a Help Desk person assisting the system administrator. Well the system admin left last week and now i'm the only IT guy trying to keep things running.

I didnt say i would quit or anything but I am the ONLY IT guy in the office for 50+people and the boss man asked me what i expected for a salary. I replied that i wasnt sure yet and that i only want a fair value. Boss man then throws out some numbers like 25k, 28k..

LOL should i quit?

I'm a college graduate with 3 years of technical experience.. just not any major systems administration which i hope to get into.


 

pstylesss

Platinum Member
Mar 21, 2007
2,914
0
0
Originally posted by: r6ashih
I just approached my boss today to express interest in getting picked up full time. I started 2 months ago as a contractor as a Help Desk person assisting the system administrator. Well the system admin left last week and now i'm the only IT guy trying to keep things running.

I didnt say i would quit or anything but I am the ONLY IT guy in the office for 50+people and the boss man asked me what i expected for a salary. I replied that i wasnt sure yet and that i only want a fair value. Boss man then throws out some numbers like 25k, 28k..

LOL should i quit?

I'm a college graduate with 3 years of technical experience.. just not any major systems administration which i hope to get into.

What qualifications do you have? What does the company need? Can you offer it to them? What is the median salary for your position? Do you want a position change?

Get all your ducks in a row, then go talk to him. It seems as if they need you. I'm a HS graduate, and I'll be making close to twice what your boss offered come January. Of course our needs are different and we have more people... but that doesn't make your position any less important.

Sounds like you're in a sweet spot right now, IMO.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You do realize that loyalty to a company is dead in this day and age, right? You will lose the skilled people and retain those that know that they are so lousy at their job that they can't get a job anyplace else.

In short, as an employer the only one you are screwing is yourself.
 

jackace

Golden Member
Oct 6, 2004
1,307
0
0
Originally posted by: spidey07
Originally posted by: Cruisin1
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You sure sound like a prick.. thank god I don't work for you.

He may sound like a prick, but that IS the way it works. Wheezer knows he can be easily replaced, so he demands the best from his people. Because his performance is on the line just as staff is.

I was called a troll earlier, but that is the flat out truth. Anybody can be replaced no matter what their level. It's just business. Seriously, it's just business. Learn to play or don't play the game.

The problem Wheezer did not address is what if this person has been with you for 10 years and has not received many if any raises in those 10 years. Sure 10 years ago the terms of our agreement were fine, but they might not be adequate any longer.

AS far as the tone and method. I too agree you never go in and give them an ultimatum, but you can try and negotiate first. If you are not happy with the results you then tell your boss thank you, but that still does not meet my needs and put in your 2 week notice.

Honestly with the current corporate america most employers do not realize how valuable you were until you leave. Both my parents have had to leave their jobs for higher paying jobs every 4-7 years just to receive decent pay increases. Its the current trend in our business world today. No longer do most employers hang on to good employees and pay them well. They would rather milk you for all you are worth then let you go.

My father for example is an engineer. He had to leave his job with a fortune 500 company for a smaller company because they refused to give him a decent raise. 5 years later he sees his old job posted and the pay range is now 20k more then what he was making. He applied again and got the job. Both my parents have told me the best way to get a raise is always be looking for a new job. Do not screw over your current employer, but always be looking for something better. Corporate America is not going to look out for you so you have to lookout for yourself.
 

gsethi

Diamond Member
Feb 28, 2002
3,457
5
81
Originally posted by: spidey07
Originally posted by: Cruisin1
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You sure sound like a prick.. thank god I don't work for you.

He may sound like a prick, but that IS the way it works. Wheezer knows he can be easily replaced, so he demands the best from his people. Because his performance is on the line just as staff is.

I was called a troll earlier, but that is the flat out truth. Anybody can be replaced no matter what their level. It's just business. Seriously, it's just business. Learn to play or don't play the game.

Well said. Remember, the company that you are working for right now was still running before you joined (except if you started it). And it will still be running (if it is profitable) long after you are gone.

Each and everyone is replaceable. Everyone and that includes the owners, presidents etc. etc. What if you die all of a sudden ? the company will still run. Quitting from the company is no different.

People just think that they have become too important. Remember, the world has been going on for tons of years and I am sure that it has tons more for sure. Businesses were running long ago, they are still running and they will continue to run. Its only the people and faces that change over time.

I am probably going to fire a person this week or next week at my business. Why ? He thinks that he deserves more $$$ (he was telling my manager that he should get a raise) while in reality, he is my worst employee on my list. Better to let that person go.

Such is the Corportate/Business world (doesnt matter if you are working at min. wage at Fast Food Restaurant or you are some experienced senior level tech at a multi-billion dollar company).
 

jackace

Golden Member
Oct 6, 2004
1,307
0
0
Originally posted by: gsethi
Originally posted by: spidey07
Originally posted by: Cruisin1
Originally posted by: Wheezer
As a supervisor, I have had plenty of employees come to me and tell me that "if I don't get more money, I am going to quit and go somewhere else"....my response?

Don't let the door hit your ass one the way out.

Asking for a raise is understandable. There is a right way and a wrong way to do it.

Threating to quit if you don't get it...well there is grounds for termination in my eyes right there.

Exactly who the hell do you think you are and how valuable do you think you are that I cannot replace you?....after all when you submitted your resume, or application...YOU came to ME...remember?

You asked me for a job first...I never knocked on your door, and when we sat down for an interview I laid it all out for you including the pay...you agreed and here we are...and now after giving you an opportunity you threaten me?

get the fvck out....I will find someone else.

been down that road many a time...generally speaking the ones that pull this crap weren't much to start with anyway.

You sure sound like a prick.. thank god I don't work for you.

He may sound like a prick, but that IS the way it works. Wheezer knows he can be easily replaced, so he demands the best from his people. Because his performance is on the line just as staff is.

I was called a troll earlier, but that is the flat out truth. Anybody can be replaced no matter what their level. It's just business. Seriously, it's just business. Learn to play or don't play the game.

Well said. Remember, the company that you are working for right now was still running before you joined (except if you started it). And it will still be running (if it is profitable) long after you are gone.

Each and everyone is replaceable. Everyone and that includes the owners, presidents etc. etc. What if you die all of a sudden ? the company will still run. Quitting from the company is no different.

People just think that they have become too important. Remember, the world has been going on for tons of years and I am sure that it has tons more for sure. Businesses were running long ago, they are still running and they will continue to run. Its only the people and faces that change over time.

I am probably going to fire a person this week or next week at my business. Why ? He thinks that he deserves more $$$ (he was telling my manager that he should get a raise) while in reality, he is my worst employee on my list. Better to let that person go.

Such is the Corportate/Business world (doesnt matter if you are working at min. wage at Fast Food Restaurant or you are some experienced senior level tech at a multi-billion dollar company).

That part is not always true. My mother used to run a medical facility. After she left the facility had to hire 2 people to do her job, and even then they began to lose money. Some people are just good at their jobs. The problem is most corporate america supervisors do not realize how important and key those people were until they leave. In my mother's case her boss called her up 4 months later and offered her old job back with a 30k raise. She refused because she had enrolled in school, but she did agree to contract work with them to help them get things running right again.
 

gsethi

Diamond Member
Feb 28, 2002
3,457
5
81
Originally posted by: jackace

That part is not always true. My mother used to run a medical facility. After she left the facility had to hire 2 people to do her job, and even then they began to lose money. Some people are just good at their jobs. The problem is most corporate america supervisors do not realize how important and key those people were until they leave. In my mother's case her boss called her up 4 months later and offered her old job back with a 30k raise. She refused because she had enrolled in school, but she did agree to contract work with them to help them get things running right again.

yes, in some cases, the business (and the owner) will go through troubles when they let someone go (like in the case of your mother).

Same thing happened with my mother. She was running a place perfectly for over 8 years. And then one day, the owner came and insulted her infront of junior employees and told her to leave. She left the workplace and never looked back. 2 weeks later, the owner was literally pleading my mother to come back and join but she refused. Less than a year later, that business was sold to someone else, BUT, from what I have heard last, the new owner is running the business (not as good as my mom used to run it but it is getting back there).

So yes, there might be hard times in some cases, but again, Everyone is replaceable. I am running 2 businesses right now but what if I die tomorrow ? There are many things in my business that only I know how to do (I keep thinking that I need to train atleast one other person (just in case) so that he/she knows everything but I dont have the time to train yet :( )
 

jackace

Golden Member
Oct 6, 2004
1,307
0
0
Originally posted by: gsethi
Originally posted by: jackace

That part is not always true. My mother used to run a medical facility. After she left the facility had to hire 2 people to do her job, and even then they began to lose money. Some people are just good at their jobs. The problem is most corporate america supervisors do not realize how important and key those people were until they leave. In my mother's case her boss called her up 4 months later and offered her old job back with a 30k raise. She refused because she had enrolled in school, but she did agree to contract work with them to help them get things running right again.

yes, in some cases, the business (and the owner) will go through troubles when they let someone go (like in the case of your mother).

Same thing happened with my mother. She was running a place perfectly for over 8 years. And then one day, the owner came and insulted her infront of junior employees and told her to leave. She left the workplace and never looked back. 2 weeks later, the owner was literally pleading my mother to come back and join but she refused. Less than a year later, that business was sold to someone else, BUT, from what I have heard last, the new owner is running the business (not as good as my mom used to run it but it is getting back there).

So yes, there might be hard times in some cases, but again, Everyone is replaceable. I am running 2 businesses right now but what if I die tomorrow ? There are many things in my business that only I know how to do (I keep thinking that I need to train atleast one other person (just in case) so that he/she knows everything but I dont have the time to train yet :( )

My point was that a lot of business people today take the initial short-sided cheap route, and it actually ends up costing them more money then if they had just given a good worker a raise. I know for a fact the medical facility my mother managed still today is not profitable, but when she managed it they were. That was over 5 years ago now. A lot of employers want good people as cheap as possible. That seems to be the mentality today in business. In order to counter act this mind set an employee has to be willing to change jobs, and they have to always be looking for something better.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
You are going to bring in someone new, a man you don't really have a clue about, you'll have to spend time training this person for his job, he may not fit in with the rest of the staff and so on and so forth.

The cost of hiring is VERY high initially and chances are that if he's any good at his job and you treat him like Wheezer treats his employees he will be gone before he's done enough work to make up for that cost.

Let's not be stupid about this, we ALL know that it is the good workers that carry the company on their shoulders and if a company has someone willing to fire people because of their attitude even if they do a great job then that company is going to go down.