what i don't get is why i see some blacks speak ebonics on purpose. i remember working with some black folk in a professional setting. once they were in a casual setting among other blacks, they'd digress into ebonics.
Exactly. Oprah does this all the time. If she has a black guest, when speaking to the guest she'll put on the characteristic heckles and affected gutteral laugh, and switch to the"mah mama sayd" way of speaking.
Its not about whether its "valid" or not. Whether its a "dialect". Actually, I believe it is a dialect, but a dialect is only such because so many speak it, right? And that goes back to my point. As skoorb correctly explained, its a mass-ignorance that has become a cultural artifact. The process is no different than any other culture - its just sad that what's being codified are unproductive and detrimental behavior.
And here's the big question Why does something Cultural have to be preserved if it is detrimental? Why shouldn't India, as it has been doing, try to do away with female circumcision, and wife-burning? These are products of ignorance just like ebonics! But the government there is trying to eradicate it and it is now largely confined to the rural villages, where, SURPRISE SURPISE, the dumbest and most ignorant live. Even there it will soon be wiped out.
But here, no....the liberal arts bunch wants to sit in a circle and just spoud "good things" for just the sake of doing so. Patching up differences, rather than attacking and understanding those differnces, which is the true way to progess...
Oh, forget it. I'm getting tired.
