Are You Raising Another Man's Child?

Aug 25, 2004
11,151
1
81
Well, are ya?

Patrick Connaro, a 42-year-old robotics engineer living in Colorado Springs, was sitting in the bleachers one warm Saturday afternoon in 2003, watching his son's Little League game, when the ground opened beneath him.

"My little boy was there, he was up at bat, and I started yelling for him, 'Go Matthew [not his real name]! Knock it out of the park!' And another man started screaming for Matthew. Louder than me. I looked over, and I looked at him, and I was like, Who is this guy? And I looked at my son, and I looked at him . . . and they were identical."

After the ball game, Connaro ordered a paternity test. The results came back 2 weeks later. "I opened up the letter from Labcorp, and it said, ' . . . 99.9 percent chance you are not the biological father of this child.' I started crying. My head started spinning."

Connaro admits that the possibility had crossed his mind before, given his son's dissimilar facial features, but each time he questioned his wife about it, she vehemently denied the suggestion. Even when he showed her the test results, she still denied it. "She said, 'You forged this,' " Connaro recalls, shaking his head in amazement.
 

Luthien

Golden Member
Feb 1, 2004
1,721
0
0
Originally posted by: leftyman
That explains the nappy hair...


oh, ooh the racist police are comming. Al sharpcunt is going to sue your butt off.

---

Post another one like that, and I'll boot your butt off the forums for awhile.

AnandTech Moderator
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
How can his wife deny it with DNA test results of 99.9% accuracy? Time to come clean and spill the beans.
 

gwrober

Golden Member
Sep 3, 2005
1,293
0
0
Originally posted by: Bateluer
How can his wife deny it with DNA test results of 99.9% accuracy? Time to come clean and spill the beans.

Exactly - and obviously the real father knows, he's there cheering. But what about the kid? Does the kid know? Men's Health is blocked here. :(
 

Juddog

Diamond Member
Dec 11, 2006
7,851
6
81
This has Jerry Springer written all over it. All we need now are a couple chairs to throw around.
 

DaShen

Lifer
Dec 1, 2000
10,710
1
0
Originally posted by: gwrober
Originally posted by: Bateluer
How can his wife deny it with DNA test results of 99.9% accuracy? Time to come clean and spill the beans.

Exactly - and obviously the real father knows, he's there cheering. But what about the kid? Does the kid know? Men's Health is blocked here. :(

The guy at least deserves the truth/honesty. It really sucks to be him...
 

SagaLore

Elite Member
Dec 18, 2001
24,036
21
81
This reminds me of that awesome craigslist post about the guy who had a vasectomy and the girl who got pregnant pretending it was his.
 

bignateyk

Lifer
Apr 22, 2002
11,288
7
0
That sucks.

I'd like to think that after having raised a child from birth, it wouldnt matter to me if I found out it wasnt mine (from a standpoint of loving the child), but until you are in the situation, its hard to say.

I think what would bother me is the fact that my wife lied about something like that. I think I could keep raising the child the same way as my own, but the wife would probably have to go.
 

theknight571

Platinum Member
Mar 23, 2001
2,896
2
81
Originally posted by: bignateyk
That sucks.

I'd like to think that after having raised a child from birth, it wouldnt matter to me if I found out it wasnt mine (from a standpoint of loving the child), but until you are in the situation, its hard to say.

I think what would bother me is the fact that my wife lied about something like that. I think I could keep raising the child the same way as my own, but the wife would probably have to go.

I agree... I think I would be more bothered by the wife's actions than with the fact the kid isn't really mine.

 

Averyel

Junior Member
Aug 15, 2001
19
0
66
That article is really good. There was one in there about a guy who after his divorce was final, he found out his daughter was his after 18 yrs. She wont speak to him either, like it was his fault. Darn shame.
 

Bryan

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,070
5
86
To answer your question. Yes. Yes, I am. The moment of truth was the single worst moment of my life, and it haunts me every day.
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: Bateluer
How can his wife deny it with DNA test results of 99.9% accuracy? Time to come clean and spill the beans.

maybe she doesn't know? i can see it happening. although, in this situation, if the other guy yelling for the kid really is the father and knows, then yeah, the wife is obviously lying.
 

sixone

Lifer
May 3, 2004
25,030
5
61
From the article:
To this day he remembers that game with a kind of nightmarish clarity. Matthew struck out. Connaro had planned on going over and giving him a hug, along with a few words of fatherly consolation, but when he heard the other guy yelling, he just stood up and walked away.

What a selfish bastard. Maybe the kid would be better off with another father.

 

iroast

Golden Member
May 5, 2005
1,364
3
81
Originally posted by: SagaLore
This reminds me of that awesome craigslist post about the guy who had a vasectomy and the girl who got pregnant pretending it was his.

There's still a very small chance of one soldier breaking through the barrier.
 

MrPickins

Diamond Member
May 24, 2003
9,124
787
126
That was a good read, thanks for posting.

As others have said: if, god forbid, I was ever in this situation, I'd definitely try to maintain a relationship with the child, but the wife's betrayal would end the marraige.
 

Alkaline5

Senior member
Jun 21, 2001
801
0
0
Originally posted by: MrPickins
That was a good read, thanks for posting.

As others have said: if, god forbid, I was ever in this situation, I'd definitely try to maintain a relationship with the child, but the wife's betrayal would end the marraige.
Would you have any legal right to see the child after the marriage ended? Technically you might still have partial legal guardianship after the divorce, but it sees like the biological parents could easily dispute that in court.
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: Alkaline5
Originally posted by: MrPickins
That was a good read, thanks for posting.

As others have said: if, god forbid, I was ever in this situation, I'd definitely try to maintain a relationship with the child, but the wife's betrayal would end the marraige.
Would you have any legal right to see the child after the marriage ended? Technically you might still have partial legal guardianship after the divorce, but it sees like the biological parents could easily dispute that in court.

i would think you would. Just as the mother has the right to get child support.
 

MrPickins

Diamond Member
May 24, 2003
9,124
787
126
Originally posted by: Alkaline5
Originally posted by: MrPickins
That was a good read, thanks for posting.

As others have said: if, god forbid, I was ever in this situation, I'd definitely try to maintain a relationship with the child, but the wife's betrayal would end the marraige.
Would you have any legal right to see the child after the marriage ended? Technically you might still have partial legal guardianship after the divorce, but it sees like the biological parents could easily dispute that in court.

Very often men are found to be financially responsible for a child even when paternity tests show that he is not the father. I'd like to think that the courts would allow the man at least visitation rights with the child also.

From what I gather, the name on the birth cert. is what is legally significant.
 

ryan256

Platinum Member
Jul 22, 2005
2,514
0
71
...there is no greater deception than paternal discrepancy...
...this lie unravels years of commitment in a single stroke...
God forbid I ever end up in a situation like this. But if it did I would never discard a kid I had raised as my own child because the mother was a whore.
 

Andy22

Golden Member
Jun 8, 2001
1,425
0
71
Long story...

My wife and I had an open marriage. The only rules were she had to tell me about it and she had to be careful. There's obviously a lot of details in there I am leaving out but really the wherefore and the why of our open marriage is another story entirely.

She calls me one day crying saying she just took a pregnancy test and she was pregnant. I left work and on the way home was trying to figure out why she was so upset since we had been trying for going on 4 years with no success. At first her explanation was that she was worried about the health of the baby because she had unknowingly gone to the tanning bed and had some alcohol. However, the level at which she was upset far exceeded that. Finally the lightbulb went off and I said "You don't think it's mine do you" and that is of course why she was so upset. We looked back at the time of conception it could have been either of us as the father. I was really anxious to be a father but definitely wanted it to be my blood. However, it was our bed we made so we had to lie in it and make the best of it. I decided regardless of the outcome I would raise the child as if it was my own.

When she was born there was a connection as if she was indeed my own. There was of course that doubt during the first year as we both tried to determine if she looked at all like me. Most people who saw pictures would say..."she must look like her mother" which always made me cringe. At about a year we had a paternity test done and a few weeks later I got a call with the results over the phone...they verified who I was and then said "99.9% chance you are not the biological father". My heart sank. But I had already built such an intense closeness to her that it did not affect the way I felt...she was my daughter. Our two closest friends are the only two that know us that know about our secret. Everyone else just assumes she looks more like her mother. An odd coincidence is that we are both left handed so that helps. We had our second daughter 3 years later and she is a spitting image of me, especially when I was her age and she looks almost nothing like her sister.

So far it has all turned out ok...I have two daughters that I love with all my heart but one day I am going to have to explain the situation and that will be hard on all of us I am sure.

Cliff Notes:

Not Available...read the whole story.