Apparently I'm not christian?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

axelfox

Diamond Member
Oct 13, 1999
6,719
1
0
next time you think they are "just words" talk to a child with those words.

Words can be powerful.
 

Mill

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
28,558
3
81
Originally posted by: neomits
Originally posted by: BatmanNate
I wasn't under the impression that Linkin Park was a Christian band. Also, Creed and POD aren't proclaimed Christian status bands either, they just have some members that are more or less aligned with that theology, but they do not use the music as a tool of worship or praise as is the status quo in "Christian" bands. Regardless of musical preference, this girl seems like a bit of a dunce to me.


LOL K-Love

POD was under a Christian label until they got big and needed a bigger label. Creed you are right... doesn't sing Christian messages but sometimes the meanings can be taken with a Christian slant and if you ask them if they are christians, I'd almost guarentee they'd say yes. (the lead singer is the son of a preacher)

Lifehouse is another band like them.


I have met Scott's Youth Pastor before. He said Scott says the he has a relationship with God but doesn't consider it to be christianity.
 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
as far as i'm concerned, if you believe jesus christ was the son of god, you're christian.
 

Martin

Lifer
Jan 15, 2000
29,178
1
81
Tell her to check out this great new chritian band called "Tool" and their new hit "Opiate" ;)
 

Maetryx

Diamond Member
Jan 18, 2001
4,849
1
81
I have been collecting Christian rock music since about 1983 or so. I'm pretty familiar with its history, and even *more* familiar with the attitudes like the one that girl you were chatting with was exhibiting. I've heard and had most of those attitudes myself at some point or other as I was growing up and trying to figure out my own beliefs regarding the morality of listening to music.

I pretty much don't sweat it anymore. I have 2 big CD racks full of Christian rock CDs and 1 big CD rack about 3/4 full of regular rock CDs. I used to try and believe that Christian rock just sounded better than secular rock (ha! okay some does but a lot doesn't). I used to be all concerned that the band Trouble made Christian themed albums but they themselves were not Christians. I used to freak out that Amy Grant wore leaopard skin coats and moved to a secular label.

Now I just buy whatever I like. I am no longer at the age where some band is going to influence me in my beliefs or worldview. I think I destroyed one secular CD because I felt that it was morally unredeemable (the theme of the album was necrophilia). At this point I don't even think I'd do that anymore.

The secure Christian has nothing to fear from music. A lot of the time it's the church-talking holier-than-thou type that have all the problems with music. You know, I grew up actually believing that KISS stood for Kids In Satan's Service and that AC/DC meant Anti-Christ/Devils Children? Chick tracts taught me that witches gathered on a pentagram to curse the masters of every rock album so that everyone listening to it would have demons entering them.

It's just sad. What a waste of time. Instead of being taught the essential doctrines of orthodox Christianity, instead of studying the early church fathers, I was poisoned with Halloween paranoia and rock music guilt and TV preacher admiration.
 

Skyclad1uhm1

Lifer
Aug 10, 2001
11,383
87
91
Originally posted by: Maetryx
I have been collecting Christian rock music since about 1983 or so. I'm pretty familiar with its history, and even *more* familiar with the attitudes like the one that girl you were chatting with was exhibiting. I've heard and had most of those attitudes myself at some point or other as I was growing up and trying to figure out my own beliefs regarding the morality of listening to music.

I pretty much don't sweat it anymore. I have 2 big CD racks full of Christian rock CDs and 1 big CD rack about 3/4 full of regular rock CDs. I used to try and believe that Christian rock just sounded better than secular rock (ha! okay some does but a lot doesn't). I used to be all concerned that the band Trouble made Christian themed albums but they themselves were not Christians. I used to freak out that Amy Grant wore leaopard skin coats and moved to a secular label.

Now I just buy whatever I like. I am no longer at the age where some band is going to influence me in my beliefs or worldview. I think I destroyed one secular CD because I felt that it was morally unredeemable (the theme of the album was necrophilia). At this point I don't even think I'd do that anymore.

The secure Christian has nothing to fear from music. A lot of the time it's the church-talking holier-than-thou type that have all the problems with music. You know, I grew up actually believing that KISS stood for Kids In Satan's Service and that AC/DC meant Anti-Christ/Devils Children? Chick tracts taught me that witches gathered on a pentagram to curse the masters of every rock album so that everyone listening to it would have demons entering them.

It's just sad. What a waste of time. Instead of being taught the essential doctrines of orthodox Christianity, instead of studying the early church fathers, I was poisoned with Halloween paranoia and rock music guilt and TV preacher admiration.

LOL!

Sorry, but... LOL!
 

Eli

Super Moderator | Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
50,419
8
81
Originally posted by: gopunk
as far as i'm concerned, if you believe jesus christ was the son of god, you're christian.

I don't consider myself apart of any religion.. I've never gone to church, or anything like that..

My belief system is my own... It borrows from all beliefs...

 

Maetryx

Diamond Member
Jan 18, 2001
4,849
1
81
Originally posted by: Skyclad1uhm1

LOL!

Sorry, but... LOL!


I know man! What a joke, right? But I just *know* that someone reading this was raised just like I was. They probably just quit trying and went out on their way and stopped going to church and just silenced the part of their mind that just knows there is something to Christianity but it just didn't make any sense anymore.
 

xirtam

Diamond Member
Aug 25, 2001
4,693
0
0
as far as i'm concerned, if you believe jesus christ was the son of god, you're christian.

How is that not like saying that if you believe that Stephen Hawking is an intellectual genius, you're a physicist? I'd hope that there's more to Christianity than believing some obscure fact about someone else, or that because you're born in America you're a Christian. (I've heard that one too, and I don't see what the justification is for it. It's not like being born in a garage makes you a car.)

As far as premarital sex is concerned, I don't think it exists. I think that sex makes you married -- it certainly does a whole lot more for your relationship than some old guy with a white beard pronouncing you man and wife and making you kiss and throwing rice at you. So if you have that view, you're only going to have sex with one partner or you wind up a polygamist. Of course, not in legal terms, but still... so how do you determine your involvement in a relationship? Well, I've kind of adopted the view that I should go no further in my own relationships than I want the schmuck who's currently dating my wife-to-be to go.

Yeah... ask her what makes Linkin Park a Christian band, and play some Creed for her that "swears." Then break out POD's Southtown and ask her what the heck that song does to promote the cause of Christ.

In a more argumentative mood with this particular girl, my argument would go something like this:

"Oh... so I'm not Christian because I listen to satanists. So am I a satanist because I listen to satanists? I am? Are you listening to me?" :D
 

tokamak

Golden Member
Nov 26, 1999
1,072
0
0
slayer very rarely 'swears' (lame word for cussing, btw) in their songs. i guess that makes them christian, right? :D
 

flexy

Diamond Member
Sep 28, 2001
8,464
155
106
Originally posted by: Eli
Originally posted by: gopunk
as far as i'm concerned, if you believe jesus christ was the son of god, you're christian.

I don't consider myself apart of any religion.. I've never gone to church, or anything like that..

My belief system is my own... It borrows from all beliefs...


The problem is that there are many 'whackos' around which proclaim to be 'real christians' in comparison to many 'normal' people with a christian belief - this fanatic 'christianity' is nothing else than practicing the 'institutional' church - and often is very much recognizable by an extreme closemindedness in regards to our current society.
("No sex before marriage...blah bla...and all the other stuff they think is 'needed' to be a 'real christ')

This totally scares me (as fanatics in general scare me)...since (i ithink) most of fanatics dont use their brains but act 'non logical'...and therefore are kinda scary...and of course you cant come such people with arguments - the argument will always bounce back from a wall of pre-judgement and closed mindedness and 'belief'. (If you know what i mean :)

I (for myself) would also rather claim to have 'my own philosophy'....(bein a born catholic :)...but after a lot of thinking once i came to the conclusion that the real Jesus (what he said...what he wanted etc...) was probably really a 'cool' guy...and his 'teachings' had SENSE (it needs some time to realize that).

So....i'd consider myself kinda 'christian' and would be very angry hearing from some fanatic i am NOT real chrstian (whatever) because i dont follow their exact listed points of what they think is necessary (or what the institution "Church" thinks is necessary :)

I think Jesus had a good portion of common sense for his time...and he had an interesting way trying to tell people how to live best together happily....no violence...etc..etc...but the teachings of the church and rituals of fanatics nowadays have *nothing* to do with that common sense...imho...

my $0.2...otherwise i (of course) tolerate every religion whatsoever..as long as it isn't accompanied by this certain arrogance ("You are wrong..you are a sinner...WE are better...blah blah")..and even here jesus already was WAYYYY better than all that religion freaks TODAY...because he actually *taught* tolerance, it was one key element actually...


(I konw this discussion could go on forever :)


 

Tominator

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
9,559
1
0
Originally posted by: Ameesh
Originally posted by: Tominator
Christian literally means Christ Like.


jesus christ was a jew.

So???? What's that got a thing to do with what I said?



Swearing.. Hmm.. Doesen't everbody swear? Like others have said.. They're just words..

Actually any outward evidence of anger may breed agression and escalate a situation. Not to mention the negative influence it has on children. I nere ever head either of my grand fathers say just one cuss word and cannot ever remember seeing either angry. I've only heard my own father cuss one time and my mom never.

As far as sex outside of marriage.. Why would it be bad for a relationship? And how in the world could it be deadly? You mean STDs? Hmm...

In this age I guess it's a secret but if you were both virgins at the time of marrage it is highly unlikely you would ever get divorced.....but since divorce [selfishness] is so accepted today I guess could cause it's own discussion. There are about 30 different deadly diseases spred by everything from kissing to actual intercourse. Rubbers stop only a few. They are epidemic btw....


Jesus proclaims that all organized religion is an abomination..

Where did you hear this?

Having a 'personl relationship with Jesus' is only a small part of being a Christian.....
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
You know, I grew up actually believing that KISS stood for Kids In Satan's Service and that AC/DC meant Anti-Christ/Devils Children?
Hehe..Christian Fund a Mental Cases are just as Dangerous as Islamic Fund A Mental Cases. The main difference from my perspective is that Islamic Fund A Mental Cases Destroy life where as Christian Fund A Mental Cases Destroy the Mind.
 

CraigRT

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
31,440
5
0
That is so INCREDIBLY retarded it makes me want to puke on my shoe!
how do people like that get so brainwashed??? that is so damn silly it's laughable.. ahaha.. as if any normal people care about religion anyways.. *puts hand up*
 

Demon-Xanth

Lifer
Feb 15, 2000
20,551
2
81
I'd just like to plug my religion:

The Holy Order of Gaming.
The biggest upside: we can prove our gods exist :)


OKay, now that that's out in the open, I think alot of "christian" fanboys tend to forget the difference between the spirit of the "rules" and the absolute quest for godliness. If swearing will make you go to hell I don't want to go to heaven. Noone I know will be there. If listening to "satanic" music or playing "satanic" games will make you go to hell, I might as well commit a triple homicide because my chances for heaven are GONE! The real spirit of the rules basically boil down to "don't be an asshole".
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Demon-Xanth, you don't seem to get it. It's all about mind control. No not by the Artists who put out thje so-called "Satanic music" but by those who tell you what you should listen too. THe more they control your mind the easier it is to brain wash you into believing the unbelievable.
 

F117NightHawk

Senior member
Aug 18, 2001
216
0
0
When I was younger I went thru a conservative phase too. During that time I wouldn't watch any TV shows that had violence or sex in them (like Married with Children) and I wouldn't listen to any music that wasn't played on the local Christian station (except oldies). I tried to be conservative, but I found it just wasn't in me.

In the end I decided that a strong Christian can listen to any kind of music they want and watch anything they want and just leave alone what you find offensive. I believe God gives us liberty to make those choices. There was something in the Bible about how some believers are weaker and will only eat vegetables and others are stronger and will eat meat sacrified to idols. Neither is wrong in what they do, but the one who can eat the meat does have a duty not to offend the one who doesn't. Therefore when I'm around conservative Christians I don't talk about the music I listen to or TV shows I watch cause I don't wish to offend them.

It's all about live and let live.
 

CraigRT

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
31,440
5
0
It's all about live and let live.

Totally!

it sucks when you see people brainwashed and dragged around by religion as if it matters for some reason.. it's a shame... :disgust: