Any gay ATOT'ers here?

Page 7 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

bob4432

Lifer
Sep 6, 2003
11,727
46
91
Originally posted by: Mrfrog840
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: Citrix
Originally posted by: moshquerade
imho, no one chooses to be gay. they are just born that way.

The spark that will cause the flames was just struck.
explain your comment.

I think he's saying that there are people who will disagree with you and this will turn into a flame war. But you were really just restating what the OP said, so he really can't blame you.
i welcome anyone to disagree with me, and i'd really like to hear an explanation of their position on the issue.

I disagree with you. I see no flames.

That was a very ignorant first statement moshquerade

You are not "born" gay. It is a lifestyle choice.
There have been people that choose to be gay, and then turned and choose to be straight.

You are not born gay. You cannot be born gay.. That is probably one of the most craziest things I have heard in awhile.

God did NOT intend for there to be homosexuals. If he did, he would of created adam and steve, not adam and eve.

MAN AND A WOMAN, NOT MAN AND MAN, or WOMAN AND WOMAN.

i highly doubt you would turn away from some hot lesbian action between jenna jameson and krystal steel....

maybe you can wrap your small viewed mind around this - god didn't create us, but rather we evolved????
 

Ryan

Lifer
Oct 31, 2000
27,519
2
81
Originally posted by: Mrfrog840
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: Citrix
Originally posted by: moshquerade
imho, no one chooses to be gay. they are just born that way.

The spark that will cause the flames was just struck.
explain your comment.

I think he's saying that there are people who will disagree with you and this will turn into a flame war. But you were really just restating what the OP said, so he really can't blame you.
i welcome anyone to disagree with me, and i'd really like to hear an explanation of their position on the issue.

I disagree with you. I see no flames.

That was a very ignorant first statement moshquerade

You are not "born" gay. It is a lifestyle choice.
There have been people that choose to be gay, and then turned and choose to be straight.

You are not born gay. You cannot be born gay.. That is probably one of the most craziest things I have heard in awhile.

God did NOT intend for there to be homosexuals. If he did, he would of created adam and steve, not adam and eve.

MAN AND A WOMAN, NOT MAN AND MAN, or WOMAN AND WOMAN.

Definitely an Official member of the "I'm a fvcking moron, look at me make a bigoted ass out of myself" Crew.
 

scott916

Platinum Member
Mar 2, 2005
2,906
0
71
Oppression of gay americans is truly one of the saddest aspects of our society, IMO. Although I myself am not gay, I do have a gay cousin and I have seen the effects of ignorance on people close to me.

If anyone remembers the transgender teacher Dana Rivers that came out with his true feelings around 1999-2000, he was a teacher of mine in High School. Mr. Warfield (Rivers) was the best teacher I have ever had, bar none. He was incredibly intelligent, understanding, and truthful, and had more impact on the lives of the kids that he taught than anyone I have ever met.

When it was revealed that he was transgendered, his image and reputation were put through the wringer, with Bible thumping parents speaking out about the atrocities of letting such a person influence their children, with no care in the world about his career or feelings. They spoke down about how he would somehow change kids into "queers", when all he had done is show people the fundamental greatness of the human spirit. It was truly sad to see the anger and fear that such an issue put into the hearts of parents. Although they believed they were acting in the best interests of their children, all they did was propogate the ignorance that seems to be sadly so prevalent in our society.

He lost his career, his life, his wife, and a great deal of the people around him. I know staff members who called him one of their best friends before they found out he was a transgendered man, and now abhorred him and labeled him a freak and a disgusting person. I truly admire him, he had the courage to stand up and show his true feelings to all, even though he had to know the consequences. I can only hope we can move as a society and as the entire human race towards a world where we can at least realize that people who are born a certain way are simply that, and not sick freaks who make this choice and are out to harm others.
 

AreaCode707

Lifer
Sep 21, 2001
18,447
133
106
Originally posted by: Ryan
Originally posted by: Mrfrog840
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: Citrix
Originally posted by: moshquerade
imho, no one chooses to be gay. they are just born that way.

The spark that will cause the flames was just struck.
explain your comment.

I think he's saying that there are people who will disagree with you and this will turn into a flame war. But you were really just restating what the OP said, so he really can't blame you.
i welcome anyone to disagree with me, and i'd really like to hear an explanation of their position on the issue.

I disagree with you. I see no flames.

That was a very ignorant first statement moshquerade

You are not "born" gay. It is a lifestyle choice.
There have been people that choose to be gay, and then turned and choose to be straight.

You are not born gay. You cannot be born gay.. That is probably one of the most craziest things I have heard in awhile.

God did NOT intend for there to be homosexuals. If he did, he would of created adam and steve, not adam and eve.

MAN AND A WOMAN, NOT MAN AND MAN, or WOMAN AND WOMAN.

Definitely an Official member of the "I'm a fvcking moron, look at me make a bigoted ass out of myself" Crew.

I dunno, with a post like that, I think he might be an official member of the "I'm a master of sarcasm and have suckered the collective mind of ATOT" crew. His comments are just too much of a stereotype...
 

imported_JeReMY

Golden Member
Oct 10, 2004
1,576
0
0
Originally posted by: maximus maximus
I have a question... do any other animals, part from human beings, have a tendency to be gay?

Animals live by instinct and do not decide for themselves so no.
 

classy

Lifer
Oct 12, 1999
15,219
1
81
You know what I don't understand. Why do people make excuses for homosexuals? Last time I checked people choose who they want to sleep with. Or did I miss something? Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple. Next we'll have perverts saying they can't help it they were born that way.
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: classy
Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple.

there is a difference between "being gay" and "sexual behavior" so why are you conflating the two? you can be straight, or gay, and never engage in any kind of sexual behavior other than masturbation. You are still straight or gay (or, for a smaller number of people, bisexual) even if you are a virgin. when people say being gay is not a choice, they are talking about who someone is attracted to. That is not a choice. The choice lies in whether you are going to pretend to be heterosexual or be true to your own attractions and desires.

edit: sure it is possible to choose to stay in the closet your entire life, and never have a sexual relationship with someone you are genuinely attracted to. However that is probably not the recipe for a happy, healthy life. I would say a meaningful and fulfilled life requires that you become what you are, not spend a lifetime pretending to be someone you are not.

 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
63,620
20,069
136
Originally posted by: classy
You know what I don't understand. Why do people make excuses for homosexuals? Last time I checked people choose who they want to sleep with. Or did I miss something? Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple. Next we'll have perverts saying they can't help it they were born that way.

You could choose to have sex with a man. That wouldn't make you gay. If you wanted to have sex with men, and only men, that would make you gay.
 

classy

Lifer
Oct 12, 1999
15,219
1
81
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: classy
Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple.

there is a difference between "being gay" and "sexual behavior" so why are you conflating the two? you can be straight, or gay, and never engage in any kind of sexual behavior other than masturbation. You are still straight or gay even if you are a virgin. when people say being gay is not a choice, they are talking about who someone is attracted to. That is not a choice. The choice lies in whether you are going to pretend to be heterosexual or be true to your own attractions and desires.

Again I disagree and here is why. Even though what you said has some truth to it, the problem with that kind of thinking is it is void of responsibility. I am married and if I am attracted to another person I still have to make the decision not to pursue a relationship outside of my marriage. The only way a person can justify homosexuality is if they find nothing abnormal about it, thats the only way. Because being gay is no different than a person choosing to be baptist or catholic.

Every person on this planet is faced with personal choices everyday and wanting to get it on with a person of the same gender is no different then the temptations others faced. And thus should not be excused as being acceptable because you want no responsibility. If you wanna be gay then be gay, but stop with the bs of being born that way. There is cute a spanish honey at work I would like to tag, so I gues I'll do the deed then tell my wife I was born to have multiple women. I am sure that will get me some leeway.
 

AlienCraft

Lifer
Nov 23, 2002
10,539
0
0
Why does it have to be "snap your fingers"? Isn't that stereotyping??? Not that there's anything wrong with that.....
 

bob4432

Lifer
Sep 6, 2003
11,727
46
91
Originally posted by: JeReMY
Originally posted by: maximus maximus
I have a question... do any other animals, part from human beings, have a tendency to be gay?

Animals live by instinct and do not decide for themselves so no.

hahaha. you think there are no gay animals? you know we are animals too and the people that are gay do not decide for themselves to be gay or straight...
 

bob4432

Lifer
Sep 6, 2003
11,727
46
91
Originally posted by: classy
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: classy
Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple.

there is a difference between "being gay" and "sexual behavior" so why are you conflating the two? you can be straight, or gay, and never engage in any kind of sexual behavior other than masturbation. You are still straight or gay even if you are a virgin. when people say being gay is not a choice, they are talking about who someone is attracted to. That is not a choice. The choice lies in whether you are going to pretend to be heterosexual or be true to your own attractions and desires.

Again I disagree and here is why. Even though what you said has some truth to it, the problem with that kind of thinking is it is void of responsibility. I am married and if I am attracted to another person I still have to make the decision not to pursue a relationship outside of my marriage. The only way a person can justify homosexuality is if they find nothing abnormal about it, thats the only way. Because being gay is no different than a person choosing to be baptist or catholic.

Every person on this planet is faced with personal choices everyday and wanting to get it on with a person of the same gender is no different then the temptations others faced. And thus should not be excused as being acceptable because you want no responsibility. If you wanna be gay then be gay, but stop with the bs of being born that way. There is cute a spanish honey at work I would like to tag, so I gues I'll do the deed then tell my wife I was born to have multiple women. I am sure that will get me some leeway.

sure you choose what person you would like to be with sexually, but you don't choose what gender gets you excited. even though you would like to tag this little latin honey at your work and that is a choice, and that is what gets you going, and you don't really have a choice that women get you going just as gay people don't have a choice that the same genger gets them going.
 

3NF

Golden Member
Feb 5, 2005
1,345
0
0
I don't see how being gay is a choice. There is this attraction I feel when I look at a women, something that isn't there when I look at a man. It isn't necessary sexual, but it isn't a choice either. I just "feel" that way. My brain was "programmed" that way at some point.

I could be wrong, but I'm guessing a heterosexual women feels the same thing when they look at a man. For a homosexual, their brain was just programmed at some point to feel that towards the same sex. There isn't anything wrong with it and it certainly wasn't their choice.
 

Lord Evermore

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
9,558
0
76
Originally posted by: 3NF
I could be wrong, but I'm guessing a heterosexual women feels the same thing when they look at a man.

Stop talking that way. You'll shatter all of our fantasies that women always want to make out with other women.

And Jenna Jameson is fugly.
 

Lord Evermore

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
9,558
0
76
Originally posted by: classy
Again I disagree and here is why. Even though what you said has some truth to it, the problem with that kind of thinking is it is void of responsibility. I am married and if I am attracted to another person I still have to make the decision not to pursue a relationship outside of my marriage. The only way a person can justify homosexuality is if they find nothing abnormal about it, thats the only way. Because being gay is no different than a person choosing to be baptist or catholic.

Every person on this planet is faced with personal choices everyday and wanting to get it on with a person of the same gender is no different then the temptations others faced. And thus should not be excused as being acceptable because you want no responsibility. If you wanna be gay then be gay, but stop with the bs of being born that way. There is cute a spanish honey at work I would like to tag, so I gues I'll do the deed then tell my wife I was born to have multiple women. I am sure that will get me some leeway.


I was born blond. Even if I color my hair and tell people I'm brunette, I'm still blonde in reality. If I wear lifts in my shoes, I'm still short. If I dress as a woman and live a woman's life, I'm still a male. (I won't even get into the transgender thing.) I'm white and born in the Southern US; if I get a tan and learn Spanish, I'm not actually a latino.

If I choose to live a straight lifestyle and only have sex with women, and suppress any urges towards men, that still wouldn't make me straight just because I decided to live that way. There IS a difference between how you CHOOSE to live after considering the options and how it will make you feel and affect your life, you can either live the way you feel, or deny the feelings and live the opposite way, but that doesn't negate the feelings, and in the innate feelings are what are used to apply a description. Gay means inside, you really are attracted to men and not women. It does not define who you actually sleep with.
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: classy
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: classy
Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple.

there is a difference between "being gay" and "sexual behavior" so why are you conflating the two? you can be straight, or gay, and never engage in any kind of sexual behavior other than masturbation. You are still straight or gay even if you are a virgin. when people say being gay is not a choice, they are talking about who someone is attracted to. That is not a choice. The choice lies in whether you are going to pretend to be heterosexual or be true to your own attractions and desires.

Again I disagree and here is why.

Whether or not you agree is irrelevant. What I said was a statement of fact, not an expression of opinion. People do not consciously choose what gender they are attracted to. That is a Fact.

Originally posted by: classy
Even though what you said has some truth to it, the problem with that kind of thinking is it is void of responsibility. I am married and if I am attracted to another person I still have to make the decision not to pursue a relationship outside of my marriage.

If you have an agreement with your partner that you will be monogamous, then for you to sleep with a co-worker is a violation of that agreement. So it is a betrayal of your partner's or wife's trust. Such a situation cannot (sensibly!) be compared with a gay person's decision to have gay sex or enter into a gay relationship. Unlike you cheating on your partner or wife (which is a betrayal of trust and morally inappropriate on those grounds) there is nothing morally wrong with having gay sex or being in a gay relationship. No-one's trust is betrayed, no one is hurt or damaged. Indeed, the well-being of the gay person is enhanced through healthy romantic or sexual ralationships, just as heterosexual people experience greater health and happiness when they are in healthy relationships.

Originally posted by: classy
The only way a person can justify homosexuality is if they find nothing abnormal about it, thats the only way.

From a statistical point of view, homosexuality is merely a normally occurring variation of human sexuality. It is no more "abnormal" than being left-handed.

All arguments that homosexual sex is per se somehow immoral come from the Bible. (Or rather, come from particular interpretations or misinterpretations of the Bible).

Originally posted by: classy
Because being gay is no different than a person choosing to be baptist or catholic.

That is false. No-one chooses their sexual orientation. There is NO - zero, nada - evidence that humans consciously choose their sexual orientation. OTOH deciding to align oneself with a particular religion in adulthood is OBVIOUSLY a conscious choice.

A better analogy would be to compare sexual orientation with hand preference. No one makes a conscious decision to be left-handeded. Some people just seem to be that way. You can force instinctively left-handed children to learn to write with their right hand, but it is never entirely comfortable for them to do so and most people would agree forcing individuals to write with their non-dominant hand is a cruel thing to do.

Originally posted by: classy
Every person on this planet is faced with personal choices everyday and wanting to get it on with a person of the same gender is no different then the temptations others faced. And thus should not be excused as being acceptable because you want no responsibility.

Seeing as there is nothing intrinsically immoral about having sex with someone of the same gender, I do wonder what exactly needs to be excused here?

As for responsibility, I think you will find gay people are no less likely to accept responsbility for their sexual choices than are straight people.

Originally posted by: classy
If you wanna be gay then be gay, but stop with the bs of being born that way. There is cute a spanish honey at work I would like to tag, so I gues I'll do the deed then tell my wife I was born to have multiple women. I am sure that will get me some leeway.

I believe I was born with a homosexual sexual orientation. Me saying I did not choose to be gay is not "bs" - it is just the truth. If you want to cheat on your partner or wife, then go ahead and do it. But please don't compare your immoral (untrustworthy) behavior with my consensual, respectful sexual relationships with people of my own gender (which by the way don't involve any lying or betrayal of trust).

 

ppdes

Senior member
May 16, 2004
739
0
0
Originally posted by: mugs
There is no inherent advantage to being gay, but there are inherent advantages to being straight.
I suspect gay guys are more likely to be able to experience pleasure from action in their backyard as well as their front compared to straights. Twice as much active sex equipment = huge advantage. I'm bi, personally, so I suppose I can't speak for either team.

Someone higher up mentioned not having to put up with PMSing SOs as well, heh.
 

moshquerade

No Lifer
Nov 1, 2001
61,504
12
56
Originally posted by: classy
You know what I don't understand. Why do people make excuses for homosexuals? Last time I checked people choose who they want to sleep with. Or did I miss something? Being gay is a choice, plain and simple. Sexual behavior is a choice plain and simple. Next we'll have perverts saying they can't help it they were born that way.
Having sex is a choice, sure, but who you are attracted to sexually is something you have no control over.

I ask you, why do you have sex with women (if you do) and not men? Why are you attracted to women?

I really don't like the perverts versus homosexuals comparison. I don't feel they are comparable.