Originally posted by: shady06
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: shady06
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: shady06
mill,
02 mustang v8 1/4 mile 14.7
02 maxima se 1/4 14.9
i'm almost sure the 2003 se was 14.7 but i cant find the link
ok, so not faster, but equal. also, keep in mind that it is very difficult to run the mustang that fast cuz its a stick so u have to get the timings down like a pro as where with the maxima you just push the pedal
Uh....do I even have to respond to that? That's the most convoluted and inaccurate statement I've heard on the net. You've never been to a track before have you? You don't just press the pedal and go because you STILL get wheelspin regardless of transmission. EVERYONE has to get their 60ft times down, and it's certainly easier to get a good 60ft on a stock mustang with a manual vs an auto. Now take a lentech with a nice stall and transbrake and you have no comparison, or even a decently stock 4r70w with a stall and decent tires and you can hook up. A stock auto in either car will have wheelspin and a crappy 60ft. With the smaller amount of torque the Maxima has it will obviously be easier to bog. BTW, the Maxima does come in 6spd and the GT has an auto trans available as well.I ran a 14.03 in my Stock automatic. I've never seen a 99-03 GT go slower than 14.2-14.3 unless it was the driver or traction limited. The Mustang is very very very clearly the faster car. I'm not sure who the hell jbautos is, but you can check the actual timeslips I posted from Maxima forums and compare it to ones on the corral.
yes you are correct, i was exaggerating when i said push the pedal but surely you'll agree that its more difficult running a stick @ a certain speed than it is an automatic esp for a new driver.
anyway, considering gas millage and insurance, it seems to me the maxima is a better buy and please dont take this as me ragging on the mustang cuz i'm not
No, actually, I won't agree. Most people with a manual have mastered some form of being able to take off from a stop without spinning, b ut most people in an Auto never give it enough gas to lose traction unless they ARE trying to race someone. Here is how I would explain it to you. An auto takes much more skill to get a good 60ft and a good 1/4 mile pass than it does for a manual. Some might disagree with me, but we are talking STOCK auto trannys here. You are going to fight not bogging out or spinning and you CANNOT stall it above the stock convertor. With a manual you can find that "sweet" RPM spot, and if the track is consistently prepped good you will be able to launch from that RPM all night long. I can tell you from experience that it SUCKS launching at 1800 RPM. Compare that to a manual to where you can launch at whatever you want.
we are talking about a new driver here
You don't get it, so I'm not going to waste anymore of my night after this post to explain it to you. Regardless of the skill level of the driver, you cannot stall higher than about 1800 RPM on the 4r70w mustang gt unless you replace the torque convertor. Because of that limitation, it is much harder to feather the gas coming out of the hole and not spin or bog(if you don't give enough gas). With a manual you have the benefit of adjusting your holeshot right out the box and being able to stick with a consistent RPM. 1800 is way to low to get a good launch, so you end up stalling it up and then feathering the gas until you hook up. With a manual you are going to be able to find the RPM ranges that gives you traction and get out of the hole. I'm not saying you'll never spin or bog, because you will, but your chances are reduced compared to a stock 4r70w. I'm a huge fan of good racing auto trannys or a modded auto tranny, but stockwise they aren't going to provide the holeshot or track times that you think. The skill level is actually HARDER.
