• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

*** American Idol 2009 ***

Page 18 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Alexis has a '36' number. Hmmm. That's the best they could come up with away from the phone sex line?

According to Ryan, there is a surprise change to the rules tomorrow night that could change the rules of the competition. Simons says it involves them (the judges) and doesn't know if the public will like it. But we already know that two will be leaving tomorrow according to what Ryan said at the beginning of tonight's show. I wonder if that's it or if it's something different.
 
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Danny Gokey and Michael Sarver were my favorites tonight by a landslide.

Looking at the recaps, it looks like it was a rough show all around tonight. Gokey looked ok though.

How could these guys mess up Michael Jackson songs so much...
 
I still can't get over how great they thought Adam did.

ETA - Don't forget that Kanye West and Kelly Clarkson will be on tomorrow!
 
Originally posted by: deftron
Jasmine Murray
and
Alexis Grace

I think you're probably right. Assuming you're saying is likely to go home. At least who probably had the worst performances. Danny Gokey's was perhaps the best IMO. I really like Anoop, but tonight his song choice did nothing to showcase his talents. I hope this is his low point of the show.

Edit: Oops, yeah Megan too. She's hot, but other than that, she doesn't exactly deserve to be on a singing talent show, certainly not at this stage of the game.
 
Please let Megan be gone, she is horrible. Yea, she's super cute, but she can't sing. She's been living on her looks for weeks. Every single time she performs we hear the same crap about her looks, and her style and that she's current. Meanwhile the judges seem to universally acknowledge that she can't frigging sing. She's horrible, I don't understand how she is even on the show. At least Simon called her out.

I'm not a fan of Adam either. My wife thinks he's great, but I just don't like him. He comes off as a guy doing musical theater to me.
 
ok danny gokey was realllyy good, so was matt giraud, and i really liked that kris guy. of course i want anoop to stay!!!! HE HAS TO STAY! he is really vocally talented and tonight he just wasnt able to showcase that.

personally, i think jasmine murray and the scott whoever dude can go home tonight. they did not impress me in the least. if not scott then megan can GTFO as well...

come on ppl, vote for anoop!!!!!
 
Originally posted by: GiggleGirl
ok danny gokey was realllyy good, so was matt giraud, and i really liked that kris guy. of course i want anoop to stay!!!! HE HAS TO STAY! he is really vocally talented and tonight he just wasnt able to showcase that.

personally, i think jasmine murray and the scott whoever dude can go home tonight. they did not impress me in the least. if not scott then megan can GTFO as well...

come on ppl, vote for anoop!!!!!

But Anoop sucked as well tonight. All votes should go for Danny Gokey & Michael Sarver!
 
in general this was a terribad show. was like 2-3 good, 2-3 standable, and the rest could have been flushed on the spot. part is probably due to whom they had to sing from, but ugh it wasn't a pretty site.
 
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
This version of 'Black or White' by Adam was atrocious!!!!!

Agreed. They better not say they liked it.

They loved it! Even Simon!!! WTF

Cuz maybe you guys aren't musical or something but he clearly destroyed everyone else. I'm putting my money on him.


Edit: yup, correct.

Betting odds:

Adam Lambert

5/2
Danny Gokey

13/4
Lil Rounds

7/2
Allison Iraheta

15/2
Scott MacIntyre

10/1
Matt Giraud

12/1
Alexis Grace

12/1
Anoop Desai

15/1
Megan Corkrey

15/1
Jorge Nunez

25/1
Kris Allen

30/1
Jasmine Murray

30/1
Michael Sarver

50/1

But then again who knows right? Archuleta had the lead all the way with odds. Even till the finals.
 
Originally posted by: trmiv
Please let Megan be gone, she is horrible. Yea, she's super cute, but she can't sing. She's been living on her looks for weeks. Every single time she performs we hear the same crap about her looks, and her style and that she's current. Meanwhile the judges seem to universally acknowledge that she can't frigging sing. She's horrible, I don't understand how she is even on the show. At least Simon called her out.

I'm not a fan of Adam either. My wife thinks he's great, but I just don't like him. He comes off as a guy doing musical theater to me.
Megan is a babe. And her mom is also a babe.
 
Adam was the best by a mile. Stop watching him, just listen to him. Danny was second.

Megan = horrible song choice. Why that boring song?! Probably because it was the only song that fit her bad dancing?

I'm voting right now for Danny, Adam, Allison and Anoop. Must save Allison and Anoop!
 
Originally posted by: her209
Originally posted by: trmiv
Please let Megan be gone, she is horrible. Yea, she's super cute, but she can't sing. She's been living on her looks for weeks. Every single time she performs we hear the same crap about her looks, and her style and that she's current. Meanwhile the judges seem to universally acknowledge that she can't frigging sing. She's horrible, I don't understand how she is even on the show. At least Simon called her out.

I'm not a fan of Adam either. My wife thinks he's great, but I just don't like him. He comes off as a guy doing musical theater to me.
Megan is a babe. And her mom is also a babe.

If you ask me, Megan's mom is cuter than Megan.
 
Just watching it now and with a daunting collection like MJ's...nobody seems to really be bringing it. I'm at Megan right now (and she looks foine...I still love her quirkiness) and I'm still waiting for a "blow me away" vocal performance. I think that Anoop really dropped the ball tonight - seems like MJ's music would be perfect for his range and he chose "Beat It"? Come on.

Another update in 6 singers or so 😉
 
Alright, so we obviously have some very tastes here 😛 I thought that Adam's performance was damn good - he was the most original tonight and of course his vocal experience helped him coast through to next week.

Overall, this week really did suck...the contestants were confronted by music that either A.) they could reproduce faithfully and be compared to MJ (they lose) or B.) try a new arrangement and possibly shoot themselves in the foot.

I have no idea who's going home this week, but my first guesses would be Jasmine and Scott - Scott has a great story, sure, but his singing technique is pretty poor and he certainly can't compare to a handful of the other guys. He won't be voted off though, due to his story. Jasmine just doesn't have the personality necessary nor the experience/age to pick good songs. She's got a pretty good voice but that won't be enough against the other women.
 
Adam
Lil
Danny

were top 3 this week

Red-head chick was also great, and I dug the last girl, though I thought she held back a little. Seemed a bit awkward, but a good performance.

Thank god this will be the last we see of Anoop. I'll never know why he was given that chance over about 8 others who should have been in the wild card round.
 
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Originally posted by: GiggleGirl
ok danny gokey was realllyy good, so was matt giraud, and i really liked that kris guy. of course i want anoop to stay!!!! HE HAS TO STAY! he is really vocally talented and tonight he just wasnt able to showcase that.

personally, i think jasmine murray and the scott whoever dude can go home tonight. they did not impress me in the least. if not scott then megan can GTFO as well...

come on ppl, vote for anoop!!!!!

But Anoop sucked as well tonight. All votes should go for Danny Gokey & Michael Sarver!

interesting. it seems those that don't like Adam seem to looooOOoove Anoop.

figures. that dude blows chunks. Hope he gets sent back to the karaoke bar where he belongs.

As much as I dislike emo, Adam is in the stratosphere, along with Lil, compared to the rest of the competition. It's effortless for those two. glad to see that Danny was really good tonight. Almost forgot about him.
 
Originally posted by: DLeRium
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
This version of 'Black or White' by Adam was atrocious!!!!!

Agreed. They better not say they liked it.

They loved it! Even Simon!!! WTF

Cuz maybe you guys aren't musical or something but he clearly destroyed everyone else. I'm putting my money on him.


Edit: yup, correct.

Betting odds:

Adam Lambert

5/2
Danny Gokey

13/4
Lil Rounds

7/2
Allison Iraheta

15/2
Scott MacIntyre

10/1
Matt Giraud

12/1
Alexis Grace

12/1
Anoop Desai

15/1
Megan Corkrey

15/1
Jorge Nunez

25/1
Kris Allen

30/1
Jasmine Murray

30/1
Michael Sarver

50/1

But then again who knows right? Archuleta had the lead all the way with odds. Even till the finals.



go ahead and replace lil with alexis and you could drop 5th-13th and hold a 2 hour final 4 now to complete the season.
 
Lil Rounds should go far in this competition. The lady can sing.

I think that the actual singing caliber this year is better overall than the last two years. Can't comment on the previous years as I did not watch the first few seasons.

I could see Adam front a band like Velvet Revolver.
 
I think my man Anoop is doomed. He was by far the worst last night.🙁
I thought Allison was the best, followed by Adam, and Lil. I thought the rest were all just OK, and so I can't pick who will be the other to go.
 
Originally posted by: zinfamous
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Originally posted by: GiggleGirl
ok danny gokey was realllyy good, so was matt giraud, and i really liked that kris guy. of course i want anoop to stay!!!! HE HAS TO STAY! he is really vocally talented and tonight he just wasnt able to showcase that.

personally, i think jasmine murray and the scott whoever dude can go home tonight. they did not impress me in the least. if not scott then megan can GTFO as well...

come on ppl, vote for anoop!!!!!

But Anoop sucked as well tonight. All votes should go for Danny Gokey & Michael Sarver!

interesting. it seems those that don't like Adam seem to looooOOoove Anoop.

figures. that dude blows chunks. Hope he gets sent back to the karaoke bar where he belongs.

As much as I dislike emo, Adam is in the stratosphere, along with Lil, compared to the rest of the competition. It's effortless for those two. glad to see that Danny was really good tonight. Almost forgot about him.

I like Anoop AND Adam. I just didn't like either one of their performances. More than likely they'll have another chance though.

I REALLY want Scott to go home but there's no chance of that happening. Jasmine can go then. LOL
 
Back
Top