i tend to favor dark beers, looking at the list: 
srs. bluemoon isnt bad but its too easy to find year round, and nothing special. i do like their harvest moon and winter moon brews, not outstanding beers, but affordable and quite decent. 
dogfish head palo santo marron. delicious, with a bourbon-y bakground. fantastic beer. easily my favorite beer at this point in time. sip it, enjoy it...its something like 9 or 10% but its great. 
-IF you see theobroma, get that, amazing drink. 
- if you like pumpkin beers their punkin ale is tasty
anything from bells is good, at least what ive had, which is most of it. 
breckenridges oatmeal is good, the vanilla has a *very* strong vanilla flavor if youre into that
three philosophers is good if you like belgian style ales. 
rogue: chocolate stout, dead guy, mocha, somer orange honey
chimay anything, if you like belgians
sammy smiths oatmeal stout or taddy porter
youngs double chocolate
ayinger Celebrator: amazingly good dopple bock. 
becks dark: like becks, but dark. i dont care for becks, but the becks dark is tasty. 
paulaner salvatore dopple bock
spaten: optimator, dunkle, or oktoberfest
okocim porter: one of my favorite beers. great beverage. 
guinness black lager: quite tasty and smooth
murphys irish red: great, great irish red. 
belhaven scottish ale
xingu black
also, see my sig. i drink lots of beer, so i have a large list of beers ive had, some with descriptions/opinions, and the document has a second sheet that is a wishlist.