Originally posted by: Thraxen
Fact: A person who buys a large vehicle for a large family will only have it filled to capacity 50% of the time or, in most cases, a LOT less. That doesn't mean they do not need it.
Fact: You cannot tow a large boat or trailer with most if not all minivans. Many people who buy large SUVs buy them to tow. But most of the time, they are not towing (of course). That doesn't mean they do not d them.
Fact: A minivan cannot seat 6-7-8 people AND all their luggage camping/sports/whatever gear. It just isn't going to happen. The full size extended SUVs can do this with ease.
Ok.
I own a Dodge Grand Caravan, the '97 flavor, so I can say a few things here. Granted, though, I have the extended version of the platform.
First point you make: no arguments.
Second: Well, the 96-99 caravans were not available with Class 3 towing packages; It can tow my parent's 17ft searay without hassle, but not effortlessly.
However, the newer generation of Caravans can be factory outfitted for heavy towing. IIRC, most Ford minivans can be similarly outfitted, particularly the Freestar.
I don't have any lore about Honda, Hyundai, et al.
Buying a minivan doesn't mean you can't tow big stuff: it just means that you have to pay ~2 grand extra for a <30-grand car.
Third: While I wholeheartedly agree with you for the generic minivan, the
extended versions can hold a full load of people and cargo.
Finally, I can fit 10 foot poles inside the car and shut the back door. Great stuff.
Even so, mine comes with the 'larger' 3.3 V6 engine....
Powerful? yes. 6.8 V8 powerful? no. 4WD? Heck no.