Originally posted by: Steeplerot
Deported? Why? Becasue they stand up for their right for freedom and oppurtunity?
Naah, If anyone, it should be the lazy midddle class "americans" that should look at what is happening today and learn a lesson in how to be a good american who fights for what he believes in.
Instead of scapegoating whoever some blowhard tells them in at fault.
Evil evil invaders! oooga booga! Get a life wankers, they show far more balls then you apathetic weenies who call themselves "legit" when was the last time YOU fought for anything, you all can't even get your sh1t together to fight bush, you other allies are the ones who elect bush, then of course there are your firneds like the klansmen and KKK who are spooging over themselves as you all sound like mini-dictators more by the day.
What a joke.
Sure the immigrants make a few problems, but the lions share of them are ours, no matter how easy it seems to pass it off on poor people.
QFT!
I read this thinking.....man, there are a lot of people that are buying into the hate-filled rhetoric that is being spewed around.
Let's look at things objectively. What is the ideal solution? Round them all up, make them felons and then deport them and build a fence? If you take the knee-jerk reaction (ie....what you are being sold by a lot of the GOP, Rush, Hannity, et al) hell yeah!! What does that approach gain you? A feeling of satisfaction knowing that you saved the country upwards of $1B/yr in possible welfare, healthcare, education and other social service payments? What did you COST you? Probably a lot more per person when the cost of business goes up for a lot of industries. Then the cost of the products go up as well. We complain enough about the price of gas, now let's throw vegetables, fruit, poultry, meat, dairy, housing and everything else that is being kept at a somewhat reasonable rate because companies can pay these
PEOPLE less per hour.
What is a viable solution? I think that it is somewhere in between Bush's proposal and the GOP's. I think that there should a fine if caught so that they can be deported without the stigmatism that accompanies a criminal record. This will allow them to be able to go through the proper channels to gain access to the country (and I don't mean the ones that they can swim across).
Try to grasp one simple concept, they have entered this country (under most circumstances) to do one thing, to make a better life for themselves and their family. These are not the run of the mill "criminal". They are certainly guilty of entering the country illegally, but they are probably better models to follow than a lot of the native born citizens. They work hard, live normal lives and are not engaging in any criminal activity (other than their entrance choice) and they are active in the political process which is a whole lot more than most on this board can say.
It is very easy to be a keyboard macho man and sit and talk about what you would do. It is a whole other level of bravery when you are willing to put you life as you know it on the line for something that you believe in. These people are doing just that. They know that they can be "rounded up" and deported, but they are willing to risk that for the ideals that they are sold by our country. That, if you come here and live a good life and work hard, you can experience the "American dream". The one thing that the majority of us take for granted just about every day of our lives.
The problem isn't "Illegal aliens", the problem is that we have become accustomed to certain expectations as consumers. And with those expectations come the reality that companies will not pay union wages because they will not be able to keep the prices down. That means loss of market share and possible loss of the business. We are being completely hypocritical by claiming that we don't want to pay higher costs for anything, but we also don't want to work for the wages that it takes to be able to keep costs at where they are. If you really want to end illegal immigration, take a lesson from what it takes to be an American from these people and be willing to make a sacrifice for what you believe, tell the corporations that you are willing to pay 50-100% more for their products so that they can afford to hire Americans like you to produce the goods.