zinfamous
No Lifer
- Jul 12, 2006
- 111,931
- 31,457
- 146
I agree Model S wasn't built with racing in mind. When Tesla released the Model S in 2012, it was designed to be comfortable highway cruiser for the American roads. Tesla was focused on battery range and motor efficiency. You can see how good the 2012 Model S design was considering cars released today by other automakers are struggling to match 2012 Model S performance and range. Porsche took and studied the Model S and used 2015 Model S as the baseline car to beat. Porsche knew they couldn't beat Tesla in battery range efficiency so they tried to match or beat Tesla in everything else and focused on racing where they had more experience and Model S only major weak point. So Porsche built Taycan with racing in mind to beat Tesla. And Porsche did a good job with Taycan minus the price and range. But it's foolish to think Tesla couldn't design fast race car if they wanted to. Tesla lead in EV is unmatched. All these "Tesla killers" coming out now are just confirming what Tesla fans already knew. Tesla has 3-5 years technology lead on everyone. So while Porsche may tout Taycan fast Nürburgring time, Tesla was prepared for Taycan's arrival. Tesla knows better than Porsche the weak points of the Model S. It's why they updated the Model S to Raven motor and cooling in May and Tesla brought Model S Plaid to Nürburgring. The Model S Plaid is actually 2017 Model S buyback lemon car Tesla have been doing testing and development work on. It's 7 seats passenger car. So the Plaid edition is not something Elon and Tesla just dreamed up last week. Tesla have been working on Plaid and was just waiting for Porsche to unveil the Taycan so they could show it off to the world.
I don't know man...I'd still take Porsche and the others over Tesla when it comes to designing a proper racing car with all that is required for racing. The battery tech is really just...barely any percentage of that expertise that is needed. In all seriousness, Tesla has many more hills to climb on that battle that anyone else does.
Don't forget that it has taken Porsche about 60 years to figure out how to make a rear-engined, RWD car not kill everyone that is sitting in it, and they do it very very well these days.
I would definitely like to see Tesla succeed here, no reason they can't--just that it's not going to happen overnight, unless they buy a bunch of engineers from Mercedes, Porsche, Ferrari, et al, that really know how to do this. They can't just win at a thing because they think they can, and because they are really good at only one out of the twenty or more things that are needed for them to be good at this particular thing.
And yeah, it would be a cool demo to show if they have made this one unicorn car, but no one cares if they can't produce the thing. There are standards to meet--Isn't it something like minimum 100 cars manufactured, before any international body will recognize your street racer, and license it for competition? This goes back decades. This wasn't set up "to get" Tesla and prevent them from succeeding, some decades before they ever existed. A lot of these companies have amazing performance cars that do amazing things on the Nurburgring, but were never really manufactured to any number, so no one bothers.
