• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

2008 Gamespot Game of the Year

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

http://www.gamespot.com/best-o...year/index.html?page=1

Some Choice Quotes

"Some may criticize Metal Gear Solid 4 for being just as much a movie as it is a game, but that very facet of this extraordinary package is what makes it so remarkable. Never before has one entertainment experience so flawlessly combined storytelling and gameplay, yet the game's most cinematic moments aren't those you watch, but those you partake in."

" Yet Metal Gear Solid 4 is more than just an intricate plot and a series of intense, scripted scenes. It is also an exciting action game that, more than any MGS game in the past, lets you play in your own style. If you wish to sneak past your enemies, you might hide under a barrel and slowly eke your way past, though you should be careful, lest an alert guard come to investigate. Or perhaps you would rather go in guns a-blazing, firing one of many terrific Metal Gear Solid 4 weapons, which you can tailor to your specifications with interchangeable sights, grips, and silencers. Or simply combine the two by shooting a soldier's neck with a tranquilizer dart and slipping past, or taking out your now-unconscious adversary with a headshot to make his silence permanent.

Each solution is equally viable, for though the series' stealth-focused gameplay is as strong as ever, both the sneaking and the shooting are equally rewarding, and neither mechanic suffers in light of the other. Capping the action are the insane boss fights versus the four members of the Beauty and the Beast Corps. Whether you're facing Crying Wolf during a blinding snowstorm or lobbing rockets at Raging Raven, the boss battles are long and intense, and they perfectly crown the levels that they conclude. Yet don't take that to mean that the standard enemies are run-of-the-mill. The acrobatic FROGS leap from wall to wall, forcing you to stay constantly focused as they flit about, and the monstrous Gekkos tower above, though they aren't impervious to that powerful railgun in your inventory.

All of this extraordinary gameplay and storytelling is wrapped in an exceptional technical shell, delivering an immersive experience brimming with heartfelt emotion. If there is one game you will remember in 2008, when the lights are dimmed and the curtains close, it will be Metal Gear Solid 4. Even in one of the greatest years ever for video games, its compelling action, moving story, and stunning visuals bring the series to a haunting close and will rightfully join the ranks of one of the greatest games ever made. "

I agree with the choice. And I like the cut scenes too.. they were long, but they were very well done and emotional.

Also how did NHL make the list?

Discuss

 
I agree with the choice.

Sidenote: someone should make a thread with a poll for ATOT's game of the year pick. I have to head to work, someone do it!
 
I'd still say Fallout 3, but I'm content with this choice. The game itself was good, albeit short, yet the everything is so cohesive, it feels like an experience. And I heart Japanese stuff.
 
personally i disagree with the choice.

i played mgs4 3 times, completing an act in each sitting, and had 0 desire to play it again.

after it sitting since july i finally got around to selling it a few weeks ago.
 
Fallout 3 is GOTY

I always liked the gameplay of the mgs series but the "story" is a piece of shit. I don't understand why people think it is so good or "well done. I've also always hated game story being told through extended cutscenes. It is the anti bioshock.
 
Originally posted by: tenshodo13
Also how did NHL make the list?

Why not? It looks like it was picked to represent the (non-motor) sports genre. I haven't bought a new hockey game in a few years, but from what I understand EA has actually made meaningful improvements in the NHL series.
 
Further proof PS3 is the superior system w/ the better games outta the 2 current generation consoles. Yes, I said 2. Wii can go suck it w/ the gamecube + vibrator scheme. Quality > Quantity
 
Yeah.....I'm seeing a lot of titles that should have been on the nomination list not even there... And I've heard that while MGS4 is a good game there was a lot more cinematic content than game content to it. Not saying that it didn't deserve it since I don't have a PS3 and haven't played the game but that choice definitely quirked my eyebrows with as many great titles that came out this year.
 
Originally posted by: Kromis
What the fuck?

Resistance 2 made the list but not Gears 2?

Wow.

What a crappy list... Gears 2 should be on there, its better than gears 1 in most ways (except a few irritating bugs) and gears 1 was great!

Burnout paradise and NHL09 shouldnt even be there. Braid.... its interesting... but cmon no its not one of the best games of 2008. None of those 3 are better than gears 2.
 
Too bad it doesn't exist for the 360. Dito that on Gran Tourismo 4. I haven't played enough to say Fallout 3, though the game is spectacular.
 
Originally posted by: Baked
Further proof PS3 is the superior system w/ the better games outta the 2 current generation consoles. Yes, I said 2. Wii can go suck it w/ the gamecube + vibrator scheme. Quality > Quantity

Lulz @ fanboyism.
 
Originally posted by: Baked
Further proof PS3 is the superior system w/ the better games outta the 2 current generation consoles. Yes, I said 2. Wii can go suck it w/ the gamecube + vibrator scheme. Quality > Quantity

Yep, because Gamespot is known as the pinnacle of gaming journalism...
 
Originally posted by: Maximilian
Originally posted by: Kromis
What the fuck?

Resistance 2 made the list but not Gears 2?

Wow.

What a crappy list... Gears 2 should be on there, its better than gears 1 in most ways (except a few irritating bugs) and gears 1 was great!

Burnout paradise and NHL09 shouldnt even be there. Braid.... its interesting... but cmon no its not one of the best games of 2008. None of those 3 are better than gears 2.

No... sorry. GoW2 is pretty much the same as the last one, and definitely not deserving of goty. Burnout Paradise and NHL09 were both huge strides in their genre, and I hoped you played both of them before making this post. Do they deserve goty? No, and that's why they didn't win.
 
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Baked
Further proof PS3 is the superior system w/ the better games outta the 2 current generation consoles. Yes, I said 2. Wii can go suck it w/ the gamecube + vibrator scheme. Quality > Quantity

Lulz @ fanboyism.

I'm very disappointed that it took people that long to notice. Disappointed!
 
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Baked
Further proof PS3 is the superior system w/ the better games outta the 2 current generation consoles. Yes, I said 2. Wii can go suck it w/ the gamecube + vibrator scheme. Quality > Quantity

Lulz @ fanboyism.

Lulz
 
Originally posted by: gorcorps
Originally posted by: Maximilian
Originally posted by: Kromis
What the fuck?

Resistance 2 made the list but not Gears 2?

Wow.

What a crappy list... Gears 2 should be on there, its better than gears 1 in most ways (except a few irritating bugs) and gears 1 was great!

Burnout paradise and NHL09 shouldnt even be there. Braid.... its interesting... but cmon no its not one of the best games of 2008. None of those 3 are better than gears 2.

No... sorry. GoW2 is pretty much the same as the last one which was awesome and definitely is deserving of goty. Burnout Paradise and NHL09 were both huge strides backwards in their genre, and I hoped you played both of them before making this post. Do they deserve goty? No, and that's why they didn't win.

Fixed.
 
Originally posted by: Baked
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Baked
Further proof PS3 is the superior system w/ the better games outta the 2 current generation consoles. Yes, I said 2. Wii can go suck it w/ the gamecube + vibrator scheme. Quality > Quantity

Lulz @ fanboyism.

I'm very disappointed that it took people that long to notice. Disappointed!

Too bad you're being serious though...
 
Originally posted by: gorcorps
Originally posted by: Maximilian
Originally posted by: Kromis
What the fuck?

Resistance 2 made the list but not Gears 2?

Wow.

What a crappy list... Gears 2 should be on there, its better than gears 1 in most ways (except a few irritating bugs) and gears 1 was great!

Burnout paradise and NHL09 shouldnt even be there. Braid.... its interesting... but cmon no its not one of the best games of 2008. None of those 3 are better than gears 2.

No... sorry. GoW2 is pretty much the same as the last one, and definitely not deserving of goty. Burnout Paradise and NHL09 were both huge strides in their genre, and I hoped you played both of them before making this post. Do they deserve goty? No, and that's why they didn't win.

personally i think GoW2 is not as good as GoW1, and hell no is not deserving of GOTY as bug infested as that damn game is.

i also tihnk Burnout Paradise is a better all around game than GoW2 and I put over 100 hours into Burnout Paradise, and my GOTY is a tie between Burnout Paradise (Xbox360) and Hot Shots Golf Out of Bounds.
 
Eh, I wouldn't say MGS4 was the GOTY, but at least I agree with it being nominated.

Some of the other nominated titles (No More Heroes, The World Ends With You, GTA IV) make me shake my head in disbelief.
 
Back
Top