Originally posted by: Pacfanweb
Originally posted by: jjsole
Originally posted by: Pacfanweb
The Zep clips sound okay, but Plant still has zero use of his his old high register. Can't even come close to the notes he used to hit, but everyone has known this for twenty years.
When he's singing lower, he still sounds like Robert Plant.
Jimmy Page is a notoriously sloppy live player, but he sounded pretty good on the clips I heard.
He completely kicks @ss over other singers that come to mind in the similar age range, like jagger, mccartney, elton john, billy joel etc. in range and clarity. He still has an outstanding voice, which most his age and music style have already trashed with so much smoking and screaming over the years.
Hmm. Jagger never was much of a technical singer...still sounds pretty much like he always did.
Billy Joel? Can still hit more of his old notes than Plant can.
Elton John? Plant is better....Elton's voice has dropped an amazing amount. He's almost a baritone now.
McCartney? That's about a wash between him and Plant now. I'd say Sir Paul has a better chance of hitting more of his old highs than Plant.
Best singer still in that age range? Sammy Hagar, hands down. He's 60, and can hit nearly any note that he ever hit. It's amazing how much every else's voice from his age group has dropped and Sammy has barely dipped. His tone has changed a bit, but the range is still 98% there. Heck, that's who Jimmy Page should have done that tour with, instead of the Black Crowes. Sammy could nail nearly all of that old Zep stuff.
And BTW, Plant attributes his loss of range to smoking over the years. Don't know if he still smokes or not.