If it's personal email, who cares. If it's work email, you should be using a Google Apps account, not a Gmail account. Google has 13+ redundant email cluster servers...it would be near impossible for them to permanently lose anything (the last time they had a mail-loss issue was Feb. 2011 and it affected .29% of accounts...the mail was restored within a few hours). The worst that could happen is email would be unavailable for a bit, and incidents are very rare.
You've already made a pretty similar point and I already responded to it (see my response to your quoted comment):
http://forums.anandtech.com/showpost.php?p=34955722&postcount=37
Losing people's email, though incredibly unlikely, would not look good for them and cause them to lose users.
People become more dependent on services like these until they reach the point where trying to migrate to another service is either extremely difficult or not worth the effort. The big-name Internet companies are playing a game where the goal is to achieve complete lock-in to their services.
The guy is hanging around with another guy that's accused to releasing classified military information and has a framework for hacking in place. OF COURSE HE'S BEING MONITORED. You make it sound like he posted "Obama sucks!" on Facebook or something.
From Wikipedia:
"Appelbaum is known for representing
Wikileaks at the 2010
Hope conference.
[5] He has subsequently been repeatedly targeted by US law enforcement agencies, who obtained a court order for his
Twitter account data, detained him 12
[6] times at the US border after trips abroad, and seized a laptop and several mobile phones."
Is that what you call "monitoring"? IMO that's like calling murder an extroverted suicide.