We had a nice long 4 hr phone conversation this evening about all of it. She was really understanding when I brought it all up, and agreed that things have been weird for awhile. Basically, we ended up trying to trace what's happened, and figured out that for the past several months, we've both been having on-again-off-again FEAR. The kind of fear that is "oh sh!t, I've been with the same person all of college. I've been in a serious relationship this whole friggin time-do I really know what I want? Do I want to be single? Do I want to date around? Do I even know what's out there?" etc. and the distance probably augmented these feelings, or made them more apparent.
Yet, we both still care about each other a lot. We talked about maybe "taking a break," but agreed that probably wouldn't make either of us happier, at least not now. So essentially, we're just gonna try and work through it, and see what happens. Maybe it'll work, maybe it won't, but the chips are on the table, and that in and of itself makes me feel about 15 lbs lighter for some reason. To hear her say that she's been feeling the same way, experiencing the same fears and insecurities, for just as long as I have, brought about an unexpected form of relief.
I guess that's all we can do for now. yes I'm still planning on going up to see her this weekend.