• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

YAGT: It's over. Done. Fiancee = Ex-fiancee. *RESOLVED*

Red

Diamond Member
***3nd UPDATE*** Monday 07:24...

So, yesterday, after she called me in the morning and acted like nothing happened, she told me she wanted to talk after work. I told her I think we need to have a long talk as well. After work she came over. Things were a bit emotional because I laid it all out on the table. I told her I think her head is in the clouds in regards to romance and I'm not changing. I told her that, yeah, sometimes I could put more effort into our relationship but I'm never going to be able to fill the shoes she expects me to wear. She apologized for acting the way she did the night before, but she explained that she was excited to see me after 2 days and was upset that I showed no enthusiasm and the first thing I wanted to do was play ping pong and forget we had dinner/pizza scheduled... she wanted to teach me a lesson by putting me in the doghouse. I told her it's not mature or acceptable for her to play with my emotions like that. I told her next time she needs to simply talk to me about it because we're both mature adults. She apologized for acting like a psycho and having unreasonable expectations and I agreed to put more effort into spending quality time with her. We "made up" and everything seems a lot better now that we laid everything out on the table.

***1st UPDATE*** 11:06am -- She just called me for the first time after the fight and acted like nothing happened. Asked me when I woke up, how I slept, etc. I didn't have the heart/gall to say anything to her then because she was getting ready for work. I told her to go get breakfast and get ready for work. Then she calls back 4 minutes later and is like "What are you doing?" I told her I'm playing on the computer, why? "That's all I need to know, thanks." ... What the hell was that?

It's 11:47 pm. Just got home from having the final argument with my fiancee. Back in November, I posted this YAGT about how my fiancee was upset that she really didn't feel the "spark" anymore after 2 or 3 years. You guys gave excellent advice to me about how she has her head in the clouds if she really thinks she is going to get butterflies in her stomach everyday... and feel sparks e v e r y day.

Well, tonight was it folks. Megan and her mother took a two-day trip (Friday + today) to Pigeon Forge (4 hours away) to go shopping. Before she took the trip, we had a talk on Thursday and the topic came up again. She told me I need to start being romantic / spontaneous or we need to stop wasting our time. So tonight, I came over when she got home from her trip. She told me she wanted to watch a movie and I asked if she wanted ice cream or wanted me to order a pizza or something. She said pizza sounds good.... then said she was going to take a shower. Soooo, I told her I'd play ping pong with her dad until she got out and I'll order a pizza in the meantime.

An hour passes, I stop playing ping pong and go order the pizza. I walk up to her room and she is sitting on her floor, reading a magazine and painting her nails, she hadn't taken a shower yet. I told her I ordered the pizza and asked why she hadnt taken a shower..... she said "don't talk to me. Don't touch me. You haven't seen me in two days and all you want to do is play ping pong with my family." We got into an argument and she said we're done. She said I have made no improvement in the past 12 months to be more romantic or spontaneous so we're done. She said she is keeping the engagement ring and I said no way. She gave me the ring and asked me to get out of her house, in not the nicest way.

I told her she needs to get her head out of the clouds. I explained how I thought we had a great relationship... we both are open and trust each other, we've never had to worry about cheating on each other, we both have goals for the future.... etc. She said the man she is spending the rest of her life with is not me, because she needs someone to sweep her off her feet for the rest of her life.

I told her she is being unreasonable and is throwing away 3 years and an excellent relationship because she is looking for story book romance. I told her she is probably upset because she just got back from a 4 hour road trip and needs to cool off.

She told me I'm wrong and we've had this talk 4 or 5 times before and I'm not the person she wants to be with. She said she is sick of being with a person who tries to act 45 years old when he is only 21 (since I tell her she needs to make a budget and don't enjoy getting drunk and having drunk sex every weekend) so she asked me to leave again.

At that point she got to me a little so I said "You only get one shot with the champ. If you want to throw everything we have away because you're looking for some kind of italian fighter pilot to make breakfast for you every morning and have spontaneous sex with you in a public bathroom, I'm not that guy. If you want to throw it all away, you don't get a second chance with me."

She put the engagement ring in my shirt pocket and said "Get out of my house."

**** Cliffs Notes ****

1. Fiancee has had 4 or 5 talks with me the past 12 months about how I need to give her sparks. She had another talk with me Thursday, the day before she took a 2 day road trip with her mom.

2. Tonight she tells me she is pissed that I chose to play ping pong with her dad instead of be with her after I haven't seen her for 2 days. I explain its because I thought she was getting a shower to get ready to watch a movie and eat.

3. We get in an argument. She wants the engagement ring. I take it. She tells me she is sick of me. I tell her she is crazy to throw away what we have.

4. She tells me to leave her house for the 2nd or 3rd time and I finally do.

3 years = down the drain. Motherfvcker.

EDIT: Title was misspelled.
 
eh, sucks for you... if she wants a spontaneous guy and you're not that type, what can you do.


But got damn, you're 21 and you're not f*cking like rabbits anymore? no wonder she wants to leave you.
 
If this was a parody (you never knew) I give it a 7/10 maybe 8/10

Otherwise I'm sorry to hear it's over but you're probably better off in the long run.

3 years = down the drain. Motherfvcker.

That about sums it up.
 
okay...

well now that your free.... go do something useful.. dont post on atot..

You got out pretty good i would say..

I wonder if your gf is around 21.. cause it seems very much that period that all women i know go thru, the age 21 independence complex.. its a complex cause men cant understand it but they will end up driving us mad..

Watch it, 6 months she is going to come back crying to get back.. works everytime.

edit: you deserve better.. somweher out there is a woman who will appreciate you for who you are..
 
Man that sucks..... but I smell something foul............ sounds to me she has someone else or is very close to being w/ someone else. sucks the big one!! well your better off anyway there is a better chick out there who will love you for who you are and not who they want you to be! good luck!

Pete
 
We're both 21. We've been together since we were 18. We do have a lot of sex. Gets a little repetitive at times, but fun nonetheless.

But yeah, I'm just looking at like I'm just not what she is looking for. I take care of her... we go out, I buy her little suprise gifts, write her poems, I've drawn her a nice picture, etc. Not all the time, but I do those things. Yet she says none of that has to do with romantic, and since I have to ask her what romantic means, that is how she knows she doesn't want to be with me.
 
Sorry to hear that J, but that's why I've never believed that women mature as fast as men. They say it is opposite, and it might be in another degree, but when it comes to emotional maturity and logic(HAHAHA) it will never happen. That gist of it all is that women are NOT logical. You'll just have to start over with someone else.
 
Sorry to hear about your story. She has some crazy thoughts in her head, and you were being perfectly reasonable. Obviously I don't know all the aspects of your relationship, but from what it sounds like, you have nothing to feel bad about. Its going to be hard, and its going to take a VERY long time, but you can move on.

BTW, your sig still has a link to you and your ex. Not sure if you want to remove that or not.

Good luck and take care.
 
Originally posted by: AMDMaddness
Man that sucks..... but I smell something foul............ sounds to me she has someone else or is very close to being w/ someone else. sucks the big one!! well your better off anyway there is a better chick out there who will love you for who you are and not who they want you to be! good luck!

Pete

Thanks Pete. She and I have very different views about people / relationships and I think it's finally hit the wall. She honesty feels (and she may be right, who knows) that there is a man out there who meets her amazingly impossible to understand demands for spontaneity and romance while being completely faithful, pays all the bills, model looks and is a through and through conservative, southern Baptist republican who doesn't look at porn. That is her ideal guy, I kid you not.
 
oh... sorry to hear that.

well, think in the long run; even if you manage to calm her down this time and make sense of her, she may go berserk again in the future; and in the worst scenerio, after you both got married, she wanted to file for a divorce coz you watched the playoff games with your boys instead of watching the premier of "How to Lose a Guy in Ten Days Part2"
 
Originally posted by: Red
We're both 21. We've been together since we were 18. We do have a lot of sex. Gets a little repetitive at times, but fun nonetheless.

But yeah, I'm just looking at like I'm just not what she is looking for. I take care of her... we go out, I buy her little suprise gifts, write her poems, I've drawn her a nice picture, etc. Not all the time, but I do those things. Yet she says none of that has to do with romantic, and since I have to ask her what romantic means, that is how she knows she doesn't want to be with me.

sounds like a overdemanding bia, youll be better off in the long run
 
Wow, that sucks. I guess now you will cross out the Girl in your sig. Anyway good luck and I know you will find a better one down the road. 21 are still young.
 
Originally posted by: Mill
Sorry to hear that J, but that's why I've never believed that women mature as fast as men. They say it is opposite, and it might be in another degree, but when it comes to emotional maturity and logic(HAHAHA) it will never happen. That gist of it all is that women are NOT logical. You'll just have to start over with someone else.

Thanks bud =( I just don't care anymore. It just kinda hurts because I still honestly feel like I offered her so much and DID soooo much for her, that I don't know what else she needed / wanted? Do I have no concept of romance? I feel like I've failed because she is the one initiating the break up... and I don't like feeling like a failure.

I forget what the 5 or 7 stages a person goes through during a tramatc event, but I think the first stage is denial. I'm still in that stage because I've haven't got upset yet and I really don't give a fvck that this has happened.

At least that is what I'm telling myself to get ready for the next stage... I hope that's not the cry like a puss stage.
 
Originally posted by: Actaeon
Sorry to hear about your story. She has some crazy thoughts in her head, and you were being perfectly reasonable. Obviously I don't know all the aspects of your relationship, but from what it sounds like, you have nothing to feel bad about. Its going to be hard, and its going to take a VERY long time, but you can move on.

BTW, your sig still has a link to you and your ex. Not sure if you want to remove that or not.

Good luck and take care.

Thanks Act. It just plain sucks. I love her, we've been through a lot, but maybe this is the best thing.

Couple of things we need to get straightened out if this is the REAL breakup I've been expecting.

1. Our puppy, a 2 year old yorkie named Giovanni, is living at my house. I'll ask her if she wants it. If she does, great. If she doesn't, It will be hard on me to give the dog away because I love the little guy, but I'm thinking it will be a problem to keep a relationship symbol like him hanging around. Haven't thought about it much though.

2. She was saying she wants everything she has ever given me back because I want the engagement ring. This would include home decor, clothing, etc. I don't care. This is a $5,000 ring I can help pay off my credit card with.

3. I'd have to cancel her plane ticket to Melbourne, Florida in July.

What a pain in the ass.
 
You didn't fail. The problem is that lots of girls that age have that silly pie-in-the-sky idea of what love and romance is all about, and it comes from watching too many movies like Bed of Roses. Your ex sounds a lot like my ex... You'll move on, and you'll find someone who's grown up.
 
But anyway, I'm gonna go to bed. Thanks for the support fellers. I hope I fall asleep soon because I dont want to start boohooing. At all.

Would it be weird if I didn't cry at all after ending an engagement? Hm.
 
Back
Top