YAFFT: Who got the better roster?

[Jgtdragon]

My buddy and I was arguing who has the better roster. You guys can decide.

Mine:
Record: (4-1)
QB: Bulger
WR: Sa. Moss, L. Coles, C. Chamber, Stallworth, J. Horn
RB: L. Johnson, R. Johnson, C. Williams, K. Jones
TE: Heap, Cooley, Witten
K: Wilkens
Def: Atlanta

His:
Record: (3-2)
QB: Vick, Palmer
WR: J. Walker, L. Evans, R. Brown, M. Harrison, B. Edwards
RB: L. Tomlinson, W. Parker, F. Gore, A. Green
TE: L. Smith, Shockey
K: Stover
Def: Pittsburg

 

[keeleysam]

Da Bears.

 

[Alex]

Originally posted by: keeleysam
Da Bears.

 

[KK]

Ditka

 

[Jgtdragon]

Come on, there has to be some football fans here that knows the NFL players.

 

[kstu]

Originally posted by: Jgtdragon
Come on, there has to be some football fans here that knows the NFL players.

courtesy bump

 

[Jgtdragon]

This is football season and I am a football fan. It is all for fun.

 

[yllus]

My team is ready to roll on over you, foo'. :| Skates > cleats. Peep this:

J. Spezza (Ott - C)

M. Handzus (Chi - C)

R. Torres (Edm - LW)

G. Roberts (Fla - LW)

D. Alfredsson (Ott - RW)

B. Gionta (NJ - RW)

P. Boucher (Dal - D)

M. Zidlicky (Nsh - D)

K. Timonen (Nsh - D)

D. Morris (Pho - D)

M. Afinogenov (Buf - RW)

B. Morrow (Dal - LW)

C. Clark (Was - RW)

R. Getzlaf (Anh - C)

M. Bell (SJ - LW)

 

[BlancoNino]

I'm still shocked out how impressive the Bears are looking...granted they played a banged up Seattle team at home...but still a good Seattle team. My Hawks better get something going soon

 

[beemercer]

Daaa Bears, ...., ugh heart attack, heart attack, got a piece of polish sausuge lodged in my aorta.

 

[MrChad]

Originally posted by: Jgtdragon
Come on, there has to be some football fans here that knows the NFL players.

QB: Adv. Him
WR: Tough call, depending on your rules; I'd say its a draw
RB: Adv. Him
TE: Why in god's name do you have 3 TEs? TE is a meaningless position these days, so it doesn't really matter
K: Not sure who's having a better year
Def: Adv. You

Overall, I give him the edge.

 

[Pho King]

It's all about weekly matchups but I'll give my thoughts

QB: Bulger over Vick and Palmer -> You

WR: I'd call a push here, you both have solid recievers, -> Push

RB: LT and L. Johnson cancel each other - R. Johnson / Kevin Jones are better than Parker and Green. Gore is having a monster year, but I still think he's overrated + he has a case of the fumbles. -> You (by end of year)

TE: Heap, Cooley, Witten vs L. Smith and Shockey - > Push

K: Wilkens vs. Stover -> Push
Def: Atlanta vs Pittsburg -> You

 

[axia55]

Him by alot