YAFFT: Which TE to start....

[Doboji]

I have Eric Johnson and Gonzo....

Gonzo is the man... but Eric Johnson is the 49ers primary weapon, and has been putting up ridiculous numbers...

Whats the word folks?

Such a happy decision to make though

-Max

 

[TuxDave]

FF..... Final Fantasy?

 

[trilks]

If you are a FF god, why are you asking for our advice?

Both are playing tough road games. Johnson has a horrible QB throwing to him. I'd probably stick with history and go with Gonzo.

 

[BigPoppa]

Originally posted by: trilks
If you are a FF god, why are you asking for our advice?

Both are playing tough road games. Johnson has a horrible QB throwing to him. I'd probably stick with history and go with Gonzo.

Rattay went 38/57 with 417 yards on Sunday. Thats more completed passes in a game than ANY of the great SF QBs before him.

 

[TheAudit]

Johnson. I got him off the waiver wire in one league and have been very happy with him so far.

 

[trilks]

Originally posted by: BigPoppa

Originally posted by: trilks
If you are a FF god, why are you asking for our advice?

Both are playing tough road games. Johnson has a horrible QB throwing to him. I'd probably stick with history and go with Gonzo.

Rattay went 38/57 with 417 yards on Sunday. Thats more completed passes in a game than ANY of the great SF QBs before him.

Yea, but still. It's Tim Rattay. I repeat, it's Tim Rattay.


<-- evil post #666

 

[imported_Strang]

Originally posted by: trilks

Originally posted by: BigPoppa

Originally posted by: trilks
If you are a FF god, why are you asking for our advice?

Both are playing tough road games. Johnson has a horrible QB throwing to him. I'd probably stick with history and go with Gonzo.

Rattay went 38/57 with 417 yards on Sunday. Thats more completed passes in a game than ANY of the great SF QBs before him.

Yea, but still. It's Tim Rattay. I repeat, it's Tim Rattay.


<-- evil post #666

B-b-but Rattay was throwing against the vaunted Arizona Cardinals' secondary.

Honestly, I would probably pick Johnson if for no other reason than that he doesn't have as much competition for catches as Gonzo would have (with Holmes, that is -- I'm not suggesting that KC has wide receivers).

 

[Mr N8]

Originally posted by: Strang

Originally posted by: trilks

Originally posted by: BigPoppa

Originally posted by: trilks
If you are a FF god, why are you asking for our advice?

Both are playing tough road games. Johnson has a horrible QB throwing to him. I'd probably stick with history and go with Gonzo.

Rattay went 38/57 with 417 yards on Sunday. Thats more completed passes in a game than ANY of the great SF QBs before him.

Yea, but still. It's Tim Rattay. I repeat, it's Tim Rattay.


<-- evil post #666

B-b-but Rattay was throwing against the vaunted Arizona Cardinals' secondary.

Honestly, I would probably pick Johnson if for no other reason than that he doesn't have as much competition for catches as Gonzo would have (with Holmes, that is -- I'm not suggesting that KC has wide receivers).

On the other hand, with Holmes running, it makes Gonzo more of a threat. A good running game makes for an effective passing game and visa versa. I would go with Gonzo. He's a big time playmaker for the Chiefs, and Baily isn't covering him.

 

[geecee]

Make sure Johnson's not going to be limited by cracked ribs first. Still not sure it's wise to sit Gonzo. However, Johnson appears to be Rattay's favorite target.

 

[Doboji]

bump... still haven't decided yet...

Who's the stronger Safety/Linebacker corps? Jacksonville or New York?

-Max

 

[TheNinja]

Never sit Gonzo, period. I would trade Johnson while his value is high for something you need, plus Johnson has a cracked rib.

 

[Chaotic42]

Originally posted by: TuxDave
FF..... Final Fantasy?

I'd start Shadow at WR, Auron at RB, and Butz at QB. That's just me.

 

[TheAudit]

Johnson is #1 in receptions and #4 in yardage in the league.
Gonzo, so far, has 18 receptions, half the yardage and TDs.