I have driven both and own neither of them. I liked the interior of the Subaru a bit more, the Mitsubishi wasn't great and felt kind of cheap to me. In terms of power/handling I'm not sure exactly what I'd pick since it's been many months since I drove them, but I remember the Evo took time to build boost whereas the Subaru seemed to spool up much faster. Factor in the fact that no one is sure how much longer Mitsubishi will be around, I'd go with a Subaru.