Jesus freaking christ. I havent seen this much bullshyt in a thread in a WHILE.
Optimus' post is the post of the devil. Everything he says is pure bull. I don't even feel the urge to defend against it, but hell, why not?
<< 1) a) Doesn't matter - N64 was more powerful than the PS1. 3DO was extreemly powerful. Even the amazing Dreamcast is not dominant because of its power. You know what is the number one console in the world today? The 8-bit GAMEBOY. >>
Woo-freaking-hoo. PS1 had like an 80% market share when Nintendo came in with a machine that was incredibly difficult to develop for, expensive due to cartridges, and a 3DO would run you $600. It was a toy that you played with at Fred Meyer, not something you took home.
<< b) X-box power is being measured in apples to oranges compared to PS2 and GameCube. Take a PIII 733, and a GeForceII Ultra. Run it through TV-out. Impressive... but doesn't wow me like MGS2, GT3, or even Soul Calibur. Game design is all that matters. Besides - run evena stripped down version of Win 2k on a 64 MB PC... watch how much power is left over for games. >>
Apples and oranges eh? How so? The machine is 3x the power of the PS2. Game design is all that matters, and obviously 160 developers with past experience will not be able to create compelling games. And THEY are trying to talk fucking apples and oranges? Youre trying to compare a full operating system that is 200MB to one that weighs in at 400Kb.
<< 2) I think this is X-box's true achillies heel - that the same lazy crap that gets churned out for the PC every week is now coming to your console. You really think M$ will say no to ANY game proposed that pays the marketing fee? So we saturate the market with endless PC ports. You know, PC ports are the worst selling set of Dreamcast games, and market saturation with poor quality games is what toppled Atari. X-box has a hard drive and runs DirectX... how many patches are we going to download? Buggy games here we come! Wow! Dad bought me Deer Hunter 18 for Christmas...
>>
Yeah, every game that came out for SNES or PS1 were masterpieces. You know goddamn well that only 10% of games are good games. Look at the freaking crapware for PS1, its nearly sickening. Even franchise games such as Twisted Metal games have gone from good fun games to choppy gameplay-sacrificed-for-eyecandy coasters that you only play because of the hype.
<< Cost is big too - when asked if the Xbox would be priced the same as the PS2 ($300), they replied by asking if the PS2 had ethernet and a big hard drive? Hmmmmmmm... cha-ching! Plus DVD is extra... cha-ching! Controllers and mice, keyboards, etc... proprietary USB, can't use your existing stuff... CHA-CHING!!!! >>
Oooh, so lets get an add on hard drive for your PS2 that will be supported by only 5 companies. Fun! Theres more cash! DVD costs $20 extra so it will save you nearly $50 on console price. (By taking away DVD/Mpeg2 licensing fees) Controllers and mice are extra for EVERY CONSOLE, wtf! And we all know that the PS2 USB is exactly spec, not proprietary. Sigh, did you just come in and try to nef this?
<< I think a lot of us here, especially, have powerful PCs. Are you going to stop buying graphics cards? Faster processors? No - you will keep upgrading, and the market will keep developing new technology. So why will you buy an Xbox to play Quake4 on? Or will you buy Q4 for your PC and play on your 21 inch monitor at 1600x1200? Anything released for Xbox will be released for PC almost immediatly - they are the same thing! (Unless M$ can buy off a few games for exclusivity). >>
Xbox supports HDTV resolutions, meaning you can hook it straight to your monitor. And all games for Xbox will be on PC? Are you out of your mind? Do you seriously think that we can run games like they can? We have things called bottlenecks, consoles do not.
Gamecube looks to me like its Nintendo going back to its roots. Xbox is a beast machine with more features than any electronic device ever created, with a hard drive for expansions and killed load times. Built in ethernet will allow for internet play. I personally will own both a Gamecube AND an Xbox, because Nintendo will have killer titles that i will NEED to play also. PS2 doesnt stand a chance.