I've never had a problem with Newegg HD shipping, and never had a DOA drive. Every drive I've gotten from them has been wrapped in gobs of bubble wrap. Recently had one that was double boxed even. Maybe they just like me. <shrug>
Amazon's fairly lacking packaging is the main reason I'd never buy a hard drive from them. A box that is 2x the size of the item, with naught but a couple air pillows in it for "packaging" is really not enough. Fairly consistent on the low end of the scale, though I have gotten a couple packages that were packed decently. Oddly enough the couple that were packed ok were also the least fragile of all items I bought :|