Word to the Wise about HP Laptops

Cygni

Member
May 12, 2001
178
0
0
My girlfriends computer is an HP Pavillion ZT1135 laptop. It was a fairly nice laptop for late 2002, with a 1.2ghz P3 based Celery, 256mb of ram, DVD/CD-RW, a nice screen, and a very thin and light packaging.

A)The problems began in early 2003 with random shutdowns. Rather quickly I realized that it was heat. For whatever reason, even with the heatsink fairly jammed with lint, the fan would rarely kick itself into high gear, even at 100% use. Anyway, frequent blow outs kept the computer running fine.

B)Then, the cheap DVD/CD-RW drive from no name company Matsushita (owned by Panasonic) simply upped and died. A few months pass, and the computer is in bad need of restoration (young females + computers, often a bad combo). Due to the dead CD-ROM, a copy of XP that wouldnt boot, and no USB boot ability... I attempted to remove the HD, and use the restoration discs in a seperate box, through use of a laptop-> standard IDE converter card. The discs unfortunatly would not allow such a simple solution, screaming of mismatching computer information. Had to purchase a refurbed replacement drive to fix that problem

C) Now the CPU fan has completely died, forcing me to take on the epic challenge of tearing apart the laptop, somehow replacing the fan with a replacement that will actually fit, and reassembling...

What is the moral of the story? HP sucks. Although this story is not to say that Dell, et al, are any better. I have a similar story to tell about a P4M based Dell whose screen connecter died. Or how about my roommates Athlon 4 based Sony whose DVD drive will no longer play DVDs, even with reformat and lens cleanening? Or how about....
 

jpeyton

Moderator in SFF, Notebooks, Pre-Built/Barebones
Moderator
Aug 23, 2003
25,375
142
116
Every laptop maker, save IBM, has it's issues. Dell and HP use the same manufacturer in China for many of their models, so those two will be surprisingly similar in reliability.

My Compaq X1000 is still going strong (knock on wood).

I've also heard good things about Fujitsu laptops.
 

Frew

Platinum Member
Jul 21, 2004
2,550
1
71
People complain about every company.... Why would you expect anything else about HP. NO company is without faults.
 

Cygni

Member
May 12, 2001
178
0
0
Im well aware that no company is without faults. Im also aware that different companies have different standards. Im simply sharing my experience with an HP laptop. One that I unfortunatly find all too often in the laptop sector.
 

OverVolt

Lifer
Aug 31, 2002
14,278
89
91
ALL laptops are crap imo.

Overpriced, under-reliabe, 100% proprietary, prone to damage, can't-make-your-own, filled with bloat software (HP has a nice trick of adding bloat to the touchpad software, on mine at least... 10Mb memory usage for a mouse, c'mon seriously now) My laptop, altough not stressed/taxed makes choppy burned CD's, replacement parts cost stupid amounts of money etc. etc.
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Buy an IBM Thinkpad if you want quality.

However, my brother has a cheap HP laptop he bought in 2002 that's still going strong. It's like hard drives, everyone has horror stories about every brand, while others have only nice things to say about that same brand.
 

OMGoddess

Banned
Jun 25, 2004
714
0
0
Originally posted by: OverVolt
ALL laptops are crap imo.

Overpriced, under-reliabe, 100% proprietary, prone to damage, can't-make-your-own, filled with bloat software (HP has a nice trick of adding bloat to the touchpad software, on mine at least... 10Mb memory usage for a mouse, c'mon seriously now) My laptop, altough not stressed/taxed makes choppy burned CD's, replacement parts cost stupid amounts of money etc. etc.

Not true, you can make your own, you won't be saving as much money as making your own PC, but you'll see a $100-$150 savings, and yes I have built my own.
 

Dave Perry

Member
Sep 6, 2004
45
0
0

Laptops are good for things you absolutley have to have them for, i.e. portability, and nothing else. You pay the price for that one thing in initial expense, limited, expensive upgradablility (if any), flimsyness, and whimpy power/speed. They can be great for students who don't mind driving people crazy with keyclicks in lectures, writers on the go, reviewing photos on trips, navigating and checking email on trips if you have a cell phone connection and, uh.....

That's it. There will never be another use discovered for them. Ever.
 

n7

Elite Member
Jan 4, 2004
21,281
4
81
I don't know if if you've caught on yet, but laptops, [/i]regardless of who makes them[/i], are far more prone to breaking down or having problems than pretty much any other item in electronics.

Buying an extended warranty or service plan for them is not a stupid thing do do at all; i would actually not consider buying one without some kind of repair coverage.

True moral of the story: Don't buy a laptop w/o warranty or plan to buy a new one every 1.5 - 2 yrs. if you don't get the warranty :)