Well, looks like this is a flop. I'll only get it if my 4830 dies out in the next few months. I'll be waiting to get something with 5850 performance around the $130 or less mark. This isn't even close. Maybe the 6750/6770 or an nVidia equivalent will be around that mark.
Gaming at 1680x1050 isn't the biggest of resolution so major GPU memory or horsepower isn't really needed. I'm sure many people are in the same boat that i'm in and both GPU manufactures need to introduce another 4830-like video card. A cut down card that performs far better per $ than their parent GPU. nVidia already did this with the 460 and ATI did with the 5830, but honestly their prices are still way too high.
$79-120 is the sweet spot for consumers to buy video cards. Once a 5850/4601GB hits that price, i'm going all in.