• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

WinXP -- swapping MB, Chip, RAM -- workable?

N

nghtmare24

Junior Member
I thought I hard heard somewhere that WinXP handle Motherboard swaps fairly good.

While I wouldn't mind rebuilding my machine, I actually just did it a few days ago when I got a new harddrive, and after reinstalling Win98SE, I went ahead and upgraded to WinXP Pro.

And I've also ordered new MB, chip and RAM.

When I swap everything out, can XP handle the change?

Win98 did it fairly poorly.

Like I said I usually rebuild in this situation, I need to change to NTFS anyway, but just wondering.
 
Although it can handle it OK, it's pretty much hit-and-miss.

You are really better off doing a full reinstall, and go straight to WinXP. Don't do an upgrade from Win98.
 
Hi,
I m in the same boat, going from a P3/i815e to a P4/i850, although XP is already installed. After the swap out, should I just boot the XP CD, and do a repair reinstall XP over itself? I understand that this will preserve my programs and files? Any further tips?
 
Since there is no real significant architecture change between the i815E and the i850 chipset (apart from a few P4 specific things, they are similar chipsets), you could probably get away with just a straight change between components.

A repair installation will keep most existing settings, and will not lose any of your data or documents.
 
To anser original post, it's very workable. I had to do an emergency motherboards swap on my work system Saturday--went to power on...and nothing. After checking everything, determined MB just died...

To be safe, after the swap, I booted into Safe Mode with Networking (in case drivers were needed, I could download). Safe Mode allowed XP to detect new drivers needed, installed, rebooted, and all was well. No need to run Repair.
 
I think it really depends on just how drastic a change you are making.

I changed my motherboard a few weeks ago from an Asus KT266A to a Gigabyte i845 and my system required a complete reinstall, blue screen on the boot. Repair didn't help.

Then again the following stuff changed on that swap:

Chipset
Processor
Sound
USB
Network
RAID Controller

The only carry overs were the DDR and the HD/CDRW/DVD drives. Needless to say if you aren't changing EVERYTHING then you should be ok.

EtOH
 


<< rockhard: I'll put something together soon >>



Great stuff. Very impressed with how the FAQ's are growing - keep up the invaluable work 🙂

'gards,

rockhard =)
 
I swapped out an ECS mobo for a Shuttle in my grandson's system yesterday afternoon and it was a piece of cake. In fact, the only downside for me is that I'm upgrading his hdd as well and my copy of Ghost isn't WinXP compatible.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top