Why nice guys don't do well:

Accipiter22

Banned
Feb 11, 2005
7,942
2
0
So I was thinking about how i hear friends say things about nice guys finishing last with girls, and I wrote down some thoughts about it...I figured I'd post it here, since there's a lot of Girl-Threads....


There's a couple problems with the whole Nice Guys finish last, Mean Guys always do better argument. Primarily it's that people assume the
nice guy is the better option. There's a few things wrong with probably a majority of nice guys.

First of all, a lot of times they place girls up on a pedestal, thinking that worshipping them, or placing them above their surroundings is a compliment. I hate to break it to you, but it's not. It's insulting. What's wrong with the girl the way she is? You have to exaggerate her qualities, or just plain make stuff up about her? That's not complimentary at all. If you think she's beautiful, tell her she's beautiful. Don't say things like 'you're the most beautiful thing I've ever seen, I've never seen more beautiful eyes' or stuff like that, unless you actually mean it. You should probably only say stuff like that to maybe one or two girls ever if you only say it when you mean it. You got to let a girl be who she is, don't exaggerate, don't make stuff up about her, don't say she has qualities that she doesn't, because that's just degrading to who the girl really is.

Next, most nice guys can be smothering sometimes. Like calling a few times a day, that doesn't show you care, or that you love someone, or that you're thinking of them. It makes it seem like you're keeping tabs on them, or that you're jealous. Remember, love isn't jealous. It's not just phone calls either. Always asking them to do stuff always buying them things, it makes it seem like you're thinking about them way too much, or that you're trying to buy them, even if you're not, so just chill. Most nice guys go for quantity over quality. Don't be like that.

Third, a lot of times the nice guys are also a bit on the sappy/weepy/emotional side. If she wanted to date a girl, she'd be a lesbian. You're a man. Act like it. Nothing turns a girl off quicker than a guy that spills his guts all the time. Showing you have a sensitive side is good, showing you have emotions sometimes is good. But it shouldn't be your dominate personality trait, overshadowing the fact that you are a guy, and should still be assertive. Which brings me to my last point about nice guys; usually they let a girl walk all over them. As if by giving in to her every whim or everyattempt to get attention that you're going to win her over. Wrong, all you're doing is acting like a door-mat. Why's she going to respect you when you don't respect yourself? Don't be too nice, it makes you seem spineless. That's not to say you should be an asshole, just be ASSERTIVE. If that means sometimes she doesn't get what she wants, that's fine. If it means she gets miffed at you and leaves occasionally, that's ok too. She'll come back. Just be polite, but be firm. In other words, act with confidence.

Now, most mean guys share a few common traits. They usually treat a girl like crap obviously, but also, they don't care enough to try to change a girl. So they're not putting someone up on a pedestal. They're going to let her be herself, even if it's because they don't care. They're probably going to be distant too, and not smothering. They're going to set boundaries, even if they are too strict. They're not going to be weepy either; they're probably going to be pretty cold. Occasionally if they want to get a girl back they'll pretend to be emotional, but still, for the most part they'll be pretty stoic. So look at it like this; the guy's an asshole, yes. But he let's the girl be herself, which is better than exaggerating qualities about her. In the end all you really have is yourself, and being with someone who lets you be yourself is better than being with someone who's 'nice' but doesn't like you for who you are. So he's mean, but he's going to give her space and not make her feel like she's suffocating. Emotionally he's going to act like a man and not spill his guts. He's going to set boundaries and be assertive, and move with confidence. So when compared to a nice guy, sometimes a jerk doesn't seem so bad. But even if he's doing things for the wrong reason, the mean guy is still easier to deal with a lot of times.

The crappy nice guys make it harder for men like me, who are nice, but don't put girls on pedestals. Who try to give space, and who reign in their emotions and don't get all sloppy and spill their guts. Guys who do act confident and assertive. Just as every girl has an asshole in her past, who makes her hate men, most also have some 'nice guy' in their past who makes them wary of the typical nice guy traits. So when I act nice, first thing that comes to their mind is 'oh no, another 'nice guy'. The key though, is that the assholes don't respect the girl. Respect the girl, and listen to what I?ve said here.



edited for paragraphs....and no i don't mean ALL nice guys are like this, there's just a good chunk of them.
 

notfred

Lifer
Feb 12, 2001
38,241
4
0
My fiancee's take on this phenomenon:

Why don't girls like nice guys? Because nice guys are fvcking boring. Girls want someone exciting more than they want someone who is polite and curteous.
 

Accipiter22

Banned
Feb 11, 2005
7,942
2
0
*sigh* yeah cliffs would help

1. Girls don't like nice guys cause usually they're weepy, or put girls on pedestals, which is actualy demeaning like the girl isn't good enough as she is.
2. Usually they call too much, or are too available, so it's a complete turn off/smothering experience with a girl.
3. They give in to any whim of a girl, which sets no limits for the girl, and basically makes you seem like a sap.
4. More often than not nice guys are weepy. If the girl liked girls, she'd be a lesbian. Don't act like a girly man.
5. A-holes usually don't care, so they don't over-compliment the girl
6. They don't smother, or act like pansies
7. So when compared to a nice guy, sometimes mean guys are a better choice, they let the girl be herself, and they act like real men.
8. You're all lazy bastards, it was only like 4 paragraphs.
 

ponyo

Lifer
Feb 14, 2002
19,688
2,811
126
Originally posted by: notfred
My fiancee's take on this phenomenon:

Why don't girls like nice guys? Because nice guys are fvcking boring. Girls want someone exciting more than they want someone who is polite and curteous.


score.
 

yoda291

Diamond Member
Aug 11, 2001
5,079
0
0
Originally posted by: Yossarian
cliffs of the cliffs? I did catch the word "lesbian" in there so you may be onto something.

Accipiter22 got shot down and is tired of blaming just a small subset of other guys.



The reason nice guys finish last is because they're not as much fun. Seriously, how much can any girl stand being told how awesome she is?

um...boobs. hehe
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
I heard that most men with small penises tend to be nice guys. If this is true then is it possible that I've been wrong all these years? I used to think women wouldn't like me because of my small penis when it's actually because I'm a nice guy. Oh, the irony!
 

kogase

Diamond Member
Sep 8, 2004
5,213
0
0
I would read it all without cliffs if only you knew how to make proper paragraphs. Alas, you do not. So I didn't read it.
 

myusername

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2003
5,046
0
0
Originally posted by: Accipiter22
*sigh* yeah cliffs would help
<As if by giving in to her every whim or every
attempt to get attention that you're going to win her over.>

Actually I thought that was the strongest part of the whole thing, even though that line doesn't stand on its own grammatically.
 

Accipiter22

Banned
Feb 11, 2005
7,942
2
0
Originally posted by: yoda291
Originally posted by: Yossarian
cliffs of the cliffs? I did catch the word "lesbian" in there so you may be onto something.

Accipiter22 got shot down and is tired of blaming just a small subset of other guys.



The reason nice guys finish last is because they're not as much fun. Seriously, how much can any girl stand being told how awesome she is?

um...boobs. hehe

lol I didn't get shot down, I wrote that for a friend lol
 

Accipiter22

Banned
Feb 11, 2005
7,942
2
0
Originally posted by: StormRider
I heard that most men with small penises tend to be nice guys. If this is true then is it possible that I've been wrong all these years? I used to think women wouldn't like me because of my small penis when it's actually because I'm a nice guy. Oh, the irony!

well they all must be good at oral then
 

Rainsford

Lifer
Apr 25, 2001
17,515
0
0
The problem with "nice guys" isn't that they are nice, it's the other traits that girls really mean when they say someone is a nice guy. It works the other way too, assholes aren't appealing to girls because they are assholes, but because of other traits. Being a man, being your own person, etc, are all things girls like. Don't get fooled by the assholes who tell you that being assholes is how they get the ladies, you'll be a lot better off if you try to combine those traits girls like with being a good guy. You'll beat the assholes every time.

Edit: Don't get me wrong, being an asshole can certainly get you girls...the low self-esteem punching bag types. Yeehaw!
 

RedCOMET

Platinum Member
Jul 8, 2002
2,836
0
0
That was 4 paragraphes??? it felt longer. The cliffs were a nice, but i did manage to read all of it.