Why many of you won't be getting your parents home.

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Aug 1, 2006
1,308
0
0
Originally posted by: Lothar
Originally posted by: steppinthrax
Originally posted by: techs
http://news.yahoo.com/s/csm/20061226/ts_csm/amedicaid

In the face of soaring Medicaid costs, Tennessee and every other state are required to set up a Medicaid estate-recovery program. Many have been launched only recently, and some - like Tennessee's - are becoming more aggressive. Often, they target the home because it's all that's left after beneficiaries have spent their assets to pay for nursing-home care.

States base their programs on a 1993 federal law mandating that they recover what Medicaid spends on a beneficiary's long-term care. Congress approved the law to prevent states from forcing the sale of beneficiaries' homes while they were still living, in case their conditions improve and they can return home, says Mary Kahn, spokeswoman for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

James Napier and his family were shocked to receive a letter from the state of Texas about his ex-wife's home after she died in May 2005. She spent the last two months of her life in a nursing home. Now the family owes Medicaid $5,600


Ok, kids. Listen up. Does your Medicare plan cover long term care? Almost certainly NOT.
So if your parents need to go into a nursing home, after whatever short term coverage you have, will cost them 2,800 a month each, if they use the one in the above article. And 2,800 is for a Medicaid facility and is a low price.
Think how easy it will be for one or two parents needing only 2-3 years of care in a nursing home to completely drain the value of thier homes.

And you thought you were going to get that house, didn't you?
Ha Ha. I rent so your parents house is going to help pay to keep my cost down. Thanks

One of the problems in this country is the low value we place on old people. In counteries like China you almost always never see nursing homes. It is expected from the children of those parents to take care of them. But in this country the youth of society finds it strange to do so.

I couldn't have said it any better :thumbsup:
The idea of shoving your own parents in a nursing home rather than taking care of them is ridiculous.

Said the person who never took care of someone in last stage Alzheimer's....
 

techs

Lifer
Sep 26, 2000
28,561
4
0
Originally posted by: slash196
I'm a little unclear on something: How does a family wind up "owing" Medicare money? I'll be the first to admit ignorance of the machinations of Medicare but my understanding is that it's designed to HELP people with medical costs, and not hold them responsible for the debts. To me that's like asking for your Social Security checks back. Why are government welfare programs charging people money? Isn't that what those things called "taxes" are for?

There is a difference between Medicare and Medicaid.
Medicare doesn't pay for long term nursing care.
Medicaid does.
In order to qualify for Medicaid assistance you must not have any money. However, in order to allow people with houses to use Medicaid for long term nursing care AND still have their house to go back to if they recover enough, Medicaid lets you keep your house and still get the nursing care paid for.
The change is that now after the person dies, Medicaid wants the money that they COULD have demanded if you had not recieved the waiver to keep your house, since now you are dead and no longer need it.
 

OS

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
15,581
1
76
this is somewhat good news actually, it means that there is precedent now how the coming huge generational costs will be dealt with.

probably the most palatable approach, without any solutions, the worst case would be a national financial crisis.

 

Ferocious

Diamond Member
Feb 16, 2000
4,584
2
71
umm the family doesn't have to pay any costs. The elder's assets are used up and then the government takes over.

Makes sense to me.

Seems like people here are pissed off because they want to inherit something while others pay for their elder's care.

Screw that!
 

imported_Lothar

Diamond Member
Aug 10, 2006
4,559
1
0
Originally posted by: International Machine Consortium
Originally posted by: Lothar
Originally posted by: steppinthrax
One of the problems in this country is the low value we place on old people. In counteries like China you almost always never see nursing homes. It is expected from the children of those parents to take care of them. But in this country the youth of society finds it strange to do so.

I couldn't have said it any better :thumbsup:
The idea of shoving your own parents in a nursing home rather than taking care of them is ridiculous.

Said the person who never took care of someone in last stage Alzheimer's....

And what happened to the person with Alzheimer's wife(or husband)? Kids? Grand kids? Brothers and sisters?
I don't remember Nancy Reagan dumping Ronald Reagan in a nursing home.
I can never do that to my own parents, and I hope my children don't do it to me.

And like I said, focking ridiculous.
 

Jhhnn

IN MEMORIAM
Nov 11, 1999
62,365
14,681
136
Well, Lothar, Nancy Reagan obviously didn't have any financial considerations whatsoever wrt Ronnie's care... She also had a huge ranch house, probably hired an entire staff just to care for him near the end.. in addition to the staff they probably had, anyway...

Do you have those resources? Do you think most people can afford that kind of care? Are there people who care provide care at your house 24/7/365?

My grandparents lived in an eldercare facility for several years. It was only a few blocks from where most of my family lives... They had dinner almost every sunday at my mom's place, often at my sister's place, very frequent visits from the rest of us, even those who lived out of town, and were actually better taken care of than we could have provided on our own... Even towards the end, when my grandmother had no idea where or who she was, family still brought her those extras, still visited, still loved her...

Good care is hard to get in major metro areas, easier in small to mid sized cities. Any facility that takes medicaid patients can't charge private-pay people any more than they do the govt, either, which limits options, splits the market into two very differently priced segments... Private care facilities are extremely expensive, at least 50% more, and the sky's the limit... When it became apparent to everybody, including my grandparents, that being cared for was the best choice, my mother took over their finances, liquidated the house, invested that money and their savings, used that to for their care and all the other stuff they needed... that fund shrank over the years, but they wanted for nothing, and there was still a substantial sum left when it was all over...

Sometimes, there's really no other way to go, whether we like it or not...
 

JD50

Lifer
Sep 4, 2005
11,630
2,015
126
Originally posted by: Lothar
Originally posted by: International Machine Consortium
Originally posted by: Lothar
Originally posted by: steppinthrax
One of the problems in this country is the low value we place on old people. In counteries like China you almost always never see nursing homes. It is expected from the children of those parents to take care of them. But in this country the youth of society finds it strange to do so.

I couldn't have said it any better :thumbsup:
The idea of shoving your own parents in a nursing home rather than taking care of them is ridiculous.

Said the person who never took care of someone in last stage Alzheimer's....

And what happened to the person with Alzheimer's wife(or husband)? Kids? Grand kids? Brothers and sisters?
I don't remember Nancy Reagan dumping Ronald Reagan in a nursing home.
I can never do that to my own parents, and I hope my children don't do it to me.

And like I said, focking ridiculous.

Oh gee I don't know, they probably have full time jobs, so I would guess that they are working.

 

imported_Lothar

Diamond Member
Aug 10, 2006
4,559
1
0
Originally posted by: Jhhnn
Well, Lothar, Nancy Reagan obviously didn't have any financial considerations whatsoever wrt Ronnie's care... She also had a huge ranch house, probably hired an entire staff just to care for him near the end.. in addition to the staff they probably had, anyway...

Do you have those resources? Do you think most people can afford that kind of care? Are there people who care provide care at your house 24/7/365?

My grandparents lived in an eldercare facility for several years. It was only a few blocks from where most of my family lives... They had dinner almost every sunday at my mom's place, often at my sister's place, very frequent visits from the rest of us, even those who lived out of town, and were actually better taken care of than we could have provided on our own... Even towards the end, when my grandmother had no idea where or who she was, family still brought her those extras, still visited, still loved her...

Good care is hard to get in major metro areas, easier in small to mid sized cities. Any facility that takes medicaid patients can't charge private-pay people any more than they do the govt, either, which limits options, splits the market into two very differently priced segments... Private care facilities are extremely expensive, at least 50% more, and the sky's the limit... When it became apparent to everybody, including my grandparents, that being cared for was the best choice, my mother took over their finances, liquidated the house, invested that money and their savings, used that to for their care and all the other stuff they needed... that fund shrank over the years, but they wanted for nothing, and there was still a substantial sum left when it was all over...

Sometimes, there's really no other way to go, whether we like it or not...

The ideal thing would be to have family members themselves providing the care.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_caregiver

Of course if the disabled person doesn't have any spouse or has only 1 or 2 children, it will be a very hard thing to do and now that I think about it, maybe I've only been looking at it from my own prespective and came of too strong.

I know my family has enough members (both immediate and extended), so nursing home won't happen.

I've asked my mother these questions already during the Terry Schavio debacle and she told me she'd rather go to where she was born and be recieving home care from family members than end up in a nursing home; she'd rather have the plug pulled than live in a vegetative state; etc...

Maybe it's a cultural thing.
 

piasabird

Lifer
Feb 6, 2002
17,168
60
91
Well if you can afford the $2,800 a month you can probably afford to buy a hospital bed and a part time nurse or a nurses assistant. There are a lot of people who can have the foresight to arrange their finances better.

For instance my grandmother died in her own bed. It is a lot more humane to refuse treatment and just cut off your drugs and die a natural death. This is a lot easier to do in a home than in a state run or private facility. You see they get paid by keeping you on happy drugs and alive. They steal your dignity and deny you of any real meaningful life.

There are other ways. Old people can sell their home to their children long before they die for a substantial loss and then there is nothing left to recover, and the children can rent the home back to the parents on paper at a loss and claim the maintenance on their rental property. All it takes is a little planning to avoid the pitfalls.

The home of the elderly can also be converted to a rental property and rented out to help pay for the care of the parent. Then the property can be improved as a rental property with a business tax deduction.

Only an idiot will sit around and wait for the state to take over their property, when it can actually make money.
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,415
14,305
136
Originally posted by: Atheus
Wow that must suck for you guys.

Hooray for socialism!

Do you think you're getting a free lunch over there, then?
 

boredhokie

Senior member
May 7, 2005
625
0
0
I work for a firm that sells Long Term Care insurance. Anyone who has parents that are getting on in life should consider looking into this coverage - it's not the cheapest to own, but it shields your parents from losing their assets to nursing homes/hospices and also guarantees a high quality of life for them when they need it most.

I don't sell the stuff, I work in IT. I do think it is a good product and if your parents/grandparents think that medicare and the 401k will save them, then they're wrong - I went through the same situation as the OP's story with my grandmother last year.

If they're relying on you to take care of them when they're senile and suffering from alzheimer's; well, have fun with that.
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,062
1
0
Originally posted by: Vic
This is not new. We have known for years that my GF's grandmother's house will be going straight to the state of California when she passes away.

Sadly, this just demonstrates the socialists entitlement fantasy world, where people are forced to purchase products for their own good, tricked into believing that they're getting something for nothing. They rip on the rich and income blah blah blah while all they while the ignore that it is not income that is wealth, but assets, and here they come to take the family home. So the divide between rich and poor grows ever greater even as income taxes get higher. Coincidence? Hell no.

haven't taxes been dropping the last few years, at least thats what people try to tell me.
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,062
1
0
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: XMan
Originally posted by: Craig234
Originally posted by: XMan
Do inheritance taxes apply to family homes?

Yes. Note that democrats are in favor of increasing exemptions around this to decrease the liability to the inheritance tax around family homes for people.

They are at odds with republicans who want to abolish the tax.

What with the rise in property values, they're going to need to get to work on those exemptions . . .

I never have understood the inheritance tax. You've already paid taxes on your assets throughout your life, then once you die it's suddenly time for the government to get another bite? No thanks.

I have the opposite opinion. I'd rather see little to no taxes throughout life, then 100% estate taxes at death.

oddly, this appeals to me.
 

techs

Lifer
Sep 26, 2000
28,561
4
0
Originally posted by: Lothar
Originally posted by: Jhhnn
Well, Lothar, Nancy Reagan obviously didn't have any financial considerations whatsoever wrt Ronnie's care... She also had a huge ranch house, probably hired an entire staff just to care for him near the end.. in addition to the staff they probably had, anyway...

Do you have those resources? Do you think most people can afford that kind of care? Are there people who care provide care at your house 24/7/365?

My grandparents lived in an eldercare facility for several years. It was only a few blocks from where most of my family lives... They had dinner almost every sunday at my mom's place, often at my sister's place, very frequent visits from the rest of us, even those who lived out of town, and were actually better taken care of than we could have provided on our own... Even towards the end, when my grandmother had no idea where or who she was, family still brought her those extras, still visited, still loved her...

Good care is hard to get in major metro areas, easier in small to mid sized cities. Any facility that takes medicaid patients can't charge private-pay people any more than they do the govt, either, which limits options, splits the market into two very differently priced segments... Private care facilities are extremely expensive, at least 50% more, and the sky's the limit... When it became apparent to everybody, including my grandparents, that being cared for was the best choice, my mother took over their finances, liquidated the house, invested that money and their savings, used that to for their care and all the other stuff they needed... that fund shrank over the years, but they wanted for nothing, and there was still a substantial sum left when it was all over...

Sometimes, there's really no other way to go, whether we like it or not...

The ideal thing would be to have family members themselves providing the care.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_caregiver

Of course if the disabled person doesn't have any spouse or has only 1 or 2 children, it will be a very hard thing to do and now that I think about it, maybe I've only been looking at it from my own prespective and came of too strong.

I know my family has enough members (both immediate and extended), so nursing home won't happen.

I've asked my mother these questions already during the Terry Schavio debacle and she told me she'd rather go to where she was born and be recieving home care from family members than end up in a nursing home; she'd rather have the plug pulled than live in a vegetative state; etc...

Maybe it's a cultural thing.
Actually the article says that most kids DO take care of their parents. The point is that it will pretty much wipe out your parents savings, their homes and the kids bank account.

 
Oct 30, 2004
11,442
32
91
Originally posted by: steppinthrax
One of the problems in this country is the low value we place on old people. In counteries like China you almost always never see nursing homes. It is expected from the children of those parents to take care of them. But in this country the youth of society finds it strange to do so. This has been going on in China for 100s of years and they don't have this same problem as we do. They also live significatnely longer then us. As far as Nuring home being expensive what in the hell kind of price do you expect if someone is taking care of your room, meals, electricity, medical, dental etc....

When all of the adult children and their spouses are working full time, 5 days-a-week during the week, it might be kind of difficult to provide the needed care during workdays. Also, not everyone has the needed caregiving skills and many adult children are old themselves and might not be in proper physical condition to provide care (the 60 year old folks who would be caring for an 87 year old woman).
 
Oct 30, 2004
11,442
32
91
Originally posted by: jackschmittusa
Well, if I get to the point where I need to go to a nursing home long term, just let me die. Quality of life is very important to me.

It would be nice if voluntary, painless suicide were an available and legal option for people who no longer wish to live for whatever reason. I have a grandmother in her late 80's and she's now either completely or almost completely blind. She's very miserable and has wanted to die for years. I'd want to die too if I'd lost my eyesight. It's not that she's poor (far from it) or suffering from other medical problems; she's just miserable without her eyesight.

If I ever get Alzheimer's, I'd want to commit suicide and my wife feels the same way. I suspect that millions of Americans share similar feelings.
 

Craig234

Lifer
May 1, 2006
38,548
348
126
Originally posted by: WhipperSnapper
Originally posted by: jackschmittusa
Well, if I get to the point where I need to go to a nursing home long term, just let me die. Quality of life is very important to me.

It would be nice if voluntary, painless suicide were an available and legal option for people who no longer wish to live for whatever reason. I have a grandmother in her late 80's and she's now either completely or almost completely blind. She's very miserable and has wanted to die for years. I'd want to die too if I'd lost my eyesight. It's not that she's poor (far from it) or suffering from other medical problems; she's just miserable without her eyesight.

If I ever get Alzheimer's, I'd want to commit suicide and my wife feels the same way. I suspect that millions of Americans share similar feelings.

If it were legalized, an ugly problem would be created where older people who did not want that were pressured by the family to do it, to avoid draining the family savings.

Having it outside the list of options protects from the bad side of people coming out more.