• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Why is the Ring so powerful in LOTR?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: SubZeroX
Thanks kami! I think I should read the books now. I read the Hobbit a long time ago and wanted to continue on to read LOTR but never got around to it.

By the way, does the Elf chick eventually "do it" with Strider? Just wondering, hahaha.

LOL this was one of the things that was added to the movie that wasn't in the books. LOTRs purists absolutly hate the fact that it was put in. I don't really mind it. So to answer you question according to Tolkien... no.... according to Peter Jackson.. we'll have to wait and see 🙂
 
LOL this was one of the things that was added to the movie that wasn't in the books. LOTRs purists absolutly hate the fact that it was put in. I don't really mind it. So to answer you question according to Tolkien... no.... according to Peter Jackson.. we'll have to wait and see
I think you need to read the LOTR appendices 🙂 Most everything of what PJ put in the films about Arwen + Aragorn was written by Tolkien. They do have kids after he becomes king.
 
Originally posted by: kami

No I haven't...how many are there now? It's intimidating just thinking about reading that massive series...but I will some day 🙂 Next on my list is the A Song of Ice and Fire series...been wanting to read those for a long time.


There are 9 currently the 10th comes out in November. So they are really good (I'm only on book 2) Yeah there is a TON of reading but I can't bring myself to read the whole background of middle earth with the silmarion and all...... maybe someday
 
Kami: that was probably the best, most concise explanation of the Lord of the Rings setup I've ever heard...
 
alls i know is that in the movie the elf chix were HOT. their rings must give them the power of HOTNESS or something.

IMO, people get to into this stuff. they're just books, for chrissake
 
Originally posted by: tokamak
alls i know is that in the movie the elf chix were HOT. their rings must give them the power of HOTNESS or something.

IMO, people get to into this stuff. they're just books, for chrissake

I thought those elves were all men.
 
Kami: that was probably the best, most concise explanation of the Lord of the Rings setup I've ever heard...
Thanks 🙂

alls i know is that in the movie the elf chix were HOT. their rings must give them the power of HOTNESS or something.

IMO, people get to into this stuff. they're just books, for chrissake
Damn good books though 🙂
 
I think they had more then just a few kids. and has king he lived for a cuple hundred years.
 
Originally posted by: Adul
I think they had more then just a few kids. and has king he lived for a cuple hundred years.

Well, one son and a unknown amount of daughters. I think he lived for about 120 years after the Ring was destroyed.
 
tokamak, are u talking about the brunette Elf chick played by Liv Tyler (don't know her name) or the weird blonde Elf chick? I like the Brunette one better.
 
Just saw the movie again today at Super Savers Cinema (or something like that) for $2. Can't wait for TTT either.


Sauron was originally a Maiar (the same race as Gandalf), but in the early days the Dark Lord Melkor seduced Sauron, and then Sauron became Melkor's most feared servant. After a long time, the Valar (you do NOT want me to try and delve into them) assaulted Melkor and took him away. Sauron escaped this assault and remained in Middle-earth, and then later on in the second age the whole thing with the rings of power begins.

Oh please do (delve into them). And is all the above in the Silmarillion? I'll have the time to read LOTR and Sil, but probably nothing else. So I'm really hoping Sil answers most of my questions.
 
Originally posted by: SubZeroX
tokamak, are u talking about the brunette Elf chick played by Liv Tyler (don't know her name) or the weird blonde Elf chick? I like the Brunette one better.
The elf played by Liv Tyler is Arwen, the one played by the weird blonde chick ( Cate Blanchett ) is Galadriel, queen of Lorien.
Arwen is the one thet gets it on with Aragorn...

I'm suprised Kami didn't say that the ring wraiths were technically the nazgul, not to try to upstage the man, but he did it for almost everything else...
 
Originally posted by: SubZeroXtokamak, are u talking about the brunette Elf chick played by Liv Tyler (don't know her name) or the weird blonde Elf chick? I like the Brunette one better.

i was talking about both, but especially the one played by liv tyler. funny thing is, i dont think she is that attractive outside of the movie.
 
Originally posted by: SubZeroX
tokamak, are u talking about the brunette Elf chick played by Liv Tyler (don't know her name) or the weird blonde Elf chick? I like the Brunette one better.

I think he's talking about the archer guy (weird blonde Elf chick). 😉
 
Originally posted by: MindStorm
Just saw the movie again today at Super Savers Cinema (or something like that) for $2. Can't wait for TTT either.


Sauron was originally a Maiar (the same race as Gandalf), but in the early days the Dark Lord Melkor seduced Sauron, and then Sauron became Melkor's most feared servant. After a long time, the Valar (you do NOT want me to try and delve into them) assaulted Melkor and took him away. Sauron escaped this assault and remained in Middle-earth, and then later on in the second age the whole thing with the rings of power begins.

Oh please do (delve into them). And is all the above in the Silmarillion? I'll have the time to read LOTR and Sil, but probably nothing else. So I'm really hoping Sil answers most of my questions.


It's in the Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales. The Valar were the Guardians of the World and the Maiar were lesser but similar beings that served them.
 
Originally posted by: MindStorm
Just saw the movie again today at Super Savers Cinema (or something like that) for $2. Can't wait for TTT either.


Sauron was originally a Maiar (the same race as Gandalf), but in the early days the Dark Lord Melkor seduced Sauron, and then Sauron became Melkor's most feared servant. After a long time, the Valar (you do NOT want me to try and delve into them) assaulted Melkor and took him away. Sauron escaped this assault and remained in Middle-earth, and then later on in the second age the whole thing with the rings of power begins.

Oh please do (delve into them). And is all the above in the Silmarillion? I'll have the time to read LOTR and Sil, but probably nothing else. So I'm really hoping Sil answers most of my questions.

Yes.

And Sauron was a wimp compared to Gothmog! *likes Balrogs*
 
Didn't read the thread in detail, but....

In the ancient times, elvish blacksmiths created the Rings off Power. Three for elves, seven for dwares and nine for mortal men. But their work was corrupted by Sauron, who created the One Ring. He poured large part of his power in to the ring, and as long as the ring survived, Sauron wouldn't really be defeated.

The ring gives it's owner power over the other rings and the thigs that were made with those rings. In reality that means that it gives te ruler of the One Ring power over the world. It's lesser power is that it turns the wearer of the ring invisible. The One rong doesn't have power over the three elvish rings, because those are hidden from Sauron.

Kami already gave brief description of Sauron, but here's some more. In the beginning, Valar created the world together with Ilúvatar in the Music of The Ainur. But during The Creation, Melkor, one of the Valar, corrupted the creation. He turned against the other Valar, and he was cast out and given the name Morgoth (The despised). Morgoth came to Middle-earth and enslaved it. Sauron was Morgoths servant. Eventually Morgoth was destroyed in The War of The Silmarils. All this happened long before LOTR takes place. If you want to read abou it, go read Silmarillion.

You could say that Valar = Gods, Maiar = angels. Then who is Ilúvatar? He (she? It?) has always existed. He was before anything else.
 
Originally posted by: Skyclad1uhm1
And Sauron was a wimp compared to Gothmog! *likes Balrogs*

That would e a cool fight to see 😉. For you that don't know, both Gothmog and Sauron were servants of Morgoth (THE badass!). Gothmog was the captain of The Balrogs. He was a major badass!
 
Originally posted by: Nemesis77
Didn't read the thread in detail, but....

In the ancient times, elvish blacksmiths created the Rings off Power. Three for elves, seven for dwares and nine for mortal men. But their work was corrupted by Sauron, who created the One Ring. He poured large part of his power in to the ring, and as long as the ring survived, Sauron wouldn't really be defeated.

The ring gives it's owner power over the other rings and the thigs that were made with those rings. In reality that means that it gives te ruler of the One Ring power over the world. It's lesser power is that it turns the wearer of the ring invisible. The One rong doesn't have power over the three elvish rings, because those are hidden from Sauron.

Kami already gave brief description of Sauron, but here's some more. In the beginning, Valar created the world together with Ilúvatar in the Music of The Ainur. But during The Creation, Melkor, one of the Valar, corrupted the creation. He turned against the other Valar, and he was cast out and given the name Morgoth (The despised). Morgoth came to Middle-earth and enslaved it. Sauron was Morgoths servant. Eventually Morgoth was destroyed in The War of The Silmarils. All this happened long before LOTR takes place. If you want to read abou it, go read Silmarillion.

You could say that Valar = Gods, Maiar = angels. Then who is Ilúvatar? He (she? It?) has always existed. He was before anything else.

Morgoth could not be destroyed if I remember correctly, he was merely enchained.
Sauron, Gothmog and the rest of the Balrogs were 'lesser' Valor who followed Morgoth when he left the others. Ilúvatar created the world, but when he saw Morgoth corrupting it got angry and made it a prison for Morgoth, too late realizing he had just condemned his creation too (Morgoth couldn't leave the prison, but Ilúvatar couldn't enter it either without being imprisoned himself). The elves, humans, dwarves and other beings that Ilúvatar had created fought great battles with Morgoth and his followers, and managed to destroy most of the Balrogs and enchain Morgoth himself. Sauron was weakened, but not captured, and as the power of the elves and such diminished, and ancient knowledge was forgotten, Sauron slowly grew in power again.

May be wrong, it's been about 12-13 years since I read it, but it should be about right.

P.S. Orcs, or dark-elves, were elves which were corrupted by Morgoth.
 
Morgoth could not be destroyed if I remember correctly, he was merely enchained.
That is correct...that's why i said above they only took him away (to Valar), not destroyed him.

Oh please do (delve into them). And is all the above in the Silmarillion? I'll have the time to read LOTR and Sil, but probably nothing else. So I'm really hoping Sil answers most of my questions.
The Valar are basically the creators or gods...more info here.
 
I am going to rent this the start of next month when it is on DVD, but I heard the end really leaves you hanging. Is that true?

I don't think I got any spoilers here besides the invisible thing, because the rest of it lost me with all the names, lol.
 
Hmm... I read the LOTR trilogy and was wondering why Gandalf never does anything really wizardlike (or perhaps my definition of a wizard is skewed)? IIRC he just threw out some lightning bolts at the nazgul and held them off. Interestingly, it is a hobbit (Pippin? Merry?) who kills the Nazgul leader.
 
Originally posted by: 911paramedic
I am going to rent this the start of next month when it is on DVD, but I heard the end really leaves you hanging. Is that true?

I don't think I got any spoilers here besides the invisible thing, because the rest of it lost me with all the names, lol.
It leaves you hanging because there's still 2 more movies 😉

Hmm... I read the LOTR trilogy and was wondering why Gandalf never does anything really wizardlike (or perhaps my definition of a wizard is skewed)? IIRC he just threw out some lightning bolts at the nazgul and held them off. Interestingly, it is a hobbit (Pippin? Merry?) who kills the Nazgul leader.
Well, the way I read it, Gandalf isn't as much a 'wizard' as a demi-god/angel type thing. And some of his power comes from the Elf ring that was given to him when he entered Middle Earth from the west. That being said, it's generally accepted that Gandalf didn't show the full extent of his power in Middle-Earth. :Q

I would also like to add that Ents 0wn j00 all.
 
All frodo/bilbo really know how to do is use it to go invisible which is automatic to them, but if they knew more they'd be seriously powerful. It does "All kinds of crazy sh*t"!
 
Back
Top