Why is prostitution legalized in Las Vegas while it is ILLEGAL everywhere else in the United States?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Looney

Lifer
Jun 13, 2000
21,938
5
0
Originally posted by: WayneTeK
For escort services... is sex an expected thing from the customer? Isn't an escort just a companion for the night to take out?

LOL yeah, people are going to spend hundreds per hour just for dinner with a stranger.
 

MAME

Banned
Sep 19, 2003
9,281
1
0
Why the hell would any country make it illegal? Tax is, regulate it and watch how little harm it does. Government shouldn't restrict something that's 100% natrual
 

iwearnosox

Lifer
Oct 26, 2000
16,018
5
0
Originally posted by: MAME
Why the hell would any country make it illegal? Tax is, regulate it and watch how little harm it does. Government shouldn't restrict something that's 100% natrual

Like pot? Or Ricin?
 

IamElectro

Golden Member
Jul 15, 2003
1,470
0
76
The government allows it so all the geeks at Area 51 can get some and keep them coming back to work.
 

TheNinja

Lifer
Jan 22, 2003
12,207
1
0
Originally posted by: iwearnosox
Originally posted by: MAME
Why the hell would any country make it illegal? Tax is, regulate it and watch how little harm it does. Government shouldn't restrict something that's 100% natrual

Like pot? Or Ricin?

There is a difference. Chemicals can cause harm to yourself and (the key:) to others. Having sex with a strange person if done as safely as possible doesn't harm others. I have a hard time with this prostitution one. Morally and ethically it is wrong in my mind, but legally I'm just not sure why it should be illegal as long as it is consenting adults.
 

Looney

Lifer
Jun 13, 2000
21,938
5
0
Originally posted by: MAME
Why the hell would any country make it illegal? Tax is, regulate it and watch how little harm it does. Government shouldn't restrict something that's 100% natrual

Because it's 'immoral'.

Personally i believe it should be legal. Why should sex always involve a relationship? Why can't it just be 'bought'? Everybody has needs, not everybody has the capability or time to acquire it properly. What if you were 18 or 19, no relationship, entered the military, went over to the middle east for a year doing your duty, come back and you're horny as hell seeing all the women again. I would certainly want to hit the prostitutes on my first days back. If i was in the Navy, i certainly wouldn't want to be in a relationship. Sure, you can be monogamous when you're at sea (unless you're gay, or unless your ship is co-ed, which some are these days?), but you can't be sure your SO is. It would certainly be hard to start a proper relationship when you're always taking off to sea for half a year at a time.

As long as the women consent to it, i really don't see a problem with it.

That being said, i think i'm starting to like the idea of the Canadian laws, where the women can't work from a single establishment. Look at countries that do have legalized prostitution. There are entire districts of area where there are nothing but prostitutes, and they're even showcased in windows. I know my local area has a big escort business, so big that part of the local government wanted the women to acquire licensing... that way they could properly track the women (so they're not 'pimped' out), and know where they're doing it (and tax them of course).... but there was a big uproar here and it never went through.
 

Black88GTA

Diamond Member
Sep 9, 2003
3,430
0
0
Mmmmmm, legalized prostitution. You could go to an expensive place when funds allowed, or if money was tight, there's a Little Skeezers Pooneria on every corner....

I'm all for it :). I think it should be allowed, between consenting adults. Would certainly help the country's financial situation with all the revenue it would generate in taxes.
 

WayneTeK

Golden Member
Apr 3, 2002
1,283
2
0
Originally posted by: JEDI
heard brothels in LV are $400/hr ;)

holy crap.. that's a grip... $400/ hr? I would imagine that number fluctuates up and down depending on "quality".

Actually, if you compare that to a lapdance ($15 x 30 dances <you figure each dance is 2 minutes long> = $450!), going to a brothel is cheaper..
 

JEDI

Lifer
Sep 25, 2001
29,391
2,738
126
Originally posted by: WayneTeK
Originally posted by: JEDI
heard brothels in LV are $400/hr ;)

holy crap.. that's a grip... $400/ hr? I would imagine that number fluctuates up and down depending on "quality".

Actually, if you compare that to a lapdance ($15 x 30 dances <you figure each dance is 2 minutes long> = $450!), going to a brothel is cheaper..

$200 for the girl, $200 for the house.

if u go during slow times (ie: weekday around 3pm), u go go as low as $250/hr. (if u leave b4 the hr, u still have for the full hr)

but just to compare pricing:
Amstradam red light district: $50 but as soon as you're done, you're out the door. So for that extra $200, u can put towards the airfare and have a vacation in amstradam.

AGAIN, THIS IS WHAT I'VE READ AND HEARD! :D
 

CQuinn

Golden Member
May 31, 2000
1,656
0
0
WayneTek, if you are still reading this... please to change your subject line to:

"Why is prostitution legalized in Nevada while it is ILLEGAL everywhere else in the United States?"

IIRC, (and I'm not at home to do proper research on the subject, so some of my facts will be off), it was legal in the territory of Nevada before they achieved statehood - or something like that.
It then became illegal because federal law overrides state law in that matter, and federal laws
make prostitution illegal.

However, the state legislators found an interesting loophole (?) that made already exisiting
brothels tolerable under the law, as long as they did not impact on a significant number
of state residents. Which is why they can have legal brothels in the smaller counties, with
populations under a target number; while cities like Las Vegas get to make extra revenue by
busting all the goobers who come to town looking for "legal" hookers without actually checking
the local laws.

Side Trivia: The US Government owned one of those brothels at one point. The Mustang Ranch
(IIRC) was seized by the IRS for nonpayment of back taxes, and they had to maintain the
"services" of the establishment until they could find someone to buy the business from them.

 

Chaotic42

Lifer
Jun 15, 2001
34,443
1,620
126
Originally posted by: CQuinn
WayneTek, if you are still reading this... please to change your subject line to:

"Why is prostitution legalized in Nevada while it is ILLEGAL everywhere else in the United States?"

IIRC, (and I'm not at home to do proper research on the subject, so some of my facts will be off), it was legal in the territory of Nevada before they achieved statehood - or something like that.
It then became illegal because federal law overrides state law in that matter, and federal laws
make prostitution illegal.

However, the state legislators found an interesting loophole (?) that made already exisiting
brothels tolerable under the law, as long as they did not impact on a significant number
of state residents. Which is why they can have legal brothels in the smaller counties, with
populations under a target number; while cities like Las Vegas get to make extra revenue by
busting all the goobers who come to town looking for "legal" hookers without actually checking
the local laws.

Side Trivia: The US Government owned one of those brothels at one point. The Mustang Ranch
(IIRC) was seized by the IRS for nonpayment of back taxes, and they had to maintain the
"services" of the establishment until they could find someone to buy the business from them.

The station I just worked at recently ran an inverview with the owner of the Bunny Ranch in Nevada. He said that prostitution was legal in any county in Nevada that had fewer than 400,000 residents. He said that there was something like a 30% increase in AIDS cases among prostitutes in Las Vegas over the last 5 years.
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
Originally posted by: Staley8
Originally posted by: iwearnosox
Originally posted by: MAME
Why the hell would any country make it illegal? Tax is, regulate it and watch how little harm it does. Government shouldn't restrict something that's 100% natrual

Like pot? Or Ricin?

There is a difference. Chemicals can cause harm to yourself and (the key:) to others. Having sex with a strange person if done as safely as possible doesn't harm others. I have a hard time with this prostitution one. Morally and ethically it is wrong in my mind, but legally I'm just not sure why it should be illegal as long as it is consenting adults.

I think it's because from an economic standpoint every woman would become a prostitute -- it just pays too well compared to the lower pay women are getting now from jobs. But most of us wouldn't want our daughters, sisters, or mom's to be prostitute -- and that's why it's "illegal".
 

kenshorin

Golden Member
Apr 14, 2001
1,160
0
0
Originally posted by: galvanizedyankee
I just stopped for a tall iced-t and to shoot
some 9 ball, honest!

What you really mean is that you stopped by to shoot some two ball? :D
 

Walleye

Banned
Dec 1, 2002
7,939
0
0
Originally posted by: Sifl
Originally posted by: Moralpanic
Prostitution is legal in Canada, as long as it's not being sold at a single location and it's not explicit. For example, brothels (and massage parlors) are illegal in Canada. So are street prositution if they're at a single location, like a corner... but if they take orders from a newspaper ad, or part of an escorts service, it's legal. If anything, it should be the opposite. At an establishment, there's at least safety for the women. But i guess they don't want areas that are known as 'red light' districts and explict buildings known as brothels.
How about opening a website called whoresrus.com up there then?

whoresrus.co.ca ;)
 

bsobel

Moderator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Dec 9, 2001
13,346
0
0
Originally posted by: Sifl
Originally posted by: Moralpanic
Prostitution is legal in Canada, as long as it's not being sold at a single location and it's not explicit. For example, brothels (and massage parlors) are illegal in Canada. So are street prositution if they're at a single location, like a corner... but if they take orders from a newspaper ad, or part of an escorts service, it's legal. If anything, it should be the opposite. At an establishment, there's at least safety for the women. But i guess they don't want areas that are known as 'red light' districts and explict buildings known as brothels.
How about opening a website called whoresrus.com up there then?

Probably because whoresrus is already taken by some folks in Texas ;)

[whois.bestregistrar.com]
Whois Server Version 2.0

Domain Name: WHORESRUS.COM

Registrant:
Organization: Compana
Contact ID: COMPA123
Name: Compana LLC
Address: P.O. Box 111501, Carrollton
Texas, 75011, US
Phone: 1 413-215-1195 Fax: 1 413-215-1195
Email: admindns@ureach.com

Administrative Contact:
Organization: Compana
Contact ID: COMPA123
Name: Compana LLC
Address: P.O. Box 111501, Carrollton
Texas, 75011, US
Phone: 1 413-215-1195 Fax: 1 413-215-1195
Email: admindns@ureach.com

Technical Contact:
Organization: Compana
Contact ID: COMPA123
Name: Compana LLC
Address: P.O. Box 111501, Carrollton
Texas, 75011, US
Phone: 1 413-215-1195 Fax: 1 413-215-1195
Email: admindns@ureach.com

Name Servers:
NS1.COMPANA.COM
NS2.COMPANA.COM

Created Date: Aug 27, 2003
Updated Date: Aug 27, 2003
Expiration Date: Aug 27, 2004