Why choose engineering?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

JohnCU

Banned
Dec 9, 2000
16,528
4
0
Originally posted by: bigdog1218
Originally posted by: sao123
But when I see the words... "for the betterment of humanity credo?" I think Nobel Prize Winners and the equivolent. Theres a big difference between doing something and getting a lot of credit for it, and changing the entire world.
Here is my internal problem with that... By nature, Engineers are problem solvers, they create solutions to given local problems. Scientists perform theoretical research in the fields of learning which eventually apply to engineering. Scientists change the world, engineers dont.


Keyword "theoretical" What good are a million great ideas if they can never be used in society? Scientists get credit for changing the world whereas engineers actually make it happen.

yeah, we make it practical and a reality, with the constraints of time and money always hanging over our heads. scientists don't usually concern themselves with that.
 

Tiamat

Lifer
Nov 25, 2003
14,068
5
71
Chemical Engineering FTW!

You have demand in work from petroleum industry to applied chemicals, nanofabrication, drug delivery, bio-tech, thin-films, material science, etc.
 

Bryophyte

Lifer
Apr 25, 2001
13,430
13
81
I asked my spouse what his dream job would be back when we were first together and he said "designing CPUs". So he went back to school and got his BSEE & MSEE because that's what he needed to do to get there.
 

flawlssdistortn

Senior member
Sep 21, 2004
680
0
0
Although I really had no idea what I was getting myself into, I started out my college career in Electrical Engineering at Marquette. I managed to kind of squeak by freshman year, meaning I got decent grades but didn't really understand everything. Sophomore year things caught up with me, and I found my math skills were not up to par. Had to transfer, took me a while to get my sh!t together, but now I am finishing up EE @ UIC.

My interest is embedded systems, so I've been working on microcontroller projects lately. I just made my own digital thermometer :) Next I'll probably be thinking about fan control for my computer, or wiring up my lights and air conditioner so I can run them all from my PC :p

One has to realize that the field of Electical Engineering is vast. Within it there's power electronics, control systems, microelectronics, signals processing, communications, computers... And each of these disciplines has further subsets. As an undergrad, you'll barely scatch the surface - there is just too much to cover. You won't gain much practical knowledge, but you will get a solid introduction to the entire field, and an idea of where you want to specialize. With only a BS, an electrical engineer's education is only beginning... Either in the workplace or in grad school, there is much more to learn.

I wouldn't advise anyone to study electical engineering unless they really enjoy it. Sure, the pay is great, but you have to work your ass off for it. This is not a 9-5 type gig. You have to always be looking to improve yourself and learn something new. Technology is developing at such an incredible rate that people who stop studying could find themselves left behind.
 

JohnCU

Banned
Dec 9, 2000
16,528
4
0
Originally posted by: flawlssdistortn
Although I really had no idea what I was getting myself into, I started out my college career in Electrical Engineering at Marquette. I managed to kind of squeak by freshman year, meaning I got decent grades but didn't really understand everything. Sophomore year things caught up with me, and I found my math skills were not up to par. Had to transfer, took me a while to get my sh!t together, but now I am finishing up EE @ UIC.

My interest is embedded systems, so I've been working on microcontroller projects lately. I just made my own digital thermometer :) Next I'll probably be thinking about fan control for my computer, or wiring up my lights and air conditioner so I can run them all from my PC :p

One has to realize that the field of Electical Engineering is vast. Within it there's power electronics, control systems, microelectronics, signals processing, communications, computers... And each of these disciplines has further subsets. As an undergrad, you'll barely scatch the surface - there is just too much to cover. You won't gain much practical knowledge, but you will get a solid introduction to the entire field, and an idea of where you want to specialize. With only a BS, an electrical engineer's education is only beginning... Either in the workplace or in grad school, there is much more to learn.

I wouldn't advise anyone to study electical engineering unless they really enjoy it. Sure, the pay is great, but you have to work your ass off for it. This is not a 9-5 type gig. You have to always be looking to improve yourself and learn something new. Technology is developing at such an incredible rate that people who stop studying could find themselves left behind.

that's for damn sure. EE is like having an 8am class and 5 pm lab for the rest of your life. here at the power plant I work at, we don't get paid for the first 5 hours of overtime, or for anything after 67. it's a sh!tty world.

 

Special K

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2000
7,098
0
76
I am a grad student in EE and find the work interesting and want to design CPUs, but I just can't get over the fact that engineers don't make as much money as doctors and don't get nearly as much respect either. I'm not saying the doctors don't deserve the respect, but I hate having to choose something I enjoy (engineering) over something that pays well and commands respect (medicine) but I don't find nearly as interesting, when I know I have the aptitude to do either.
 

feelingshorter

Platinum Member
May 5, 2004
2,439
0
71
Originally posted by: JohnCU
Originally posted by: flawlssdistortn
Although I really had no idea what I was getting myself into, I started out my college career in Electrical Engineering at Marquette. I managed to kind of squeak by freshman year, meaning I got decent grades but didn't really understand everything. Sophomore year things caught up with me, and I found my math skills were not up to par. Had to transfer, took me a while to get my sh!t together, but now I am finishing up EE @ UIC.

My interest is embedded systems, so I've been working on microcontroller projects lately. I just made my own digital thermometer :) Next I'll probably be thinking about fan control for my computer, or wiring up my lights and air conditioner so I can run them all from my PC :p

One has to realize that the field of Electical Engineering is vast. Within it there's power electronics, control systems, microelectronics, signals processing, communications, computers... And each of these disciplines has further subsets. As an undergrad, you'll barely scatch the surface - there is just too much to cover. You won't gain much practical knowledge, but you will get a solid introduction to the entire field, and an idea of where you want to specialize. With only a BS, an electrical engineer's education is only beginning... Either in the workplace or in grad school, there is much more to learn.

I wouldn't advise anyone to study electical engineering unless they really enjoy it. Sure, the pay is great, but you have to work your ass off for it. This is not a 9-5 type gig. You have to always be looking to improve yourself and learn something new. Technology is developing at such an incredible rate that people who stop studying could find themselves left behind.

that's for damn sure. EE is like having an 8am class and 5 pm lab for the rest of your life. here at the power plant I work at, we don't get paid for the first 5 hours of overtime, or for anything after 67. it's a sh!tty world.

I was about ot go into EE at my local college as they offered a small scholarship. Just recently i backed out of it and now im undecided again. After much research, i feel that EEs work their ass off too much as compared to being a dentist/optometrist or something like that. They barely work and get paid more. My cousin whos a dentist works 5 days a week just because he doesnt need the extra money (aparently, hes making enough).
 

Bryophyte

Lifer
Apr 25, 2001
13,430
13
81
Originally posted by: Special K
I am a grad student in EE and find the work interesting and want to design CPUs, but I just can't get over the fact that engineers don't make as much money as doctors and don't get nearly as much respect either. I'm not saying the doctors don't deserve the respect, but I hate having to choose something I enjoy (engineering) over something that pays well and commands respect (medicine) but I don't find nearly as interesting, when I know I have the aptitude to do either.

CPU DEs make decent money.
 

blipblop

Senior member
Jun 23, 2004
639
0
76
For me, it was just loving the field. You are also one of a few that when you graduate can say that you're an engineer. You will get credit for that and people will know that you've got some smarts since you made it through school. the engineering discipline is very diffifcult and you will always be wondering how the business majors are just hanging around and having fun...
 

iwantanewcomputer

Diamond Member
Apr 4, 2004
5,045
0
0
You hear it a lot, but do what you like...don't go into engineering unless you are interested in the subject/technology/research.
 

MrBond

Diamond Member
Feb 5, 2000
9,911
0
76
Originally posted by: Tiamat
Chemical Engineering FTW!

You have demand in work from petroleum industry to applied chemicals, nanofabrication, drug delivery, bio-tech, thin-films, material science, etc.
Chemical Engineering is a lot of fun, but it's no walk in the park to get your degree. At my school, we had several good looking women in my class too (the good looking women outnumbered the not-so-good-looking ones pretty easily). BioE had more hotties for sure, but that's really no reason to pick a major. You're allowed to date girls in other majors :D.

The only bad part about being a Chemical Engineer is having people annoy you complaining about the cost of gas. I've taken to telling people that I think it should cost more and I should probably be driving a bigger car to keep my fellow ChemE's employed. I don't work in the oil industry directly, but it does effect me (plastics).
 

bharok

Senior member
Jun 19, 2001
401
0
0
Originally posted by: ramirez
For all the EE's here, why did you choose this degree? Also, how hard is the curriculum and does the difficulty vary with different colleges?


I'm a senior in EE and I did it because I love designing things (electrical systems etc...) .

Yes it is tough, very tough, but I enjoy what I work on so I am glad I went with it.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
Originally posted by: sao123
Electro Engineers dont get credit for the whole betterment of society... Electronics make life more complex & difficult for most, not easier. Hint: (the unusable VCR, the coffee pot you have to program, etc)
Go Aero, Civil, Mechanical, (Bio)Chemical, or Nuclear.

I guess it depends on the mindset of the user. I can use appliances like that very quickly without needing the manual. What seems totally screwy to other people is perfectly intuitive to me. My theory on that is that the engineer mindset differs considerably from the average person.
 

veggz

Banned
Jan 3, 2005
843
0
0
Originally posted by: ramirez
For all the EE's here, why did you choose this degree? Also, how hard is the curriculum and does the difficulty vary with different colleges?

You bet the curriculum varies according to college, just like every other major.
 

Rumpltzer

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2003
4,815
33
91
Originally posted by: Fenixgoon
all your base are belong to materials engineers, suckas!:D
I work with a lot of material science engineers in semiconductor fabrication and device development. At some point, someone decided that they'd make good process engineers.

It's frustrating to me how little they understand. For example, one of them is currently attempting to design a process test structure. I spent ten minutes explaining the difference between "open" and "short" and then the difference between current and voltage. We ended with a lesson on the dynamics of how resistors work when put in series. I used analogies to "big pipes" and "little pipes" to get the point across.

I suppose I do feel like a "sucka" because I actually showed up to sceince class that day in junior high, and this MatSE apparently did not.

Yeah. :D
 

ajouvenat

Junior Member
Aug 19, 2006
1
0
0
I've been fooling around with electronics and computers since I was about 8 or 9, so the choice to go EE was pretty easy. I was into 3d art once I got out of high school, and did computer animation for a year at an art school. However, I started playing hockey again when I turned 19, and I had to transfer to a school that had a sports program. I would like to get into GPU design engineering once I graduate as it would have some ties to my interest in 3d.

 

SamurAchzar

Platinum Member
Feb 15, 2006
2,422
3
76
First of all, we're all in this site for a reason, and that's probably not ATOT. I mean, it might be now ;) but we came here for the love of computers, which AFAIK aren't made by Nuclear engineers (that might change with the NV9000 and R20000 GPUs, though). So EE already has some head start.

In any case, there's ALOT of demand for EEs in almost any place with good high tech industry, and there's stable demand elsewhere as almost no product nowadays runs without some kind of electronics in it.
Plus, it's a very nice industry to work for compared to others. I mean, Petroleum engineers might get more money, but then, would you REALLY want to check the piping on a barge in Alaska? Dunno.

The only issue I'd think of is what happens if you have any aspirations of becoming a business owner. AFAIK, it's MUCH easier to do Civil Engineering (etc.) conslutantcy than it is with EE.
 

azoomee

Golden Member
Jan 5, 2002
1,054
0
0
EE is a good foundation for alot of industries. Combine it with an MBA and you'll be very well rounded. Never actually applied my specific EE degree but the experience allowed me to understand alot of technical ideas during work.
 

Fenixgoon

Lifer
Jun 30, 2003
33,421
13,044
136
Originally posted by: Rumpltzer
Originally posted by: Fenixgoon
all your base are belong to materials engineers, suckas!:D
I work with a lot of material science engineers in semiconductor fabrication and device development. At some point, someone decided that they'd make good process engineers.

It's frustrating to me how little they understand. For example, one of them is currently attempting to design a process test structure. I spent ten minutes explaining the difference between "open" and "short" and then the difference between current and voltage. We ended with a lesson on the dynamics of how resistors work when put in series. I used analogies to "big pipes" and "little pipes" to get the point across.

I suppose I do feel like a "sucka" because I actually showed up to sceince class that day in junior high, and this MatSE apparently did not.

Yeah. :D

rofls.. that's pretty bad - any engineer should know very basic electronics theory (i do, but i suck hardcore at the rest of E&M):D

i'm focusing in on ceramics... cool stuff i tellz ya!:D:D