Why Biden is pulling the US -- and NATO -- out of Afghanistan

Page 37 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

sportage

Lifer
Feb 1, 2008
11,492
3,163
136
Note to the Taliban, be careful what you wish for....
Oddly enough there was a PBS Frontline special on Afghanistan (Leaving Afghanistan) back in July just before the American withdrawal. The Taliban now has other problems besides American, the Taliban's new enemy is Iran. Iran is moving into Afghanistan with an Iranian backed militia fighting force called the Fatemiyoun. The Fatemiyoun are being sent into Afghanistan in anticipation of a civil war.

This just goes to show you and should show American politicians that American involvement within this region and involvement within an Afghanistan civil war was never going to be successful. We have so many different groups, cultures, forces in play that if Biden had not got us out of the region we'd surely remain in Afghanistan for hundreds of years to come. It's like with the covid pandemic, if only everyone had worn masks and taken the vaccine we could have defeated covid in total by now. And with Biden removing us from Afghanistan and considering all the heat Biden is taking over this, we will never know the hundreds/thousands of American lives Joe Biden just saved.

If leaders and "that former" president had delivered real leadership to Americans from the start, then covid could be a thing of the past instead of an ongoing pain in the American ass. The same goes for Afghanistan. Biden has done the right thing and the future lives saved will never be known only because Biden has done the right thing. Joe Biden acted, and this was the best outcome possible. Period!
 
  • Like
Reactions: gothuevos

Ajay

Lifer
Jan 8, 2001
16,094
8,114
136
I got nothing. Official American obeisance before the House of Saud is self-defeating, stupid, and a source of great sorrow in the world.
Yeah, I'm always left wondering what they have on us, besides oil, large purchases of military hardware and allowing us to put Air Force bases there ;).
Oh, and some 70ish year-old pseudo alliance.
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
73,205
34,537
136
Yeah, I'm always left wondering what they have on us, besides oil, large purchases of military hardware and allowing us to put Air Force bases there ;).
Oh, and some 70ish year-old pseudo alliance.
Anyone who replaced the Sauds would also sell oil. The air bases were there to protect the Sauds' royal fannies. So the only interest we have there is a customer for weapons. The price was 9-11 and Saud funded global terrorism.
 

NWRMidnight

Diamond Member
Jun 18, 2001
3,610
3,111
136
The alternative might be described as a clean exit, without tens of thousands of foreign nationals (Americans included) trapped behind enemy lines.
Biden's bungle has pinned his Presidency on the kindness of the Taliban and whether they let people peacefully reach the airport.
These people who got "trapped" had months to prepare, as this they have known this was coming long before the election last November, and where ordered out in April of 2021.


Pretty tough for fucking the incompetent and senile Biden to pull out of Afghanistan when there's still @ 15,000 Americans that he left behind enemy lines. The collapse of the Democratic party has stunned everyone.

See above. These 15,000 people had months to prepare and get out.
 

Roger Wilco

Diamond Member
Mar 20, 2017
4,825
7,239
136
Last edited:

Kaido

Elite Member & Kitchen Overlord
Feb 14, 2004
51,858
7,368
136
Just awful:


The C-17 evacuated 640 people in on flight:


I don't know what the record is, but they did 670 people evacuating a typhoon in the Philippines. I can't believe that many people can fit on an airplane:

1629316989894.jpeg
 

Amol S.

Platinum Member
Mar 14, 2015
2,579
782
136
Looks like the terrorists are getting back to their old antiques and methods. According to world news reports in the past day the terrorists have done the following.

* Burnt down an amusement park. The terrorists claimed the amusement park contained elements that were against Islam.
* The terrorists claim they will allow female news anchors to work, as long as they follow the rules, however there are news reports of female news anchors being threatened over the phone and physically.
* The terrorists have taken one of the only three female governors in Afghanistan into custody. She was known to speak up against the terrorists and have even cheered on to women, men, and armed forces to pick up weapons and fight against the terrorists.
*The terrorists have once again started grossly killing women who did not wear burkas or went against the terrorists imposed rules.
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,082
136
We knew what would happen. Thats not the issue.
The issue is we couldnt prevent it. We couldnt fix that country because we dont have the ability. Party because over the last hundred years we've become incompetent at fixing major problems. Also because we dont understand foreign cultures very well. Its the main reason we lost Viet Nam.
 

gothuevos

Diamond Member
Jul 28, 2010
3,479
2,411
136
This is probably a dumb question...but is anyone else surprised that we had over 15k US citizens still over there? Like besides embassy staff (who were reported all out)...why are there so many Americans still over there?

THAT many contractors?
 

Amol S.

Platinum Member
Mar 14, 2015
2,579
782
136
This is probably a dumb question...but is anyone else surprised that we had over 15k US citizens still over there? Like besides embassy staff (who were reported all out)...why are there so many Americans still over there?

THAT many contractors?
There might have been a few who could have been vacationing.
 

Panino Manino

Golden Member
Jan 28, 2017
1,149
1,385
136
Note to the Taliban, be careful what you wish for....
Oddly enough there was a PBS Frontline special on Afghanistan (Leaving Afghanistan) back in July just before the American withdrawal. The Taliban now has other problems besides American, the Taliban's new enemy is Iran. Iran is moving into Afghanistan with an Iranian backed militia fighting force called the Fatemiyoun. The Fatemiyoun are being sent into Afghanistan in anticipation of a civil war.

I hope anyone is suggesting that this is a problem, that it's a "problem" that Iran is making preparations to defend itself from Taliban that is being set up as "the spear of the sunni" in the region with full support of Arabia, Pakistan, and of course, directly and indirectly, murrica.
 
Dec 10, 2005
29,210
14,597
136
The Taliban graciously thanks you US taxpayers for their blackhawk helicopters - and much much much more. These are 100% the US Military - not the Afghan's. You can show Biden how much you appreciate your tax dollars going to work.

What a COLLASSAL fuck up of epic proportions


View attachment 48998

View attachment 48999

View attachment 49000

I'm confused. Should we or should we not have supplied the Afghan army with supplies? Give them nothing - shows you have no faith and get blamed for precipitating a collapse. Give them stuff but then blow it up on the way out, same issue. Sounds like you just want to whine - all complaints, no solutions.

Also, Blackhawk helicopter, the latest and greatest tech of, let me check, the 70s and 80s. Doubt we were giving them helos with all the bells and whistles. And good luck to them when it comes to maintaining them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gothuevos and Zorba

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,169
47,393
136
Didn't realize the US operated a lot of Mi 17s lol. Our choppers suck in hot and high I guess.

Most of what I've seen so far is stuff that the US clearly supplied the Afghan forces. Good luck to the Taliban maintaining it without us parts and contractors.
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
88,073
55,604
136
The Taliban graciously thanks you US taxpayers for their blackhawk helicopters - and much much much more. These are 100% the US Military - not the Afghan's. You can show Biden how much you appreciate your tax dollars going to work.

What a COLLASSAL fuck up of epic proportions


View attachment 48998

View attachment 48999

View attachment 49000

Every post you make reeks with desperation for attention.

Also your own thread says you’re wrong. Lol.
 

Amol S.

Platinum Member
Mar 14, 2015
2,579
782
136
I'm confused. Should we or should we not have supplied the Afghan army with supplies? Give them nothing - shows you have no faith and get blamed for precipitating a collapse. Give them stuff but then blow it up on the way out, same issue. Sounds like you just want to whine - all complaints, no solutions.

Also, Blackhawk helicopter, the latest and greatest tech of, let me check, the 70s and 80s. Doubt we were giving them helos with all the bells and whistles. And good luck to them when it comes to maintaining them.
But then again ... the U.S military itself still uses military customized variants of the Boeing 707. Does our military face a money shortage?
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,169
47,393
136
Biden says troops will stay past the 31st if there are still Americans stuck. Expectation seems to be 50-60K SIV eligible Afghans to come out too.

The Taliban surely wants us gone before the 11th and there are other cards the US has to play. The nation is basically bankrupt and the Taliban can't access currency since the US ceased shipments, cut off the IMF money, and froze basically all the reserves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roger Wilco

Ajay

Lifer
Jan 8, 2001
16,094
8,114
136
Anyone who replaced the Sauds would also sell oil. The air bases were there to protect the Sauds' royal fannies. So the only interest we have there is a customer for weapons. The price was 9-11 and Saud funded global terrorism.
The deal with the house of Saud also gives us forward airbases in the Middle East. Kind of helpful. So what are you suggesting? Coup? I’m sure Russia and China would be happy to take our place.
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
73,205
34,537
136
The deal with the house of Saud also gives us forward airbases in the Middle East. Kind of helpful. So what are you suggesting? Coup? I’m sure Russia and China would be happy to take our place.
The planes are in SA to defend the House of Saud, not defend America. I'm suggesting that we exterminate the House of Saud, root and branch. We should have done it on 9-12 but W put his family connections ahead of our national security.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zinfamous

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,541
48,065
136
It's funny to hear those who have been dismissing the pandemic that's killed 637k Americans, now lose their minds over the ~10k still in Afghanistan. Taliban are letting Americans leave apparently. The USAF can move mountains when given orders to do so. They're upping the traffic bigtime and probably have contingency assets on standby in case Taliban decides to get froggy. I'm hopeful.

Trump had more Americans die in under a week during 2020's peaks. We were losing 3k Americans a day for awhile. A 9/11 everyday. That's a fuck up of epic proportions, and don't let a treasonous douchenozzle tell you different. Blaming Biden for the ANA's morale collapse and long entrenched corruption is pretty dumb, but then it's likely coming from people who said jack shit about the Afghan government being sidelined in negotiations. Magats are still trying to convince themselves this pullout would have worked out better under Cadet Bonespurs. They'd be back to not caring what our allies think, like with Syria, if Trump had done it.

But incel clowns are trying to act like they give a shit about American lives again, so more weak theater for the rest of us.
 

Ajay

Lifer
Jan 8, 2001
16,094
8,114
136
The planes are in SA to defend the House of Saud, not defend America. I'm suggesting that we exterminate the House of Saud, root and branch. We should have done it on 9-12 but W put his family connections ahead of our national security.
This is going to go nowhere and is in the wrong thread. I respect your opinion, but disagree.