IMO:
Libermain > Kerry
Leiberman > Bush
McCain > Bush
McCain > Leiberman (though not by much)
Leiberman was probably the only democrat I would have voted for this year. The only republican I would take over Leiberman would be McCain.
I am voting for Bush because I can see past his lack of charm and articulation that the Media loves to use to make him look stupid. I'm sorry but no matter who someone is, if they are president of the USA, its hard to call them stupid. He may not be the charmer Slick Willy was, or the strong speaker/leader like Reagan, and hes made some Yogi Berra like comments that dont make any sense, but by no means is he "stupid"
Hes strong on Defense, you can argue that hes not going about it the right way, and that his methods infringe on our liberties, but in reality you have to realize that terrorists were successfull due to the immense liberties, freedoms, and privacy enjoyed by anyone within our borders, US citizen or not. They used our own "loop holes" if you will, to execute 9/11, in my opinion, cutting off the ability to exploit our liberties for uses against us, is the only way to truly combat terrorism within our borders. You can have all the intelligence agencies money can buy, but they wont be able to stop every terrrosist attack if we hold liberties above security.
As for standing up for the American workers, Bush was the only president as far back as I can remember to actually do this, not just talk about it, putting the tarrif on imported steel saved thousands of jobs, it was hotly contested by the international community, but instead of being an appeaser to the UN pansies, he stood up for US steel workers, which took some courage, he kept the tarrifs until the threat of a trade war was nearly upon us, and finnaly repealed them, economists have said that even though the tarrifs no longer exist, the year or so that they were in place gave the US Steel industry a chance to get back on its feet, and when the tarrifs did recind, the Steel industry was much stronger and was able to compete with foreign steel companies. The democrats solution would have been to not piss off any other countries, let the US Steel industry crumble, then put all the steel workers on extended unemployment, increasing the burden on us all.
I have a few more issues I'd talk about now, but im gonna go drink some beers.