Who should win the heisman?

[b0mbrman]

Originally posted by: hdeck
reggie has had 4 games of under 100 yards rushing and 3 without a touchdown at all. his "break out" game came against a fresno state team that went on to lose to nevada. after 3 average performances, reggie has 1 great one and suddenly has unanimous 1st place heisman votes. after 7 solid-to-amazing performances, vince has 1 bad game and he loses everything. the logic doesn't make sense.

Quoting Bush's numbers almost implies you haven't watched him play

 

[hdeck]

Originally posted by: b0mbrman

Originally posted by: hdeck
reggie has had 4 games of under 100 yards rushing and 3 without a touchdown at all. his "break out" game came against a fresno state team that went on to lose to nevada. after 3 average performances, reggie has 1 great one and suddenly has unanimous 1st place heisman votes. after 7 solid-to-amazing performances, vince has 1 bad game and he loses everything. the logic doesn't make sense.

Quoting Bush's numbers almost implies you haven't watched him play

i've watched him play in every game that has been nationally televised. saying vince doesn't deserve the heisman implies none of you have watched him play all year long.

 

[b0mbrman]

Originally posted by: hdeck

Originally posted by: b0mbrman

Originally posted by: hdeck
reggie has had 4 games of under 100 yards rushing and 3 without a touchdown at all. his "break out" game came against a fresno state team that went on to lose to nevada. after 3 average performances, reggie has 1 great one and suddenly has unanimous 1st place heisman votes. after 7 solid-to-amazing performances, vince has 1 bad game and he loses everything. the logic doesn't make sense.

Quoting Bush's numbers almost implies you haven't watched him play

i've watched him play in every game that has been nationally televised. saying vince doesn't deserve the heisman implies none of you have watched him play all year long.

Nope, I live about an hour away so have probably seen every USC/UT game you have, to the number.

 

[monk3y]

Bush for sure...

 

[AgentEL]

Originally posted by: hdeck
without vince, texas would be no where near where they are today. 90% of vince's stats have come from the first 3 quarters of play since he hasn't played a down in the 4th quarter of all but 2 games this season. the entire texas morale is driven by vince.

I agree with this. But, that just makes Vince the MVP for Texas and not necessarily Heisman winner. Heisman is an individual award. Bush stands out on a team of many great players.

 

[ElFenix]

Originally posted by: hdeck

Originally posted by: dafatha00

Originally posted by: hdeck
vince SHOULD win the heisman. reggie WILL win the heisman.

Why's that?

without vince, texas would be no where near where they are today. 90% of vince's stats have come from the first 3 quarters of play since he hasn't played a down in the 4th quarter of all but 2 games this season. the entire texas morale is driven by vince.

reggie has had 4 games of under 100 yards rushing and 3 without a touchdown at all. his "break out" game came against a fresno state team that went on to lose to nevada. after 3 average performances, reggie has 1 great one and suddenly has unanimous 1st place heisman votes. after 7 solid-to-amazing performances, vince has 1 bad game and he loses everything. the logic doesn't make sense.

don't forget, they lost to LA tech too
vince has had more spectacular games than reggie has. it's as simple as that. vince had 1 mediocre game all season. reggie had several. i don't know how anyone can say that reggie is a better player than vince.

 

[yosuke188]

Originally posted by: kalster
Bush
/thread

 

[miniMUNCH]

The award goes to the best player in college football not the guy who was the "highest" MVP for his team. Reggie is the better player this year.

Reggie Averaged about 9.0 yards per carry this season and every team keys on Reggie when he's in the backfield...don't forget Reggie great game against ND.

And the bottom line...Reggie Bush is a video game. He is amazingly elusive and very fast. And he shares time with Lendale White...another back who will probably end up starting in the pro's.

Also, aside from OSU...Vince has not played against many solid defenses. He has a huge game against USC, which he'll need to for Texas to stand a chance, and that'll be his statement that he should've won.

 

[BrokenVisage]

Brady Jr.!

 

[kalster]

hope Reggie wins it tommorow, 3 heisman winners in 4 years, not bad