Flashy people and their status symbols. :roll:
Seriously, there's nice and then there's adequacy issues. Any pen over $100 better do something damn cool for me to consider it. Think about it, unless your friend is a prolific writer or collector this is just going to sit on (her?) desk and look shiny. Nothing else, nothing more, nothing but. If she's either of the former I recall my criticism, if not my lack of full comprehension.
But if you're dead set on one of those two, go for #1. Looks more sleek/modern IMO.