Which is smarter? Cat or Dog?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Miramonti

Lifer
Aug 26, 2000
28,653
100
106
Originally posted by: conjur
Cats can poop in a toilet, or at least in a litter box, saving the owner from having to walk their pet in bitter freezing temperatures!

a friends dog was trained to excrete in the tub when she was out.
 

XZeroII

Lifer
Jun 30, 2001
12,572
0
0
Originally posted by: werk
Originally posted by: sman789
you see the video of the cat on the bed then the owner scared it by moving his hands towards it quickly?

The cat turned around and jumped, smashing its head into the wall:p
haha...that's my favorite internet video of all time. :D

Link

HOLY POPUP ADs BATMAN! Dont' click that link to close that annoying little box! The video doesn't work right. It gets half way through, then freezes, then resumes about .5 seconds before the end.
 

conjur

No Lifer
Jun 7, 2001
58,686
3
0
Originally posted by: jjsole
Originally posted by: conjur
Cats can poop in a toilet, or at least in a litter box, saving the owner from having to walk their pet in bitter freezing temperatures!

a friends dog was trained to excrete in the tub when she was out.

Eeewwwwww!!
 

MacBaine

Banned
Aug 23, 2001
9,999
0
0
Originally posted by: WinkOsmosis
Originally posted by: conjur
Cats can poop in a toilet, or at least in a litter box, saving the owner from having to walk their pet in bitter freezing temperatures!

That has nothing to do with intelligence. It's training.

I would say dogs are smarter.

Looks like you just lost your case
 

Titan

Golden Member
Oct 15, 1999
1,819
0
0
It depends on how you define intelligence, really. And since you are comparing two species that do not communicate in a consistent way with us humans, how would you go about determining that intelligence? It can't be done (sceintifically). Unless you believe in size of brains, but craniology was dismissed over 100 years ago.

Also, animals are just like people (we are all mammals) some are smart, many are average, and some are stupid. But we can't really tell without careful observation of the creatures in their environment, not ours. Just because we can train a dog, doesn't mean a cat is dumber, it's not in it's natural environment. But from the human perspective, cats are cute playful things that do nothing other than poop in a box in your house. A dog is man's best friend.

All that being said, my dad has a dog that he does not treat like a dog, it is a member of the family. Total we have 3 dogs in our house and they all live like people, they sleep where they want, they go out when they want, say what they want, and they eat at the table with my dad, and we never try to subordinate them with dumb commands like sit or stay, we just take good care of them, and let the dogs be what they are, dogs. They are all smart in the sense that they pay attention to what people do, and the female watches my dad all the time, and she pays attention to our language, and reacts to many words. She always listens when you talk to her, she understands most of the time and behaves unless she is distracted with chasing a cat or something. But this is an atypical situation in most households, the dogs are truly treated as people. Which brings me to my final point, all dogs like to think they are people.

Dogs rule.
 

Sid59

Lifer
Sep 2, 2002
11,879
3
81
Originally posted by: NFS4
DOGS!!

You don't see "rescue cats" or "seeing eye cats." Cats are lazy fumbducks

lol.


i don't know which are smarter. Cats are more independent and crap in litter boxes. Dogs help blind people and rescue people.

im so torn.
 

NFS4

No Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
72,636
47
91
Originally posted by: tkotitan2
It depends on how you define intelligence, really. And since you are comparing two species that do not communicate in a consistent way with us humans, how would you go about determining that intelligence? It can't be done (sceintifically). Unless you believe in size of brains, but craniology was dismissed over 100 years ago.

Also, animals are just like people (we are all mammals) some are smart, many are average, and some are stupid. But we can't really tell without careful observation of the creatures in their environment, not ours. Just because we can train a dog, doesn't mean a cat is dumber, it's not in it's natural environment. But from the human perspective, cats are cute playful things that do nothing other than poop in a box in your house. A dog is man's best friend.

All that being said, my dad has a dog that he does not treat like a dog, it is a member of the family. Total we have 3 dogs in our house and they all live like people, they sleep where they want, they go out when they want, say what they want, and they eat at the table with my dad, and we never try to subordinate them with dumb commands like sit or stay, we just take good care of them, and let the dogs be what they are, dogs. They are all smart in the sense that they pay attention to what people do, and the female watches my dad all the time, and she pays attention to our language, and reacts to many words. She always listens when you talk to her, she understands most of the time and behaves unless she is distracted with chasing a cat or something. But this is an atypical situation in most households, the dogs are truly treated as people. Which brings me to my final point, all dogs like to think they are people.

Dogs rule.

Agreed.
 

Miramonti

Lifer
Aug 26, 2000
28,653
100
106
I can tell my dog to pee and she pees, poop and she poops. (provided she has it in her)

Try to train a cat that.
 

MacBaine

Banned
Aug 23, 2001
9,999
0
0
Originally posted by: jjsole
I can tell my dog to pee and she pees, poop and she poops. (provided she has it in her)

Try to train a cat that.

You can train a cat to use the toilet... I think you lose.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,036
47,128
136
Also cats catch and kill mice/rats.

I would really prefer the cat running around the house to do this rather than a dog.
 

NFS4

No Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
72,636
47
91
Originally posted by: K1052
Also cats catch and kill mice/rats.

I would really prefer the cat running around the house to do this rather than a dog.

LOL @ you for having rat/mice problems :)
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
I adore dogs but I have to say that cats are smarter.. I mean, have you ever noticed how cats really check out a situation before acting? Like if you tease them with a toy their eyes scan the toy and your movement and they try to predict your next action.. Dogs would just kinda jump around trying to get the item...Cats also poop in a box- that's pretty damn smart for an animal.. Dogs are amazing and are very loyal while most cats probably would walk away if they knew that they'd be better off in a different situation... I think that dogs may be easier to train BECAUSE they are not as smart..while you can train a dog a cat is probably just thinking "fuk that" while you try to train them...
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,036
47,128
136
Originally posted by: NFS4
Originally posted by: K1052
Also cats catch and kill mice/rats.

I would really prefer the cat running around the house to do this rather than a dog.

LOL @ you for having rat/mice problems :)

The best part is that once they catch it the cat will usually chew on it a little and let it go so they can continue the chase.:evil:
 

BlamoHammer

Platinum Member
Sep 21, 2002
2,259
0
0
Originally posted by: Toasthead
Jack Russell terriers are smarter than most people.

Agreed. I have two 15 week old puppies and they are fricking geniuses. Now if I can only affix laser beams to their heads..
 

Thraxen

Diamond Member
Dec 3, 2001
4,683
1
81
Does the fact that dogs can be trained make them smarter, or just not smart enough to think for themselves? Seems like a lot of people are penalizing cats for being more independant.