which is better - 478 P4 1.9@400mhz or Celeron 2.8@533mhz?

[dxpaap]

wondering which is the better CPU, both cost the same. The celeron has better specs but its not a P4 (to be installed in a Shuttle XPC SB6162 mini cube - with onboard video)

thanks

dave

 

[Cooler]

Celeron at that speed and FSB

 

[dexvx]

A 1.9 P4 is Willamette Core. The Celeron will blow it away in every imagineable benchmark.

 

[stevty2889]

Yep, the celeron@2.8 will beat the williamette with no trouble.

 

[n7]

Celeron will destroy that P4

 

[nomagic]

Originally posted by: n7
Celeron will destroy that P4

what the guy said

I have a question too. However, how is a Northwood P4 at 2.66 and 533 FSB (512 L2 Cache) compared to a Celeron D at same speed?

Since both of them have the same FSB, the only difference is the core. The celeron has prescott core with 256K L2 Cache.

Correct me if i am wrong. The Northwood P4 and the celeron Prescott are probably equivalent in terms of performance. Right?

 

[stevty2889]

Originally posted by: nomagic

Originally posted by: n7
Celeron will destroy that P4

what the guy said

I have a question too. However, how is a Northwood P4 at 2.66 and 533 FSB (512 L2 Cache) compared to a Celeron D at same speed?

Since both of them have the same FSB, the only difference is the core. The celeron has prescott core with 256K L2 Cache.

Correct me if i am wrong. The Northwood P4 and the celeron Prescott are probably equivalent in terms of performance. Right?

Northwood has a lower latency cache than prescott, so a northwood will be faster than a Celeron-D at the same speed. Actualy in a lot of things, the northwood is faster than a prescott P4 at lower clock speeds. My northwood @3.45ghz was faster at gaming, rendering, and MP3 encoding than my prescott @3.82ghz. The prescott was faster at video encoding, and rendering that took advantage of SSE3.

 

[dxpaap]

thx

 

[3chordcharlie]

Originally posted by: nomagic

Originally posted by: n7
Celeron will destroy that P4

what the guy said

I have a question too. However, how is a Northwood P4 at 2.66 and 533 FSB (512 L2 Cache) compared to a Celeron D at same speed?

Since both of them have the same FSB, the only difference is the core. The celeron has prescott core with 256K L2 Cache.

Correct me if i am wrong. The Northwood P4 and the celeron Prescott are probably equivalent in terms of performance. Right?

Northwood P4@533 will be considerably faster than prescott celeron@533.