Which game should I play? 2 choices, with poll

Which game should OCNewbie play?

  • No opinion/Other

  • Fallout: New Vegas

  • S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl (with complete mod)


Results are only viewable after voting.

OCNewbie

Diamond Member
Jul 18, 2000
7,596
25
81
Fallout: New Vegas

or

STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl (with complete mod, I guess)


I played Fallout 3 and absolutely loved the exploration side of things, and in general, very much enjoyed the game. It did get a little too easy once you got to level 20 (never played with any of the DLC), and I lost interest shortly after (BIG SPOILER)
your dad dies in that gas chamber
.

I've not played any of the Stalker series games.

Oh, if I do choose to go with FO:NV, should I start the game with all DLC, or no?
 
Last edited:

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,081
136
New Vegas. For the awesome.

Also, if you get all the DLC, keep in mind theres a glitch with Honest Hearts. If you pick up ED-E before doing the Honest Hearts region you cant do it.
Do Honest Hearts first and then if you feel like adding ED-E to your team and doing his quest, go ahead.

And if you wanna challenge yourself, take a low INT and dont take any feats that give bonuses to skills or bonus skill points per level. The game is MUCH harder with weak skills. Especially weapons.
 

IGemini

Platinum Member
Nov 5, 2010
2,472
2
81
I also say New Vegas, but I can't speak for the DLC.

I have played a fair amount of Chernobyl and a bit of Clear Sky, as well as finished FO3 and played a little of NV. STALKER is very linear (though not completely) and has a more depressing backdrop. The physics are phenomenal and it's geared for realism but I think it requires a bit more determination than Fallout. Definitely get the complete mod if you plan to play it.
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
I played FO:NV without DLC or mods, most of the DLC seems like side trips that don't add anything and might leave you overpowered, so if you replay RPGs you might want to save the DLC for a second play. Or just keep a bunch of saves at the right levels then use them later.

I asked about what levels to play the DLC at in another forum and got this response:

---
My revised estimate is Honest Hearts 10-15, Dead Money, 15-20, Old World Blues 20-25. As some have mentioned the enemy levels and equipment scale so you can do them at differing levels, but these are the best, imo, taking into consideration the non-scaling elements.

Honest Hearts you can only bring so much with you, and the ammo drops are kind of strange- you'll find a lot of .45 ammo there but other ammo types you will find less common. So bring a gun that you doesn't chew ammo too fast, or learn to love the .45 guns. HH is very heavy on tribal themes but it's also pretty bland- you don't really need any particular skills to finish this DLC, but it places emphasis on Survival, simply because healthpacks are fairly rare, but campfires and ingredients are everywhere. HH goes first not because the combat is particularly easy compared to the others, but because picking and hacking aren't major factors and there are only a few instances where you'll need a 100 skill.

Dead Money, your gear won't matter as you can't take it with you at all. You are essentially in a self-contained environment with a lot of traps, so Light Step is useful, and a lot of the enemies are essentially invulnerable but follow a simple patrol, so Sneak is handy. Healing is also somewhat limited, but there are some great recipes available that help out with this, so a decent Survival can help a lot. Since you can't come back, it pays to get your lockpicking and hacking within a few levels of 90 so that you can do the 100 skill checks with a book- if you finish and can't do that, you won't get another chance.

Old World Blues is (obviously) very science/medicine heavy, and while you will find an unusual amount of gear to pump those stats, you probably want to have at least 80 in science and 60 in medicine. You can bring anything you can carry with you, but you can't go back for more until you finish. Expect a lot of energy ammo and not much powder-based, but OWB also supplies you with some very effective energy weapons to combat the extensive enemy population. In my latest playthrough I showed up with my Gobi, dumped all my ammo, panicked for a little while, and then realized I was ok with the stuff I was getting along the way- but it helps to make sure you have a decent Energy Weapons skill.
---
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,081
136
Good Hand-To-Hand and Melee is helpful for Dead Money cuz you are unarmed for a bit and then poorly armed for much of it. Not an excess of ammo either, so dont plan on shooting everyone.
Having the health regen implant and dermal armor is also good cuz you got no armor and wont be able to heal much. Few stim-paks and the food isnt strong.
 

Maximilian

Lifer
Feb 8, 2004
12,604
15
81
Fallout new vegas, no contest. I never liked stalker much, seemed like too much of a chore and not enough fun. If you liked fallout 3 you will like new vegas :thumbsup:
 

JujuFish

Lifer
Feb 3, 2005
11,440
1,053
136
New Vegas is one of the few games I've played for more than 100 hours. Highly recommended.
 

JujuFish

Lifer
Feb 3, 2005
11,440
1,053
136
Also, if you get all the DLC, keep in mind theres a glitch with Honest Hearts. If you pick up ED-E before doing the Honest Hearts region you cant do it.
Do Honest Hearts first and then if you feel like adding ED-E to your team and doing his quest, go ahead.
ED-E was my first companion and I had no trouble with doing the Honest Hearts DLC.