<<
I've tried one Dunhill blend that I didn't particularly care for, I found it a bit harsh for my taste. >>
English tobaccos might not be for you then...although Dunhill blends are fairly well-known for being very harsh and seem to have more nicotine then a lot of other blends. Something from Davidoff or G.L. Pease might be nicer for you. Pease's blend called "Haddo's Delight" gets raved about almost daily on A.S.P. even by people who don't usually like latakia. It's very mild, I hear.
<<
I find Cherry Blend to be very good in the Meerschaum but that's not a regular smoking pipe and it loses a lot in the Grabow. >>
I've heard meerschaum pipes tend to bring out the casing flavors of aromatic tobaccos. I actually haven't gotten any! I need to go get one or thirty....
Why isn't it a regular smoker, though? The more you smoke them, the better color it turns

Although you shouldn't smoke any pipe more than once ever couple days...
<<
my second question after "what is a good, affordable, beginner pipe" would have been "what should I start with to smoke in it" >>
Aromatic blends are usually the way to start because they are lighter and less complex. Most beginner smokers think those English blends taste like sweatsocks and a lot of old-timers think so, too. It took me about a year to get started on English blends and I like them more and more. I doubly like them because after awhile I became almost desensitized to flavorings like cherry and rum, etc. Now, if I've been smoking an English blend and one day throw in some cherry, I can really taste the cherry because it's so different from the latakia in the English stuff.
Anyway, if you have access to a smoke shop, they usually have a lot of bulk tobaccos in jars. Go in and sniff at all the ones and grab a 1 or 2 ounces of a couple that smell good to you. Many shops will even let you light up a bowl on-the-house. I know the Little Taste of Cuba shops in New Hope and Princeton always welcome people to bring their pipes in and try anything they have out.
If you don't have access to a pipe shop....there's not a lot you can do except buy some smaller tins of things that sound good to you in descriptions and reviews and just hope you get something you like.
The Cherry Blend that speed01 smokes is available in most drug stores along with Captain Black and a few others. CVS actually has a store-brand line of tobaccos that isn't half-bad. These aren't the greatest tobaccos but they're pretty cheap and you can get a feel for a few different flavors.
And, of course, if you can get on usenet's alt.smokers.pipes, you could probably get a boatload of recommendations in just a couple posts.
<<
any recommendations among these blokes? >>
Hmmm...I can't tell for sure. It's kind of disturbing because the manufacturer's logo is typically on the side of the shank that faces you with the stem pointing to the right, which is also the side you typically photograph (See
here and here is a
closeup of how they're usually pictured).
So it's hard to say because we don't really know the brands or anything...almost makes you wonder if they don't want you to see the logo because you'd realize it's not worth as much as they're asking...
Also, if these are seconds or rejects of name brands, they may have puttied holes and other imperfections...they'd still smoke ok, but they wouldn't be worth as much. The ones for $19.99 and $24.95 are probably cheap enough that even if they are noname junkers, you'd still get a decent value. The Mexican one for $32 might also be good. When I was in Mexico I bought a no-name pipe from a local and it's very decent. I think I paid about $30 US for it.
Your best bet is always to find a smoke shop and really look over the pipes and find one that you like in your price range. They often have a "bargain basket" with seconds like I mentioned above that make great pipes to start out with. They're usually $20-$30 for anything in the basket. I've gotten some real nice pipes that way.