0roo0roo
No Lifer
Originally posted by: boomerang
Look, I'm not going to argue this point. But I'm going to take the risk of pissing you off (which I really don't want to do) and tell you that if you have no experience in a manufacturing environment, you have no idea how fast things can be done.Originally posted by: Modelworks
Originally posted by: boomerang
When I was a working man, I regularly moved around tooling that weighed as much as 140,000 lbs. Moving something weighing 1000 lbs is nothing. It truly is. It's all what you're used to. I can understand an individual who works in an office environment thinking it's waaay out there but it isn't by any means.Originally posted by: Modelworks
You guys talking about battery swaps at the station do realize they are not like changing a car battery now ? These things weigh 1000lbs + and take a forklift to move, they often take up several square feet. You are not just going to swap them out and be on your way.
You do it from the bottom of the car. You provide a means to index the battery to the vehicle which can also double as a means to index the tooling for changing the battery. The mechanism comes up from the bottom, indexes itself on the battery and unclamps it from the car. That battery is transported out of the way to a charging rack and the replacement battery moves into position. It is lifted into place, indexed and clamped. During the process, the bar code on the battery is read as well as the VIN of the vehicle for tracking purposes. A database is maintained to track the status of the battery.
Really, it's not a big deal at all.
You are dreaming if you think people will go for that.
There is no way that a change like that can be done quickly. There are too many safety concerns. You would have to put the vehicle on a lift, take out the old battery pack, place it somewhere so it can be recharged, then get a new one and place it in the vehicle, take the vehicle off the lift and do the paperwork, get paid.
That is at least 20 minutes or more to accomplish and that is if the person doing the work really rushes. People are not going to do that when they can fill up and go in a minute or two.
My example used a quick oil change model. The car is driven over an opening in the floor and the whole process is completed from below. Totally automated. It would take 3 minutes tops. With multiple bays, there would be no more wait than a wait at a typical gas station.
Battery storage and charging is all done in the basement of the facility. Just as the quick oil change stores their waste oil tanks, etc., there will be plenty of room for battery storage and the equipment to change and charge them.
Have you not seem automated equipment run in a manufacturing environment? On TV even? Things happen very quickly. This is as doable as it gets. Watch How It's Made sometime.
ugh..dooable? you are talking heavy duty automation, something far beyond a petrol station type technology. in military application perhaps. but for wide spread consumer use...thats just not economically feasible. you are talking a crew of people per station. right now you are lucky to have one person at a station, and they are only there to sell candy bars.