What's the big deal about Scientology?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Phoenix86

Lifer
May 21, 2003
14,644
10
81
Originally posted by: TGS
Kidnapping, brainwashing, people dying mysteriously in their "care". I don't think I've heard of mainstream religion doing anything like that since the Inquisition.
Search nunneries+slave.
Text

 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
Originally posted by: Nik

1. A religion or religious sect generally considered to be extremist or false, with its followers often living in an unconventional manner under the guidance of an authoritarian, charismatic leader.

Sounds like Apple fans.

iCult :laugh:
 

Phoenix86

Lifer
May 21, 2003
14,644
10
81
Originally posted by: Gurck
Originally posted by: 91TTZ
Originally posted by: Nik

1. A religion or religious sect generally considered to be extremist or false, with its followers often living in an unconventional manner under the guidance of an authoritarian, charismatic leader.

Sounds like Apple fans.

iLife:laugh:
Fixed

 

Pliablemoose

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
25,195
0
56
?I?d like to start a religion. That?s where the money is.?

- L. Ron Hubbard to Lloyd Eshbach, in 1949; quoted by Eshbach in OVER MY SHOULDER: REFLECTIONS ON A SCIENCE FICTION ERA, Donald M. Grant Publisher. 1983
 

TGS

Golden Member
May 3, 2005
1,849
0
0
Originally posted by: Phoenix86
Originally posted by: TGS
Kidnapping, brainwashing, people dying mysteriously in their "care". I don't think I've heard of mainstream religion doing anything like that since the Inquisition.
Search nunneries+slave.
Text


Again a hidden branch of people doing things by themselves. The church wasn't condoning those actions. It's like saying priests molesting children is doctrine.

Which is completely unlike, how Scientology forces you to sign away your rights to take legal action against them, for what they do to you.
 

Phoenix86

Lifer
May 21, 2003
14,644
10
81
Originally posted by: TGS
Originally posted by: Phoenix86
Originally posted by: TGS
Kidnapping, brainwashing, people dying mysteriously in their "care". I don't think I've heard of mainstream religion doing anything like that since the Inquisition.
Search nunneries+slave.
Text
Again a hidden branch of people doing things by themselves. The church wasn't condoning those actions. It's like saying priests molesting children is doctrine.

Which is completely unlike, how Scientology forces you to sign away your rights to take legal action against them, for what they do to you.
It was done by mainstream religion. Who said it was "hidden" did you bother searching? Who do you think funds nunneries? :confused:

Your original statement said nothing of it being doctrine, so I was just showing you that "Kidnapping, brainwashing, people dying mysteriously in their "care"." does indeed happen, fairly recently too.
 

cquark

Golden Member
Apr 4, 2004
1,741
0
0
Originally posted by: notfred
Originally posted by: Britboy
Originally posted by: notfred
It's no more ridiculous that Wicca or Islam or Christianity. Why does everyone make such a big deal out of this particular religion?

Your statement is ridiculous, you obviously have no knowledge of the subject or are just trying to rile people up.

What is so ridiculous about my statement? Scientologists hate phychiatrists? So, Christians hate gays.

Scientologists require you to pay to be a part of thier religion? Many Christian sects require you to tithe.

Scientologists beleive in aliens? Christians beleive in ghosts and evil spirits.

Scientologists sue people who badmouth thier religion? Christians blow each other up with car bombs because they can't find an agreement between Catholics and Protestants.

How is scientology so much worse exactly?

The beliefs of scientology are no more ridiculous than those of Christians, but the Church of Scientology is one of the most dangerous churches tolerated as a legitimate organization by the US (though many countries are sensible enough not to tolerate scientology any more than they'd tolerate the IRA.)
 

Turnpike

Senior member
Oct 30, 2003
222
0
0
Being a sociology major in undergrad I took a class about religions and why people join them etc. We learned alot about scientology. Sociology basically classifies religions into 3 main categores: a) maintstream, b) sects, and c) cults. A certain religion is categorized based on what society you are in. In the US Catholics/Protestant Christianity is the dominant religion so it falls under mainstream. Any religion of the same faith with more extreme values or seen as deviant falls under sect, ie Mormans/Adventists/Jahova Witnesses. A cult is any religion that doesn't adhere to the norm faith, these can include Scientology, Satanists, UFO people (ie Raelians), and even Islam, Buddhism, etc. Likewise in the middle east, Christianity is defined as a cult whereas Islam is mainstream. Religion itself is basically defined as a set of values/rules that offer explanations to answers that we do not know (ie creation of the universe, what happens when we die, etc) Anyways thats how religion and cult are related in terms of sociology.

Scientology was founded by Hubbard, who was a scifi writer that tried to make a big break into the world of psychology. He really really really wanted psychologists to accept his theories about whatever he made up. Of course the pyschology world flat out rejected and humilated him and he got upset and said screw it, and made his little religion. Someone posted a good summary of the beliefs ealier so I won't go into it much, but basically lets say you are afraid of heights. Well the reason you are afraid of heights might be because you fell off a bridge in a previous life, and this left a bad memory in your soul called an engram. Scientology has therapists that can hypnotize you and such to remove this engram (this all costs money of course) so you will no longer fear heights and that takes you one step closer to human perfection (Tom Cruise and John Travola have reached the stage of perfection btw). Scientology has big time money, and even bigger time attorneys. So it's usually pretty rare to see bad things about this religion in the media. Of course after this Tom Cruise stuff on TV who knows.
 

TGS

Golden Member
May 3, 2005
1,849
0
0
Originally posted by: Phoenix86
Originally posted by: TGS
Originally posted by: Phoenix86
Originally posted by: TGS
Kidnapping, brainwashing, people dying mysteriously in their "care". I don't think I've heard of mainstream religion doing anything like that since the Inquisition.
Search nunneries+slave.
Text
Again a hidden branch of people doing things by themselves. The church wasn't condoning those actions. It's like saying priests molesting children is doctrine.

Which is completely unlike, how Scientology forces you to sign away your rights to take legal action against them, for what they do to you.
It was done by mainstream religion. Who said it was "hidden" did you bother searching? Who do you think funds nunneries? :confused:

Your original statement said nothing of it being doctrine, so I was just showing you that "Kidnapping, brainwashing, people dying mysteriously in their "care"." does indeed happen, fairly recently too.

You will still have to show me Catholic doctrine that specifically states this was a Church Sanctioned process. The only thing that I'm pulling up on the subject is text covering over 100 years ago about people being shocked to see priests running operations like this.

To the modern era, people are shocked at what priests/religious members are doing right now. Though perhaps that could be said about a good portion of humanity on various topics.

Read here


Originally posted by: Turnpike
A cult is any religion that doesn't adhere to the norm faith, these can include Scientology, Satanists, UFO people (ie Raelians), and even Islam, Buddhism, etc. Likewise in the middle east, Christianity is defined as a cult whereas Islam is mainstream.

Ummm here
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Originally posted by: Nik
Originally posted by: Electric Amish
Originally posted by: Zysoclaplem
It's not a religion, it's a cult.

I don't believe there is a difference between those two words.


5 entries found for cult.
cult Audio pronunciation of "cult" ( P ) Pronunciation Key (klt)
n.


5.
1. Obsessive, especially faddish, devotion to or veneration for a person, principle, or thing.
2. The object of such devotion.

Noting this entry in the definition for "cult", I am reminded of all those thousands of people who flock to images of the Virgin Mary and/or the baby Jesus that they see in mundane things.
 

OrByte

Diamond Member
Jul 21, 2000
9,303
144
106
I wonder if there are any scientologists reading this. If so...

SPEAK UP!!!

lets hear the story!
 

LS20

Banned
Jan 22, 2002
5,858
0
0
there was this guy who was like Captain Planet, Silver Surfer, and Fantastic Four all rolled into 1--he had immense power... so much power he can do whatever he wants... so much power we cant even begin to fathom and understand him. He's so powerful that he can divide by Zero.

So, for reasons we dont know (cuz we cant understand him because hes powerful, remember) he created the world. Then he put together some dust and clay and created man. He decided to give the guy a wife... but instead of dust, he put the guy to sleep and pulled out a rib and created the girl from the rib. I suppose they were all naked and all, and even though being husband and wife, they werent supposed to be cognizant of their body parts or shamefullness or whatever.... until they eat the magical apple!

See Yahweh put an apple in their garden that had magical properties... all the other trees and fruits were normal... this tree was special and was the tree of knowledge and it bore special knowledge fruits. To tempt them into eating it, there was this snake there that KNEW HOW TO TALK. and boy was it a good talker, too... because it tricked the couple into eating the apple.

fast forward sometimes... to when people were living 'til 600 years of age and stuff. God decided that his playEarth was shtty and he watned to destroy it... of course he had all the power--powers that we cant imagine.. but instead of *poof*ing the earth away he flooded it. So he told his old 600 man to make a boat. i suppose he made it by himself.. a boat wide and grand enough to carry 2 of every species on the earth. god was a pretty powerful dude so he mustve created 9 billion species but lets digress. so this family was on the boat with all the animals and they survive the flood and then repopulate the earth






see... how is that any less credible of a story than Xenu and scientology ? dont forget to leave your tithe at the door
 

TGS

Golden Member
May 3, 2005
1,849
0
0
Originally posted by: LS20


see... how is that any less credible of a story than Xenu and scientology ? dont forget to leave your tithe at the door


Pretty much summed up on page one.
 

jonnyGURU

Moderator <BR> Power Supplies
Moderator
Oct 30, 1999
11,815
104
106
You guys just don't understand the HISTORY of psychology! Ritalin is a STREET DRUG! Brooke should've KILLED her baby and given us all our money in order to release some of her thetans! Damn you Xenu!!!! DAMN YOU!!!!

L Ron Hubbard.... Writes a book about how to live a better life.... then dies... Damn thetans.
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Originally posted by: jonnyGURU
L Ron Hubbard.... Writes a book about how to live a better life....

Have you ever actually tried to read Dianetics? It's utterly meaningless; you will read pages and have no idea what he's trying to say.
 

jonnyGURU

Moderator <BR> Power Supplies
Moderator
Oct 30, 1999
11,815
104
106
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
Originally posted by: jonnyGURU
L Ron Hubbard.... Writes a book about how to live a better life....

Have you ever actually tried to read Dianetics? It's utterly meaningless; you will read pages and have no idea what he's trying to say.


Hehehe.. I know.... perhaps that's why so many WHACK JOBS follow Scientology. Some people run from what they don't understand... while others embrace it.
 

Dean

Platinum Member
Oct 10, 1999
2,757
0
76
I remember when i was a kid, there was a Dianetics "store" down the road from me. I would walk by it every day on the way to the grocery store. I had no idea what Scientology was at the time and found it strange that they would setup an entire store dedicated to one book!
 

jonnyGURU

Moderator <BR> Power Supplies
Moderator
Oct 30, 1999
11,815
104
106
Originally posted by: Dean
I remember when i was a kid, there was a Dianetics "store" down the road from me. I would walk by it every day on the way to the grocery store. I had no idea what Scientology was at the time and found it strange that they would setup an entire store dedicated to one book!

Did they sell the inflatable aliens and the "make your own volcano" kits?
 

jonnyGURU

Moderator <BR> Power Supplies
Moderator
Oct 30, 1999
11,815
104
106
From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenu

A very funny, funny read. I literally laughed out loud. I'd EASILY believe in ANY other religion other than this one after reading this. This stuff makes the Bible read like a Refinancing Your Home For Dummies book.

My favorite part:

Funny stuff! A MUST READ!

Critics of Scientology have pointed out that there are many factual and scientific problems with the story of Xenu. There is no scientific evidence that the events Hubbard described ever took place, though in fairness Hubbard never did try to put a scientific gloss on the story. Peter Forde's paper A Scientific scrutiny of OT III analyses the matter in detail.

Hubbard did not elaborate on the number of space planes required to transport a population of some 13.5 trillion people. The Douglas DC-8, said to be an exact copy of Xenu's spaceships, seats a maximum of 250 people and has a payload of only around 40?50,000 kg, depending on the specific model. This means that only about 600 to 700 human-sized frozen bodies could have been transported with each trip. It would therefore have required around 54.1 billion trips with everyone seated or 274 million trips with frozen bodies packed more efficiently.

Assuming the Galactic citizens had bodies about the same mass as humans, 76×178 billion×2 ft³ per alien is 184 cubic miles (766 km³). This is about ten percent of the volume of the Chicxulub Crater, the site of the asteroid impact that is credited with having killed the dinosaurs. The frozen bodies would have had to have been stacked a mile (1.6 km) deep, covering an area more than six miles (10 km) across around 6 volcanos. Even assuming that they were all killed, their fossilised remains would certainly be visible in geological strata today. There is no sign of any such remains.

The energy required to blow up Xenu's victims would also have been colossal. Thousands of hydrogen bombs with a cumulative explosive force equivalent to gigatonnes of TNT would have been needed. This would certainly have left physical traces; Forde lists plausible craters as the Manson crater (35 km, dated at 73.8 million years ago), Eagle Butte (10 km) and Dumas (2 km, both 78?74 MYA).

Such a huge release of energy, more than during a full-scale nuclear war, would have wrecked the Earth's climate, causing a nuclear winter and prompting a mass extinction of terrestrial life. The hydrogen bombs would have left a residue of radioactive isotopes which would have been easily detectable today. It has been suggested that Hubbard meant to explain the extinction of the dinosaurs through the Xenu story but got the dates wrong ? 75 MYA as opposed to 65 MYA, when the Cretaceous-Tertiary extinction event occurred ? but this is unproven.

The Xenu mythos includes humanoid Galactic citizens living on Earth at the time; no traces whatsoever of human-style habitation 75 MYA has been noted, nor of mass extinctions.

The volcanoes that Hubbard mentions in the story (notably Las Palmas and Hawaii) did not exist at the time that the events of Incident II are said to have taken place. Forde goes into considerable detail on this point.

Finally, the earlier Incident I is set four quadrillion years ago, which is nearly 300,000 times the currently accepted age of the Universe of 13.7 billion years.

 

cHeeZeFacTory

Golden Member
Apr 23, 2001
1,658
0
0
this scientology religion thing would never have gotten this much publicity w/o tom cruise. The should make him the "pope" of scientology. He'll attract millions of young women around the world.

btw, i'm athiest